Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 1
Ship Stability
Ch. 5 Initial Longitudinal Stability
Spring 2016
Myung-Il Roh
Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering Seoul National University
Lecture Note of Naval Architectural Calculation
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 2
Contents
Ch. 1 Introduction to Ship Stability
Ch. 2 Review of Fluid Mechanics
Ch. 3 Transverse Stability Due to Cargo Movement
Ch. 4 Initial Transverse Stability
Ch. 5 Initial Longitudinal Stability
Ch. 6 Free Surface Effect
Ch. 7 Inclining Test
Ch. 8 Curves of Stability and Stability Criteria
Ch. 9 Numerical Integration Method in Naval Architecture
Ch. 10 Hydrostatic Values and Curves
Ch. 11 Static Equilibrium State after Flooding Due to Damage
Ch. 12 Deterministic Damage Stability
Ch. 13 Probabilistic Damage Stability
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 3
Ch. 5 Initial Longitudinal Stability
1. Longitudinal Stability
2. Longitudinal Stability in Case of Small Angle of Trim 3. Longitudinal Righting Moment Arm
4. Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) 5. Moment to Trim One Degree and Moment to Trim One Centimeter (MTC)
6. Example of Longitudinal Stability
1. Longitudinal Stability
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 5
L1
W1
F
GF
B GB
Static Equilibrium
Static Equilibrium
I
② Euler equation
When the buoyant force (FB)and the gravitational force(FG) are on one line, the total momentabout the transverse axis through any pointbecomes 0.
It does not matter where the axis of rotation is selected if the two forces are on one line.
for the ship to be in static equilibrium
0 ,( 0)
① Newton’s 2ndlaw
ma F
F
G F
Bfor the ship to be in static equilibrium
0 F ,( a 0)
G
F
B F
G: Center of mass of a ship FG: Gravitational force of a ship B: Center of buoyancy at initial position FB: Buoyant force acting on a ship I: Mass moment of inertia
: Angular velocity
: Moment m: Mass of a ship a: Acceleration of a ship
W1L1: Waterline at initial position
.
A P F P .
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 6
Longitudinal Stability - Stable Equilibrium
② Then, release the external moment by moving the weight to its original position.
③ Test whether it returns to its initial equilibrium position.
ZL: Intersection point of the vertical line to the waterline W2L2through the changed position of the center of buoyancy (B1) with the horizontal line parallel to the waterline W2L2through the center of mass of the ship (G)
Return to its initial equilibrium position
Stable
B1:Changed position of the center of buoyancy after the ship has been trimmed
P
A. F.P
FG
FB
B
e
W1L1: Waterline at initial position W2L2 : Waterline after trim
FG
FB
B1
① Produce an external trim moment by moving a weight in the longitudinal direction (e ).
W2
L2
ZL
G
A.P : after perpendicular, F.P : forward perpendicular
r
Longitudinal righting
moment (τr) GZLLongitudinal righting arm
L1
W1 G1
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 7
Reference Frames
FG
FB
B
e
FG
FB
B1
W2
L2
ZL
G
r
L1
W1
e
B1
r
B
G L1
W12 ZL L2
W
FB
FG
Rotation of the water plane fixed frame while the body (ship) fixed frame is fixed
Rotation of the body (ship) fixed frame with respect to the water plane fixed frame
Same in view of the Mechanics!!
FB
In this figure, the angle of inclination, , is negative, which means that the ship is trimmed by the stern.
,
O O x
z
Longitudinal Stability of a Ship - Stable Condition (1/3)
B
1z
x
F
G, z
, x
t TrimmomentF
BG
B
① Apply an external trim moment to the ship.
② Then release the external moment.
③ Test whether it returns to its initial equilibrium position.
stem
stern
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 9
Longitudinal Stability of a Ship - Stable Condition (2/3)
B B
1x
z
x z
, O O
t TrimmomentF
Br
B1 r
GResultant moment about y-axis through point O ( ): τ
eF
Gr
B1F
Bτ
e, ,
, ,
, ,
( )
( )
( )
G G z G G y
G G z G G x
G G y G G x
y F z F x F z F x F y F
i j k1 1
1 1
1 1
, ,
, ,
, ,
( )
( )
( )
B B z B B y
B B z B B x
B B y B B x
y F z F
x F z F
x F y F
i j k
, , ,
G G G
G x G y z
G
G
G x y z
F F F
i j k
r F
, ,
, ,
, ,
( )
( )
( )
G G z G G y
G G z G G x
G G y G G x
y F z F x F z F x F y F
i j k
, ,
( x FG G zz FG G x)
j1 , 1 ,
( xB FB z zB FB x)
j
, , ,
0 0
G x
G G y
G z
F F
F W
F
, , ,
0 0
B x
B B y
B z
F F F
F
1(
xG W xB)
j
1(
xG xB)
j (
xG xB1)
j
W IfF
Gr
G
G
In this figure, the angle of inclination, , is negative, which means that the ship is trimmed by the stern.
