ºí} í} ¥ 5
½y%1åM¹õ~í:Õ¡Õ¡¹Õaý½:¥=¥}%¹b¹1ôMéE
Ý}~í:Õá1}¹õ:Õ>¡ÕM½%Ýùyb¹Aé¥ä½õv}EÕQÍõ v1%Ý11åM¹Aéõ~í:Õ¹:Õ>Õ%ibÙ}%!µÝíyb¹Aéõ 1aÕ¥UeÕyêy)EÕÝeÕv1%*Ñ1e¹½:Õ½á½]¥:©
½æa¥å~¹aEæaÕ¥e½ÕõFPÕÑÕõ*AÞFP\U¹E ó¡Á¥=½Eæa½áFPe½Y=-Ý¥I¹Må~½H[FHVV3E3EH[
î%õÙMå1õea¹íó¡s¥ÕÙ 1õ¡s¥ù!EÕM½3EH[
¹!µõæaÕ¹¹=:©QÍN1}v}vy*¹!µ¡Ý¹¹ÑÕõar1}
>}3EH[Õ]½:©vy¡É9:Õá½æy)Ùä½qI}EÝ}ÕM
½]õ:© rbÙvy1¹Õa½áæ}Õ:Õ>1MÉy饹Y
½EÕæa¹íp%í©v:e1íÝå~½] 2¡a 3'%¹õeÝ &¡
a 3'%¹õeÝù!E%í:e1í¹Ñ¡¥]¥Õ1"ab½Ai}
s¥¥¥¥YA¥1õáµ}s¥ù!õÑÕõ¥]¥ÕEÙ
e1¥Õ"ab½ÕѽeÕ)¥ùyb¹AéEÕ¡z¡]õ~í:Õ1}½æ
a¹µºbå¥Õ]ѹvy*!µÝõvÁyéõa¥}=½E :Õ:Õ>æa:¥=¥}3EH[©v:e1í
$%675$&7/LPHVWRQHFDYHVLQ.RUHDKDYHEHHQXQGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIPRQVRRQDOFOLPDWHKXPLGLQVXPPHU DQGGU\LQZLQWHUWKXVWKHVSHOHRWKHPVJURZLQJLQWKHVHFDYHVPD\UHIOHFWWKHVLPLODUFOLPDWLFYDULDWLRQV 0RQVRRQDOFOLPDWLFYDULDWLRQVFDQEHGHWHFWHGIURPWKHVRGDVWUDZLQWKH6HRSGRQJ&DYHZKLFKJUHZIRUILYH
\HDUV-XO\a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aDQG a 3'%UHVSHFWLYHO\&DUERQLVRWRSHFRQWHQWVDUHUHODWLYHO\PRUHGHSOHWHGIURPWRDQGWKLV ZDVSUREDEO\GXHWRWKHORZHUDPRXQWRISUHFLSLWDWLRQGXULQJWKLVLQWHUYDO2QWKHFRQWUDU\WKHSHULRGVRIKLJKHU SUHFLSLWDWLRQaVKRZPRUHHQULFKHG &YDOXHV7KLVUHVXOWVKRZVWKDWWKHJHRFKHPLFDOFRPSRVL WLRQVRIVRGDVWUDZVPD\EHXVHGDVDSRWHQWLDOSDOHRFOLPDWHSUR[\IRUPRQVRRQDOYDULDWLRQV
.H\ZRUGV6HRSGRQJ&DYHVSHOHRWKHPVRGDVWUDZ(DVW$VLDQPRQVRRQ3EH[VWDEOHLVRWRSH
-R.1DQG:RR.6'HSDUWPHQWRI*HRORJ\&ROOHJHRI1DWXUDO6FLHQFH.DQJZRQ1DWLRQDO8QLYHUVLW\
&KXQFKHRQ*DQJZRQGR.RUHD+RQJ*+/HH+0DQG6XN%&.RUHD2FHDQ5HVHDUFKDQG 'HYHORSPHQW,QVWLWXWH$QVDQ32%R[*\HRQJJLGR.RUHD
ý y¥eeÍb½}>}"Õ!]
Íýµ}a%bιaM½ ÕÕ}
Yù¹%!µÝi¹e½QÍaEò½å Ý1} q¶yA éE Õ1º åÝ1}õ
%!µ i1¥ybÙ A%¾¥ V1¹ õ QÍaMMA%=ñE
¥ÕÕIAéE Î
¹ ÕòUb¥Õ½QÍaMMºñE
1¹ÕÕIyÕ Ý
Ù yUb ùùÕ µå :Õ>
R¥Õ½"¹A%QÍõ ¥a%
yáíy¹ºñE1¹Õ}-ÕIAéE v1=Ù ý浡 va±
Õ"-Ù
ÕM½"¹A%=ñEr:Õ>¡
½]E%b½]|AéõA%=ñ
½} b½
" ¹1tíåM¹Ñ =aEEò¹ Eõ q¥aAéE q½:Õ>¡Ýå
%U¹v¶½Qå~¥y½Ñb A>
ºb µºb r]Õ ±a¹Eõq¥- E Ñ Ù
½]¹QÍ]1¹¹Õ :Õ>¡=òV* !µ¡
ar¹íayéõä½ }v%
ÝV1¹õÑé½ä
½ù!E
¡rÎ
¡ :Õ¹~}½áå~}í:e 1íå]=òV*¥a¥¹M =òV*Õ }v%ÝÑi¹õrõ½õÙÕÝA}©½u éE ùÝõ :¥=¥ }1v½b¥|A éÑ v1% %p}]%1åM¹õ:Õ
½á%]å¹:Õ>ÕEyUAy)
!½Õ¡z¡QÍabyé¥ä½i
"}E > Ù
eÎ Ù1}}½}QÍ]E¡:
Õ>ÕeÍbÙ%!µÝyb¹AéE õE¥UM])E YMù
¡:Õá1}vyAéõÕ~¥rõý
¹MY:e1í]ÝUA¹Õ}ÕEÕ¥*v
"=¹b¥|¹¥ä½Õ~¹aÑ :Õ>
¹:e1í]Ýv¶¹íÕ~¹eÕ}
õ:Õá¹% Õµ%íå¶ úy
R¹b µºbÑÕ¥ A ¹M UvÕ
ݽEA}©¹aE q½ õ
¡ >¹¥Õ!µ¹õN¹:Õ>
1a½%í:e1íÕ~¡]!N¹µåå
~1¹Õáþyéù aN1}¹Õ~
¡¥éåæ¹í ¥é¥b½ué E Ý} :Õ>¥A%QÍ1 UEv¶é b¹eÕ}õeabÙ½v}%v UÝÕÁ y éõ ½]¹:Õ>¥Õ½õ abÙQÍa ¥õ¹E
éÕM½QÍ1}õ%ibÙ!µÝå
~Áyé¥v%½ÁÕí¹õ:Õ>¥
¶U¹õäÕ ¥ybÝäÕE
ÕQÍ1}õv1%*ѹ:Õ1}½]
¥e ½æa¹µºb
å¥å~¹aE ¥Mæa¹µºbå Õe:©}%¹!µÝbiéyb
¹Aéõ1a½}¡YõÙ1aÕA¹ aE
:Õ¡ v1% *Ñ *® ] âe
: q :í½%
a 1e¹½E :Õ¡rá1}}
}ñQ~í:Õ½} ¥Õ%º%1UA y)E :Õ¡ÙV%¹reáå1e¹¹A éÑ ~Õõ Þ ÕE ]! v¡
]½Õ}A%Þ Ù¹¡%B½ ÕIéÑ :Õæ͹Õ}A%õ
Þ ÕE :ÕÕe¹½N1õ
A>aåm½ Õ%¥:©Ub}ä½õ vyõ ÑeÑvÕåM¹A éÑ Õ
¡]½µí*¹~íµ]v¹-½)Õ½
Íy éE vÍÙ :Õ á1õ E
ò½æ¹¹ :Õ>Õ vy éÑ ÕEr
æa æ~ ~} ~µRÕ¹í}M¹A
éE
æa¡áa¥éõÉa ò¹ :Õ>
½} ]e½èíÕ~Õ ÉeyÕ} v
}E ê:Õ¹ ýÕùÕ1 ý = eEM éõ:Õy ½áq
a1Ý Õ~1a½ Õ%a
¥A¹Ù^áå1}-òÕµ½ }é ÝùÕYáå¹ÕÕ~1aÕÁÕí ]Mµ"=1ÕÕÕ}Õ~ÕÉe¹õäÕE ÝybÙæa¹¡Þ v%½Ýv¹
- 1Ý}õæa¹
Õ Õ1Ý!µ¹%½E Õ QÍ1}õ
¥ 5á ¥ 5:Õ¹á1}
½ æa¥ å~¹aE Õæa
¡ÙVq¹æͽáÞ q1}v
y)Ñ ]ñ}æ~¹¾áå½á
¹aE ¥ 5Áv¥eÕæa
¹¾áå 1 ê¡ * êͽ ½=¹aA ¥ 51Y:© ½ÕÝv¹aE ¥e
½Õõ ½ E¥½î%½¹aE Aav½EÕYÁ¡*AÞ ÕE Õ M½ Á¡Î¹ :Õ>¡Á ÙÎ1}%
UA} ua 'õE ÁÙ ÁÕE
Õæa½á:Õy a õ y õ%i1Ý/¡
ÕÝUÕ-ÙÝÝaÞ ía
Ñ ÕÙ 1õѹ «¹E
:Õá¹ÑÕ¥¥U eÕæͽá=