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 10
Longitudinal Stability of a Ship - Stable Condition (3/3)
B B
1x z
, O O
F
Br
B1F
GG
r
Gx
z
The moment arm induced by thebuoyant force and gravitational force is expressed by GZL, where ZLis the intersection point of the line of buoyant force() through the new position of the center of buoyancy(B1) with a transversely parallel line to a waterline through the center of the ship’s mass(G).
r
GZ
L
•Longitudinal Righting Moment
Stable!!
r
GResultant moment about y-axis through point O ( ): τ
eF
Gr
B1F
Bτ
eGZ
L j
( x
Gx
B1)
j
Z
Lx
GB1
x
, z
, x
r Restoring momentNaval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 11
Position and Orientation of a Ship
with Respect to the Water Plane Fixed and Body(Ship) Fixed Frame
Rotation of the water plane fixed frame while the body (ship) fixed frame is fixed Rotation of the body (ship) fixed framewhile the water plane fixed frame is fixed
Same in view of the Mechanics!!
B B
1x
z
x z
, O O
FB
FG
G
B
관계ID가 rId28인 이미 지 부분을 파일에서 찾 을 수 없습니다.
x
z
x z
, O O
FB
FG
G
Emerged volume
Submerged volume
The ship is rotated.
The water plane is rotated.
2. Longitudinal Stability
in Case of Small Angle of Trim
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 13
Assumptions for Small Angle of Trim
Assumptions
① Small angle of inclination
(3~5 for trim)② The submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same.
P
A. F.P
FG
FB
Emerged volume Submerged volume
e
W1L1: Waterline at initial position W2L2 : Waterline after trim
FG
FB
L1
W1
W2
L2 L G
Z
B B1
r
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 14
Longitudinal Metacenter (M L ) (1/3)
Longitudinal Metacenter (M
L)
The intersection pointofa vertical line through the center of buoyancy at a previous position(B) with a vertical line through the center of buoyancy at the present position(B1) after the ship has been trimmed.
P
A. F.P
FB
W1L1: Waterline at previous position W2L2 : Waterline after trim
FB
L1
W21
W
L2
1
M
LB B1
G
※ Metacenter “M” is valid for small angle of inclination.
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 15
P
A. F.P
FB
W2
L2
2
M
L3 G W
L3
MLremains at the same positionfor small angle of trim, up to about 3~5 degrees.
FB
As the ship is inclined with a small trim angle, Bmoves on the arc of circle whose center is at ML. The BMLis longitudinal metacentric radius.
B2B1B
The GMLis longitudinal metacentric height.
1
M
LLongitudinal Metacenter (M L ) (2/3)
P
A. F.P
3 G W
L3
FB
W4
L4
MLdoes not remain in the same positionfor large trim angles over 5 degrees.
FB
B3
B2B1B
Thus, the longitudinal metacenter, M
L, is only valid for a small trim angle.
3
M
L ML1,ML2Longitudinal Metacenter (M L ) (3/3)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 17
② The submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same.
Longitudinal Stability for a Box-Shaped Ship
① Apply an external trim moment (e ) which results in the ship to incline with a trim angle .
② For the submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same, the ship rotates about the transverse axis through the point O.
: Midship
P
A. F.P
FG
K FB
Emerged volume Submerged volume
e
r
W1L1: Waterline at initial position W2L2: Waterline after a small angle of trim
FG
FB
L1
W1
W2
L2
O B B1
G
Assumption
①A small trim angle(3~5)
About which point a box-shaped ship rotates, while the submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same?
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 18
Longitudinal Stability for a General Ship
What will happen if the hull form of a ship is not symmetric about the transverse (midship section) plane through point O?
The submerged volume and the emerged volume are not same!
Assumption
①A small angle of inclination(3~5 for trim)
② The submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same.
The hull form of a general ship is not symmetric about the transverse (midship section) plane.
P
A. F.P
FG
K FB
B
Emerged volume Submerged volume
FG
FB
B1
L1
W1
W2
L2
G
So, the draftmustbe adjustedto maintain same displacement.