- ¥I q ~ } q1} % % Ý v¹aE a¹v¡~
¡1Ù1E=¹aÑ Õ1%Õ õ }q1}:Õy¹y] Ýv¹aE ¥ I½æa¡Eá} Í!½å~eæ
a¹á1y ¥]æ¹MAµ=E æ
a¹YÑ]*µ!µÝEeY
¥Õ¹Ma¹aÑ å)ùÝ
ÝÕ¹Mæa ¹¥
v¹aE µºå~¥e½Y =-
Ý ¥I¹e¹M æa¥¡ ] 1 y²=}Ùá1úéõÕpÕb½
½Õ~¥}ѹaÑ Y=
]¥ùÕe ÝÕ¹M e½ Y=-Ý ¥I¹aE
)LJ$PDSVKRZLQJWKHORFDWLRQRI6HRSGRQJ&DYH
)LJ3ODQPDSDQGORQJLWXGLQDOVHFWLRQRI6HRSGRQJ&DYH0RQLWHULQJVWDWLRQVQXPEHUVRIWHPSHUDWXUHKXPLG
LW\S&2
DQGVDPSOLQJVWDWLRQV6ZRIFDYHGULSZDWHUDUHLQGLFDWHG
¥I}Y= -1aÕ å~]í p %í :e1í å~ ¥ E=¹aE å~¡
¡ 1}=}ö
]:ݹíêy)E æa¹ ¡ v¥eÕ Y=-ÝÕfuÕ
1ùe UAjÙ¹aE jÙ} =-õ ¹ 1í 1 a½ *v
1%MÁyé%¾½MeUa¹a E ] ¹î%Ýv¹eÕ
¡ ¹ q) ÝÙ
Õ Õy)E b =-õ Ýv½ =e:©
½vy)Ñ Õf B
¥ eÕ
¹EÖæ ] q)½a
YA ÕÕy)E q½bÖæ 1 a½ ¥õ ]Õ Ub
a¥Õ¹M%¹aE =-
¡a¹a%õ E ¹1 ñÂ
yUv ¡=깫¹
E
í p%í :e1í å~¥e Õ½Îi ]º 1QÍ 1aeY11} U ¹Aéõ©v: e1í
*å ~
a Õy)E å~ õ ÕÑ å~s¡ ½½¹aE Õ¡ É9 í1Ù1¥y} :Õy=-1 aÕ}%
í:e1í å~Õ ÕIÑ s¡
½ ½¹aE
æa¹å~]ÝE}%ñ-¡¥±¹
)LJ$/RFDWLRQRIFDYHHQWUDQFH%(QWUDQFHRI6HRSGRQJ&DYH1RWHWKDWWKHHQWUDQFHLVWKHDUWLILFLDOWXQQHO
&6SHOHRWKHPVLQ6HRSGRQJ&DYH'7KHVRGDVWUDZIRUWKLVVWXG\ZDVJURZLQJEHIRUHWKHVDPSOHZDVWDNHQ
eÕæaÕ½ ¥ 5á ¥ 5
¹"ñ- ÝÕ¹aE :ÕÕe
¹½*Ñ1õ"a¡aíae¹¹
«!½*Ñ]ÙrÕéõb5"a1}
v½%ñ-Ý% % vy*R½ùe å~¹aE
:Õ Õe¹½ v1% *Ñ¡ ½y%¹ rMá 1e¹ ¹AéÑ Må1 õAE¹ A 1 õaÕѽ :¥=¥}%¹b¹1 ôM éE Må Ù 5á 5 Õ1õQe~v y*¹ Þ a ryA éÑ =î¡â= *ò}á 1}Qr }v%a}>¹M Õ rÞ }a ùÝ 1 erbÙ b¥ a E "
b5 *Ñ N¹ 5*A%õ
¹õeÝUÕÑ ¥ 5á ¥ 5
¹e*A%õ Ýù!E QÍN¡
E¥:¥=¥}¹v½b¥ |¥ Må1õ
%aóA 1õ¡ò"¥EÝv¹íù
!E %õ ¥á ¥*A ݾ¹aÑ % !µ¡)a½Må1ó
¡%Ý 1¡%ÝUÕõò"¥E¥
yVb½ù!AéE vy*¡Qe~vy*
¹vy* 5%vy*%½¥±¹aE a ó¡~vy*¥¾½¥%õ ¥½
ÕA a ¡vy*¥ ¾½¥%õ ¥
¹ ÕE éEÙQ%¹vy
*ÕÞ Õ"¥¾½Ñ¥Õ ¥]
¥¡ÕUEÞ a¡vy*¥
¾½Õѽe½*aÁyéE ½y%1 õvyõaáå 5á 5¹ 1 ryõ ¥UÕ 1Õ =1a½vy
*¥¥±Õ U¹E ¹vy*¡ ¥1
½a¡vy*¥ ¾¹aõÑ ÕõQe
~vy*1}¡zÕ ¥ra¡vy*ÕE YMù ¥¹~vy*¡aó¡
ä½¾y)ù ¹vy*1}õ ¥
¥YA ¥1¥Õ ¡vy*¥ù!
õ$¥UÙE ¥e¹5%vy*¡ebÙ
1} ¥qí¹õ¥ ¥á
)LJ'LPHQVLRQRIWKHVRGDVWUDZLQWKLVVWXG\
¥õ þa¹õ ¥ UMaE
:ÕæaÕ¹¹ e1õ ±¡¹a
= =î¹b¥|¡uéõÑ ¥1¾ }ó¡vq ¡ 5¹=î I 1¹
½¾ÕE ¹- ¥ 5½y%1
¾bÙvÝÝ =î EY õY
½a½y% á¡:Õ©N½}½y½ y%b}N1õ I 1¥ÕÑb¥Y¹
¹aE ¡ea
)LJ7KHDPRXQWRIDQQXDOSUHFLSLWDWLRQIURP-XO\WR-XO\DQGFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
3E
H[DFWLYLW\FRQFHQ WUDWLRQVRIWKHVRGDVWUDZ
7DEOH7KHDPRXQWRISUHFLSLWDWLRQIURPWR
$QQXDOSUHFLSLWDWLRQPP 7KHDPRXQWRISUHFLSLWDWLRQIURP -XO\WR2FWREHUPP
ÕQÍ1}å~½æaÕ¹¹=1õ YÁ1aÕm¦¹¹a1:Õ á1a½ )"¥E=¹«¹ù =-
¥IÕ%æaÕ ½ ¹¥ m¦¹eÕ Ý¥e )"¥E=¹aE :Õ¹Må
%õÙá 1}=-¥Iq
¹õeÝù!)Ñ %
õ ¹ õeÝ UÙE Må1õ :Õæͽáá½iy¾%a ¥Ñ 1õó¥õ¥UÙE =-¥I q1}¹ %õ Må] 1 bb ¡
½}Qr!µaѹ')Ñ Õõ
½ù!ý:ÕÙá¹Q*A%¡¥±¹Õ Õ¹¹ ÕÝUÕõѹ ½%ÕE %õ Må1 Ýù!)Ñ 1õ
¹õeÝù!)E Må1õ:
ÕÙá¡á¹%aÑ!µÝUÕ«ù 1õÙá1¥Õá¹ %aeaé óí
vy)E =-¥Iq1}õMå]
¹%abb ¡ ½¹íù!
E Õ¡zÕ=-¥I q1}%i] a%'Õ
%p%aÝv¹íù!ùõä¡ Õ QÍ1}
å~½æaÕ©vbÙ:Õ¹1}¹a
¥=½E :Õ¹ebÙ %¡%!µ õv1%Ý11 åM¹Aéõ EÙ ~í:Õ¹
%!µ¡½$¥ UMaE >
:Õ Ùá1}¹ Õµ%í嶡 Må 1õ ¹õeÝUaÑ 1
õ ¹õeÝù!)E
¹- ¹vs¡½q1}¹s¥}Ù¹ Õ ¹â¡õeÝUÙE :ÕÙá
¹Õµ%í嶡 ½
Må] 1ѹ½s¥ù!yÕ =-
¥Iq1}¹]õMå1
1 ½ý½ÕÝù!)E êÕµ
%í嶡vy*Õó¡¡vy*Õb¡Õ
1ÝÑÕÝ UÙE Må¹ Õµ%íå¶
¡Ùá1}=-¥Iqqb½ó¥
7DEOH$LUWHPSHUDWXUHKXPLGLW\DQGS&2
LQ6HRSGRQJ&DYH
VWDWLRQ 7HPSHUDWXUH +XPLGLW\ S&2
SSPE\YROXPH
õ¥ UM]- 1õ Ùá¡Ñ¹½ s¥ UMaE v%¹ Õõéù ÕM
½Õµ%í嶹!µ¡v1%1åM¹ õEÙ:Õ1}%UA}uéE >Ù
:Õy¹í:e1íå~¡ 1%:Õy a õ±q ¥v¹M~
¡1Ù1bbMå] 1ÕIE
:Õy1a½í:e1ís¡ ¹ s¥UÕÑ ¹sÕÕ1¥Õ v
%Ai}s¥ UM]ù Õõ å~ õeÝA ÁY½Õ½>b}E =-¥I q] Ùr½ q 1} ¥y½ :Õy¹í:
e1ís¡±¡ å~½ Må1õ ± ¥ ù!)Ñ 1õ ¥ ù!)E
ÕQÍ1}å~½æa¡ ]ñ}æ~¹¾ áå½á¹aE æa¹¡eb
½"áUE¹á1}µò¡¥UÕÑ æ~áå½áæa¹"á1ÕÕ
É"¹vEÕ½Õ¥ÏAéE éæa
"á¹Ùá½Õ1}%}¹íúéõÉ"
¹Õ~vÕay%½E :Õæa1 }õáa¥ éõ áå]ùÁ Z=á
Õ~vÕáÝ¥Õ}¹õáåÕÉ 9a}E
æa¹p Ùá v=õEÙ:Õ1}
ù!ùõÝybÙæa]õEÙ$¥UÙE êÝybÙæa¡a½Õ Ý
¹Ñáõ¥ éù :Õæ
a¹¡ ¥±bt¡õ
e1}é=º¹í!µ¹AéÑ áaÕ~ v1¹Õ¥-é õv=ÝUÕ
% ½E æ a¹ Õ eyb ½ é=º¹ í !¹
õ ¹- qõ
¹¥±bÝv½õeÝù!Ñ q
7DEOH+\GURJHQDQG2[\JHQLVRWRSHFRPSRVLWLRQVRIFDYHGULSZDWHULQ6HRGRQJ&DYH 6WDWLRQ1XPEHU
2 602: ' 602:
6Z
6Z
)LJ9DULDWLRQVRIWHPSHUDWXUH$KXPLGLW\%DQG
SDUWLDOSUHVVXUHRI&2
&LQ6HRSGRQJ&DYH
õ ½Õqqí
¹õ¥UMaE q½ æa¹¾á
åÙ õ ½¥±b
½¥ UM]AéE
:Õæa1½=½ê¡*)E ¹
!µÝa½] qõå®*¥
ù!ùÑ Õ% qõ)E¹µbÕ
ѹ ù!ù«õE ¡
qÕ1}õ }¹æ½ê¡*Õay Ñ é ¹ ê¡ * Õa æ¹íù!