O
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 19
The intersection of the initial waterline (W1L1) with the adjusted waterline (W3L3) is a point F, on which the submerged volumeand the emerged volumeare supposed to be the same.
So, the draftmustbe adjustedto maintain same displacement.
P
A. K F. P
B F
GF
BB
1L
1W
1G
W
3L
3Submerged volume
Emerged volume
W
2L
2F O
Expanded view
What we want to find out is the point F. How can we find the point F?
W1L1: Waterline at initial position W2L2 : Waterline after a small angle of trim W3L3 : Adjusted waterline
x
W
1x
Rotation Point (F)
= Emerged volume (vf) Submerged volume (va)
.
. ( tan ) ( tan )
F F P
A P y x dx F yx dx
. .
F F P
A Px y dx F x y dx
What does this equation mean?
( ) V x
( ) A x dx
tan x y
dx
L1
P F.
W1
W2
L2
P A.
K
F
tan
y xtan
( ) A x
tan x y
L
C
x
G
B1
B
Longitudinal Center of Floatation (LCF) (1/3)
: Longitudinal coordinate from the temporary origin F : Breadth of waterline W1L1at any position
F
OFrom now on, the adjusted waterline is indicated as W2L2.
W1L1: Waterline at initial position W2L2 : Adjusted waterline
x
x z
y
z
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 21 .
F A Px y dx
That means the point Flieson the transverse axis through the centroid of the water plane, called longitudinal center of floatation (LCF).
a f
v v .
. ( tan ) ( tan )
F F P
A Py x
dx F y x
dx
. .
F F P
A Px y dx F x y dx
Longitudinal moment of the after water plane area from Fabout the transverse axis (y’) through the point F
dx y
x dA
F x
y
. F A Px dA
Longitudinal moment of the forward water plane area from Fabout the transverse axis (y’) through the point F F P.
F x dA
FF P.x y dx Since these moments are equal and opposite, the longitudinal moment of the entire water plane area about the transverse axis through pointFis zero.
<Plan view of water plane>
Longitudinal Center of Floatation (LCF) (2/3)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 22
Therefore, for the ship to incline under the condition that the submerged volume and emerged volume are to be the same,
the ship rotates about the transverse axis through the longitudinal center of floatation(LCF).
F
Longitudinal Center of Floatation(LCF) L1P F.
W1
W2
L2
P A.
M
L
K
F
G B1B
Longitudinal Center of Floatation (LCF) (3/3)
L O Z
x
x z
y
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 23
3. Longitudinal Righting Moment Arm
B ML
Longitudinal Righting Moment Arm (GZ L )
: Vertical center of buoyancy at initial position : Longitudinal metacentric height
: Longitudinal metacentric radius : Vertical center of mass of the ship K
: Keel
GM
L KB BM
L KG
KB ≒ 51~52% draft Vertical center of mass of the ship How can you get the
value of the BML?
B1
F
BZL
F
G: Longitudinal Metacenter
F G
L B
GZ F
Longitudinal Righting Moment
From geometrical configuration
L L
sin
GZ GM
with assumption that MLremains at the same position within a small angle of trim (about 3~5)
x
x z
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 25
4. Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM L )
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 26
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (1/8)
Because the triangle gg'g1is similar with BB'B1 1
1
BB BB gg gg
1 1
BB v gg
The distance BB1equals to v 1
gg
B x
B z
B
B
, ,
( )
B v a v f
x
x x
( , ,)
B v a v f
z
z z
x'v,f, z'v,f: longitudinal and vertical distance of the emerged volume from F x'v,a, z'v,a: longitudinal and vertical distance of
the submerged volume from F B1: Changed position of the center of buoyancy
B: Center of buoyancy at initial position
: Displacement volume v: Submerged / Emerged volume
Let’s derive longitudinal metacentric radius BML when a ship is trimmed.
, g: Center of the emerged volume , g1: Center of the submerged volume
The center of buoyancy at initial position (B) moves parallel to gg1. L
M
B
1P F.
P A.
W2
L2
M
LB1
K
g
L1
W1
F
r
g
v f,z
,
z
v a,
x
v f ,x
v a1 1
1 1
BB B B gg g g
, ,
( ) ...(1)
B v a v f
x v x x
, ,
( ) ...(2)
B v a v f
z v z z
: Longitudinal translation of B to B1
: Vertical translation of B to B1
B B
1 O
g x
x z
y
F z
y
x
② The submerged volume and the emerged volume are to be the same.