ýE )*½ q1}õ)E¹µ bÕay«Ñ q1}õå®
*¥ù!E Õ¡zÕ:Õæa1½=½ )E¹ *Õ Íe%½ÕÝù!õ䡹ὠÕ:¹õ)Eå¹òÕ=)EMñ¥µ=
½E ÕM½]Ý v*b½ *a¹õä¡
ù )áå1"ab½µÙrÕéõæ
a"á¹*ÕÑ*å®*¥UÕõÑyÕ
¡ qÕ1}ê¡*Õù!
ùõä¡ÕáåÕÁZ=:ÕyaÁÕí Vjy)¥ =¹õä½qI}E
:Õæa¹ î%
Ýå~¹MY]Ý 1}=¹ aE 1}=}ä]zÕæa¹
î%õ ¹E
t¡ õeÝUÕÑ ÕM½s¡
¡ 1¹Õ}=}:Õ>
¹ ½:%1 ¥ÕE ó¡sÕE Õ¡z¡ å~ ]Ýæa¹Õ1 a
½Yùe½%=¹aE Y1}Uõu
¡zÕ Yùe1õ ~ }¹ ¥e½vq ] }¹yvq YA }¹I Õ ù!ùÑ vqE¡=-é éqí¹õ
¥ =-é éõþa¹õõÝUMa E bvqEr=-é é] é1ÕZ¹õv qÕa¡ î%ÝUÕÑ ya
½=-é é] é¡aó¡s¥UMaE q½ é1ÕZyõ vq¡]!¹vq1 ¥Õ ó
¡vq¥ù!E î%Yùe1}
ù!ùõ qEÙ$¡Yùe¹v=ÝEyé
E ê I]IÕÝÝ¥:©¹¾¥UÕõ¹ ù¹B ½ UÕ vq¹rMÕ B1}
Î" ݽ ¹1é¥UM aE
¥MbB¹ ÙáåÕµ½¥
Ý ÝUE µ ¥-½ Ý UÙE ÕM½ B¹v=õ:ÕæaÕ¹õ:
©E¥eyá:©1õ ¹VjÕj¹í þay)A %yá½aÕ} YòÕ qqí¹a
¥ù!E
:Õæa¹í¡%í:e1íå~]
õ 1éE í:e1ís¡
¹¥±bâ¡õeÝUÕõyÕ %í:e1í s¡ ½ "ab½ t¡ õeÝUÙE æa¹ í:e1í Ñ¡ áåb½ áµ
yÑù Ai }ä½UÕ
%¹ù eb½æa¹1Ýý
½!µ'ÕÝv½s¥¹AéE q½:Õy¡æa¹í:e1íÑ ±v 7DEOH9DULDWLRQRIWKHVRGDVWUDZGLDPHWHULQWKLVVWXG\
ZLWKJURZWK
*URZWK/HQJWKFP 'LDPHWHUPP ROGHVW
\RXQJHVW
)LJ9DULDWLRQVRIWKHGLDPHWHURIWKHVRGDVWUDZZLWKJURZWK
7DEOH([FHVV
3EDFWLYLW\FRQFHQWUDWLRQVRIWKHVRGDVWUDZLQWKLVVWXG\
6DPSOH
QR &RXQWLQJ7LPH
/LYH 7RWDO&RXQW &RXQWLQJUDWH FSP )DFWRU
GSPFSP 6DPSOHZW J
3E
H[GSPJ
3E
H[%TJ
y*] a} ]Ý ù!«¹E e M MQÍÝÕ u½õ:Õ>¹í:
e1íÑ¡vy :Õy ¹ í:e1íÑ
:Õ¹ Ùá % :ºb å%òR1b
¥|õä½ éù
Õ¡zÕÝv½í:e1íÑ¡æaÕ
¹õ:©ÕM½ÑÕEÕѹ!µ¹«¹
¥ µ=½E í:e1í ѹ !µ¡õM
%í:e1íÑ¡ Þ ¹ ÕÝUÕÕ}
áµ} Íe]Ai} ÍeÕ涹íÍå}E q
½ ÕM½±Íe1}%¥±b=ºb½ù
!ùõ !µÝUÕ% ½E
õ:Õ>¥ÕIõÕ~Õ :e1íb½*v"=1}Ée¹«AÁÙ
ò1¹Õ:ºbå%ò¥|¥
í¡%í:e1íõ ½!µÝUÕõ :
=1*vÑÕ1}Éeyõ:e1ísUEµá µ}s¥ù!õä½}©½uéE ¹- ÕQÍ1} å~}æa¹ 1õí p%í :e1íѹ!µabb&Ùä½ù!