Assumption
①A small trim angle(3~5)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 27
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (2/8)
tan 2
L B
BM
B2 L tan BM BB
2 2
BB BBB B
2
1 tan BB B B
1 tan
tan xB zB
, , , ,
1 ( ) ( ) tan
tan v a v f v a v f
v v
x x z z
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v a v f v a v f
L v x v x v
BM z v z
Find!
, ,
( ) ...(1)
B v a v f
x v x x
, ,
( ) ...(2)
B v a v f
z v z z
Substituting (1) and (2) into and
x
B z
B
B M
L
B
1 2B
B
P F.
P A.
W2
L2
ML
K
L1
W1 F
r
g v f,
z
,
xv f ,
xv a
B12
B B B
O
g g1
,
zv a
F z
y
x
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v f v a v f v a
L v x v x v
BM z v z
(A)
(A) : Momentof the emerged volume
about y’-z’ plane P F.
P A.
W2
L2
M
L
K
g
g
1 L1W1
r
g
v f,z
,
z
v a,
x
v f ,x
v ax
F
(B) (C) (D)
B21
B B B
,
v x
v f. ( )
F P F A x x dx
. 2
tan F P
F x y dx
. tan
F P
F x y x dx
y: Breadth of waterline W1L1 at any distance x from point F[m]
x
x z
y
F
tan
y xtan
( ) A x
tan x y
L
C
Derivation of Longitudinal
Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (3/8)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 29
x
x
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v f v a v f v a
L v x v x v
BM z v z
(A)
,
v x
v a. ( )
F A PA x x dx
2tan F.
A Px y dx
. tan
F
A Px y x dx
P F.
P A.
W2
L2
M
L
K
g
g
1 L1W1
r
g
v f,z
,
z
v a,
x
v f ,x
v ax
F
(B) (C) (D)
(B) : Momentof the submerged volume
about y’-z’ plane
tan
y x tan
( ) A x
y xtan
L F
CB21
B B B
z
y
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (4/8)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 30
x
x z
F
tan
y xtan
( ) A x
tan x y
,
v z
v f (C). ( )
F P F A x z dx
. tan tan
2
F P F
x y x dx
2 .
2tan 2
F P
F x y dx
: Momentof the emerged volume about x’-y’ plane
1 tan z2x
L
C
P F.
P A.
W2
L2
M
L
K
g
g
1 L1W1
r
g
v f,z
,
z
v a,
x
v f ,x
v aF
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v f v a v f v a
L v x v x v
BM z v z
(A) (B) (C) (D)
2
x
B1 B
B B y
Derivation of Longitudinal
Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (5/8)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 31
x
x z
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (6/8)
P F.
P A.
W2
L2
M
L
K
g
g
1 L1W1
r
g
v f,z
,
z
v a,
x
v f ,x
v aF
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v f v a v f v a
L v x v x v
BM z v z
(A) (B) (C) (D)
,
v z
v a. ( )
F A PA x z dx
. tan tan
2
F A P
x y x dx
2
2 .
tan 2
F
A P x y dx
(D) : Momentof the submerged volume
about x’-y’ plane
x
tan
y x tan
( ) A x
y xtan
L F
C1 tan z2x
B1
B B B2
y
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (7/8)
1 1 3
tan .tan
tan IL 2 IL
1 2
1 tan
2
L
BMLI
By substituting (A), (B), (C), and (D) into the BMLequation
,
v x v a tan
APF x2y dx (B),
v x v ftan
FFP x2y dx (A)(D) v z v a, tan2 2
2
F
APx y dx
(C) v z v f, tan2 2
2
FP
F x y dx
. 2 . 2
3
.
2 .
2
1 tan tan
tan 2
F P F F P F
F x y dx A Px y dx F x y dx A P x y dx
, , , ,
1 ( ) tan
tan v f v a v f v a
L v x v x v
BM z v z
(A) (B) (C) (D)
. 2 . 2
, L F P F
F A P
I
x y dx
x y dx IL: Moment of inertia of the entire water plane about transverse axis through its centroid F
2
2
. 2 2 . 2 2
. .
1 tan tan tan tan tan
tan 2 2
F P F F P F
F x y dx A P x y dx F x y dx A P x y dx
P F.
P A.
W2
L2
ML
K
g
g1 L1
W1 F
r
g v f,
z
,
zv a xv a, xv f,
B21
B B B
O
x
x z
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 33
Derivation of Longitudinal Metacentric Radius (BM
L) (8/8)
L L
BM I
which is generally known as BML.