E q½ÕQÍ1}å~}:Õæa
¹ ÕæaÕv}q¹%¡:Õy
¹ í:e1í Ñ¥ Aé!½
1¹Õ]>¥Õ¹M*
v"=1} b½Ée}æa¹ í:e
1íÑ¥ %Á y éE
M} ÕÑ
æaÕ½qá]1}v½:Õy¹
í:e1íÑ¡ %õ
Ýb¹aE %]*v"=1}
Ée}Õ~¹í:e1íÑ¡
¹õeÝù!)Ñ æa¥å~½í :e1íÑÕ ¹õeÝUÕõä¥
q©¹ÕÕõ:Õæa¥ÕIõÕ~Õ í:e1í1aÕ*vÑÕ¹1}Éey)¥
ù!E
͹ ar1õEò½æ¹¹ ÖæE
ÕÕ½E ÕEr ¡]V
¹aíæ1¹Õ>yÑ
¡½¹ý1¹ Õ õÖE91 ¹Õ >}ä
½ éE ÕM½
a¹ÖæEré½"=Ù
)LJ3ORWRIFDUERQDQGR[\JHQLVRWRSHFRPSRVLWLRQV1RWHWKDWFDUERQVWDEOHLVRWRSHYDOXHVDUHPRUHGHSOHWHG
GXULQJWKHDULGLQWHUYDO
yq Ý ¡½1}ar½ý}%
ö1¹Õ yq ¥ ¥>½ E ÝIar1}>} ¡ÁÕí1½ Ù æñ¡ ʹõ ¥ UÕÑ
Õ>ú¹ qõ
>ú¹ 1¹ÕE=½1Ub}
E ÕM½Ñ:¥UÕõ ¡eEò½ åÝ1}ñQõbñ ½}E
¹í by µE
½]1%MM¹1}¹UbQÍ a
I¹Õ: 1½Ù¹¹=e Õò¹æñ}
¹R¥e½õbñ½Õ}uéE
q½ õÕò %]Ub¹ Qå~
eÕÕy%¹aE
Õ¡zÕ!åÝ1}õ ¥ ñQõbñ
¡Qå~¹%ͽ}Eò¹íÕÕä]õ M :Õ>¥Õ½A%QÍåÝ1}õ Qå~¥ eÕ}- }½b½ y µE
¹- ¡
¥ Mɽ a å Õ :Õ á½vy¡É9rb½æ yé¥
ä½õv½uéÑ ½]1
¡ar¹ÊåÕ:Õ>1MÉ yé
¥UA½uéE êÕM½QÍ]õ:Õæ
a¹ å~]avy*]a å¹õ bñ½ Õy 饵=½E
:Õæa½áå~½ î
%¹!µõE]z¡èa$1}5%v y*¹!µ¡E¹E ; Yùe1ù!ývq]I¹ya5%vy*1ù
!ýä]ݹ½E ¹; vq]I¹óÕ¹!
µavy*¹!µ¡Ý¹½E ¬; }¹ vqré;vqÕ]!¹vq1¥Õeaé ó¡ä¡ ¥¹vy*ÕE/Eõq]Ý
¹½E E; 1}q½½=}ä]z ÕebÙvy*¹!µ ] }½Ý¹½E Õ
¡z¡E¡æa1}å~} Õ NbÙvy*¹!µÝ¥±bv¶¹íyb¹A
é¥=¹Ñ ÕõH ¹!µÝÕ½Q
Õ~ÕÕI y é¥ ¹Y½E
õ:Õ>1a½ bÙ Vj1½} :Õy1 Ú¥ éõ ] :Õ a r1} ö½ >}
¥}=¹aÑ Õr%ñ¹:Õò
¹ Õ:Õ>1¥ÕE
!½ÕE¹Mõ=ÁyéEA¹aE Ý }:Õ>¹ ¡:ÕáUEõÙá1 }1}ä½>bÁyéÑ a¡ò 1 Õ¹õ ] Õ ]}b¥ Y½ä½ õv}E M} a r¹ ¡Y 1Õ ½1 é!½a¹í"á½Ýiy¾YòÕq
qí¹Ñ
ya½ò1}õar½áE=
Ubyõ 1¹Õ½Õ1}aóA¹á½ iy¾qí¹õ ¥ UÙE
Ý} ¡ r bÙvya}>yõ:©¸]É9½1 }¹½æyé¥äÕÑ ÕM½EE¥
A Á :Õ æa¹]õa¡ò¹ ] Õ:©vy¡É9:Õá½
æyæa1MÉy)¥yb¹õä½ UÙE
q½:Õæa¹]a EÙ:Õ¹ :Õ>
1}å~½ î%1¥ÕEó
íù!ýä
]eò 1} å~} ½:%a Íí Eõ ä
¡ :
Õ æa¹ Õò¹ ¡ UEõ ]½a1¹ÕVjy)¥µ=¹õä½q I}E YM!½ :Õæa¹ å~ ]õa
r1} ]¹íÑ:¹õå¥ÕÁy éEÕ :Õ> Õ] Ña å¹ =ñ½} Õ
y éõa ¥ }=½E
:Õ>¹%í:e1íÑ¡]½:ÕÕ e¹½N¹>> >¹¥
pY}Mv
% YA:Õy½á
yõÕµ%í¹ò
1¹ÕÑiyõä½Õ~yµE YM ù:Õ¹ ]!¹¡ýyN ¥eñQ¹¥
Ya½ ¹Aé)Ñ é æaÕ½ e1õý½>>¹!µaay«¹!
½eñ¹ Õ~ÕbyõE q½Õµ%
íò¹ :Õyaæa¹¾ 1 ùEM é¥y¾Õµ%ía y éõ = e¡A%í:e1íõqáµäÕE
¹-:Õæa¹%í:e1íaáµ }áåÕ ±vy*Õ"ab½ó¹¹=1 ÕZ¹Ñ Õ =1õ:Õya"ab
½µÉ ¥ä½>bÁyéE Ý }:Õæa¹%í:e1íå~]1}ù
!ý !µõ Õ¡z¡ õÙE½ æ¹õE ]
õ:Õ>¹%í:e1í1b¥YÁyé õEÙõÙE½:Õy¹þ}òÕùÁÙ
¹ò :e1í¹:ºb å%ò Õ
~Ée R¥}©½u
éE Ýyb½æa¡ ¹ò1¹Õ
¹õä½ éE Ý} þ}ò1¹
½:ºbÙå%ò¹]½%í:e1í
åÕ!µéEAUõ E q½ ¹ÁÙ
ò1¹Õ:Õæa¹%í:e1í
åÕ!µéEAÁy%'E YÕõæaÕ ÁÙ ò1¹½:ºbå%ò½ í:e1í Ñ] %í:e1íÑÕ :ݽ
!µÝ UÝä½i"y- :
Õ¹]õ Õ¡õM}½&bÙ !µ ò"¥
UÕÕE q½:Õy¹þ}ò]
Õ~Ée1b¥|¥%í:e1íaáµ yõÑÕ¡:Õya"ab½µñíVjy õÑÕÝäÕE
YMù:Õ¹]õvy*
Õ"ab½µ/¡=1%í:e1íaáµ }ä½ù!ù!½Õ¡áÊy «õE
Ý}:Õæa½áå~}%í:e 1íѹ !µõÕE]õ EÙ õÙ1¹Õ}>
}ä½>b}E 1¹¹Õa EyaN¹:Õ>Õ Õ"¹%í:
e1ís¥ UÕÑ ÕM½s¡aN1åM¹ õ >¥A ¹M%}sUEeaéó¡
äÕE YE¡Õ¡z¡]Ýò ¹=e
¹ b½ æ¹a
Ñ "ab½0¡¹=e½ÙÕÉýy¡
ò a¥e½:e1íb*v¥ ÕI¹ aÝäÕÝA Õ~¹aE ÕM½ÕE¹ ]¡E9QÍ
1 ¹Õ}% ¶ÙÁ y éE ê ¹ yµò
¡¥±bñíÝùÑ
¹y²î%õ ¹yµ òI%1 ¹Õ Ñi}E :Õæa¹%í:
e1ía Ai}e:©¹a ]} !µõvy
*¹!µÕ!½
¹]¥b½EÕ vy*Õ/¡ e1õò
¹=eÕ¥±b0¥a ¹b¥|
¡:Õyaò1Õ¹õ ¡*v¥ÕI
¹Aáµ}s¥aäÕÑ Îæa%"
ab½áµ}%í:e1íÑ¥UÝä½ 7DEOH&DUERQDQGR[\JHQLVRWRSHFRPSRVLWLRQVRI
WKHVRGDVWUDZLQWKLVVWXG\
6DPSOH1R
&
2
ROGHVW
\RXQJHVW
i"}E ya½vy*Õb¡e1õò
¹ =eÕ ò ¡:Õyaq*v 1]r¹íyA:Õy¹%í:e1ís¡Ai
äÕÑ ½æb½õæa¹%í:e1í ÑÕAiäÕE Õ¡z¡av¡ÕQÍ1 }å~}æa¹%í:e1í]¡vy*¹
!µ1 ±ùáÊ}E Ý}
:Õæa¹ %í:e1íÑ¡ ò ¹
=e1 rbÙb¥ |¡ä½UÕÑ ]b
½vy*¹!µ1¹ÕÑi}ä½ qI}E
¥ 5á ¥ 5½æa¥
å~¹M%ñ-¡a¥ÕY] Õæa¡
:ÕÕe¹½*ÑN¹ÎbÙvy*
¾¥ v¶¹íyb¹A éõä½ Õ~}E ùÝõ E¥ ¹ vy*¥
¾¹-QÍ er ¥] ¥1õbb
¡ ݾ¹M*¥1¥Õ E ¡vy*¥¾¹aE Õz¡
E¡æaÕ¹õ e:©vy*ÕEý
¹í!µ¹a¥ù!Ñ Õѽe1
½áå¹ ]%í:e1ís¡ ±Õѽ
%Ýyb¹õ]ÝUMaE ê
¡Õe¹5%vy*!µ¡E½!µ ÝUM])Ñ Õѽe¹±vqÕEÙv q1¥Õ"ab½íù!E q½ %í:e 1íÑ¡Õѽe:©½áå¹sÕ
*¥¹vy*¥ =¹õs1¥ÕÞ Õ"A i}ä½ ù!E
¿}½u¡zÕ ùÝõE¥y¡