1
21 tan 2
L
BML
I
Ifθis small, tan2θ θ2=0
The BMLdoes not considerthe change of center of buoyancyin vertical direction.
In order to distinguish between them, the two will be indicated as follows:
2 0
(1 1tan ) 2
L L
BM I
L L
BM I
(Consideringthe change of center of buoyancy in vertical direction)
(Without consideringthe change of center of buoyancy in vertical direction) P F.
P A.
W2
L2
ML
K
g
g1 L1
W1 F
r
g v f,
z
,
zv a
,
xv f ,
xv a
B21
B B B
O z
x
x
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 34
5. Moment to Trim One Degree and Moment to Trim One Centimeter
(MTC)
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 35
Moment to Heel One Degree
B
1M
eF
BDefinition
It is the moment of external forcesrequired to produce one degree heel.
Assumption
Small inclination where the metacenter is not changed (about 7~10)
When the ship is heeled and in static equilibrium,
B
sin
F GM
Moment to heel = Righting moment
Moment to heel one degree F GM
B sin1
r B F GZ
(at small angle )
Z
1
Substituting G: Center of mass
B: Center of buoyancy at initial position FG: Gravitational force of a ship FB: Buoyant force acting on a ship
B1: New position of center of buoyancy after the ship has been inclined Z : The intersection of vertical line through the center of buoyancy with the transversally parallel line to a waterline through center of mass M: The intersection point of a vertical line through the center of
buoyancy at initial position(B) with a vertical line through the new position of the center of buoyancy(B1) after the ship has been inclined transversally through a small angle
F
GLCF: Longitudinal center of floatation
ZL: Intersection point of the vertical line to the water surface through the changed center of buoyancy with the horizontal line parallel to the water surface through the center of mass
ML: Intersection point of the vertical line to the water surface through the center of buoyancy at previous position(B) with the vertical line to the water surface through the changed position of the center of buoyancy(B1) after the ship has been trimmed.
Moment to Trim One Degree
FG
G B τe
F
B1
F
BF
GM
LFB
Definition
It is the moment of external forces required to produce one degree trim.
Assumption
Small trim where the metacenter is not changed (about 3~5)
When the ship is trimmed and in static equilibrium,
B L
sin
F GM
Moment to trim = Righting moment
Moment to trim one degree F GM
B
L sin1
B L
F GZ
(at small angle )
1
Substituting τr
ZL
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 37
F
GG B τe
F B1
F
BB L sin1 F GM
Moment to trim one degree
M
LOften, we are more interested in the changes in draft produced by a trim moment than the changes in trim angle.
1
B L
100
BP
MTC F GM
L
MTC: Moment to trim 1 cm
sin tan
BP
t
L Trim (t): da– df,L
BP: Length between perpendiculars [m]
da: Draft after df: Draft forwardP P F.
A. LBP
L2
(Ifis small) 1
LBP
A.P F.P
t da
df
B.L F
LBP
Moment to Trim One Centimeter (MTC) (1/2)
1 t cm
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 38
Moment to Trim One Centimeter (MTC) (2/2)
1
B L 100 MTC F GM
LBP
L L
GM KB BM KG
As practical matter, KB and KG are usually so small compared to GM
Lthat BM
Lcan be substituted for GM
L.
1 1
100 100
B L B L
BP BP
MTC F GM F BM
L L
1 100
L BP
MTC I
L
100
L BP
I L
G B τe
F B1
F
BM
LIL: Moment of inertia of the water plane area about y’ axis B
,
F
L LBM I
Substituting
K 2
L
F
GP A.
1
LBP F.P
Naval Architectural Calculation, Spring 2016, Myung-Il Roh 39
6. Example of Longitudinal Stability
W1
L1
[Example] Calculation of Draft Change Due to Fuel Consumption (1/4)
During a voyage, a cargo ship uses up 320ton of consumable stores (H.F.O: Heavy Fuel Oil), located 88m forward of the midships.
Before the voyage, the forward draft marks at forward perpendicular recorded 5.46m, and the after marks at the after perpendicular, recorded 5.85m.
At the mean draft between forward and after perpendicular, the hydrostatic data show the ship to have LCF after of midship = 3m, Breadth = 10.47m, moment of inertia of the water plane area about transverse axis through point F = 6,469,478m
4, Cwp = 0.8.
Calculate the draft mark the readings at the end of the voyage, assuming that there is no change in water density (=1.0ton/m
3).
P P F.
A.
F
BP
195
L m
3m
88 m
Consumable
Stores 5.46m
5.85m