1Ù1=î¹b¥|íyÑ QÍe:©1 õ ±¡¹a= =î1 b¥|¡u éE
¥¹=î I ¡ ¥¹=î E Y aYä½} ¥¹vy*1}õ I 1
¹½Eó¡vq¥¶ÙÁyé)ù EY 1
¹½vy*¡"ab½ý¹íay«õ
E :Õæa¹ !µõÕM½
vy*¹ ÕÝ v¶¹í yb¹A éE ¥ I 1ÕZ¹õ ¡]!1¥Õó¡vq
)LJ$VXPPDU\GLDJUDPVKRZLQJWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHDPRXQWRISUHFLSLWDWLRQDQGWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
3E
H[DQGFDUERQLVRWRSHFRQWHQWVRIWKHVRGDVWUDZDQDO\]HGLQWKLVVWXG\
¥ ù!)- EY 1 ÕZ¹õ ¡ ¡ vq¥ù!ÕZ=1QÍN¹vy
*¥ yb¹AéE q½ æa¹ ½= q½á
Þ áå1õæ¹íù!ýê¡*¹ )E åÕay)E Õõ 1¹Õõv}
Q]a¥ÕY ] =î I ¹¾¥yb¹ õä½qI}E ÕM½]E¡:Õ
¹æaÕÎbÙvy*¥¥±bv¶¹í
¾¹A é¥ù!E ¹- a= ¹=î1 b
¥ | «¡ ¥] ¥¹ sÕóí ù!ùõä¡:©¹vy*¥=¹õä
½>byÑ Ý} :Õæa¹ µºbå~
]õ=î]z¡ r¡:©~
vy*1¹½VÊbÙ ]½ qI}E
½y%¹rMá1e¹½v1%*ѹ:
Õ1}½] ¥e½æa¹µºbQÍ ÝÕ¡Á¡ E]zE
; æa¹ å~]õ5%vy*
p¹~vy*]E¹Ñ Õõ:Õ æaÕNbÙ¹vy*¥¥±bv¶¹ íyb¹A é¥=½E
¹; æa¹ ¡ar1}æñ½Ñ :
¹õ Õ:©õvy¡É9æa
½Vj} ä½Õ~y)Ñ Õõ:Õ>Õ a å¹ =ñ½}Õ y é¥ µ=½E
¬; %í:e1íÑ¡vy*Õ*¥1¥Õ
¡e1Ai}s¥ù!)Ñ Õ¡z¡
æa¹%í:e1íÑ¡vyaòaÝ ]¹õ=eê ò ¹=e1ÝÑiyõ ä½ Õ~}E
; æa¹%í:e1í ÑÕvy*¹!
µÝµ= ¹!½ùÝ ~í:Õ¹:Õ>
1¾}%í:e1í¹!µõ]ѹvy*¥
V1¹e½A%=ñ
½¹í Õy é¥äÕE
ÕQÍõVVQÍí¹r: v¦ QÍ&
1 ¹Õ1y)E ÕQ͹ áÒ½ q¥ U¥Áy é%¾¥í'õ Ñ¥]A Õrù ±y9]¡v v99q=E ÕQ ÍÝe½:Õ¹Ñ1%!¥]Av1aº±
:ÕQÍí½) er] ÕU Õe ¡bõ
%1íq¹1¥e½E
"KWWSZZZNPDJRNU
¡ea¥=îI¡¥e=î¹¥±
}%!µºaíi¾}æµía 5ÝS
Ý¡¥vÕ0DFNHQVHQ$)*Õº
ÕÉÕ%:rÎÕâáÕN]ÊÕ¹A¹!µ ºí
v1=}v/LX<X¡õv½y1ùùÕ
ÝÕ½ ¦N¹5a5~vy*V1½Î}
ºí
>½)1¡¡}]%Zù:Õ :Õ>¹1ºí
>UÕºÑUA}b5ÑS
> B:ÕæʺÑUA}*Ñ S
Õ"-¡] ]ò: ¹¡b =µå å~¥Õ½¥=î:N¹%mÝÕ vÍA¹ºíÕ)bòyv% ½Î%
* b5%Nñ1}}QÍíS Ñ >¡vò: (GZDUGV5/DZUHQFH
&KHQJ+DL:DQJ<RQJMLQ1Õ:Õ~}1¾ }%mÝÕ¹A%!µºí
ýæµva±IªIy 1}¥I}
}%Ub¹A%ºb¹Yºí
%DNHU$,WR(6PDUW3/DQG0F(ZDQ5) (OHYDWHGDQGYDULDEOHYDOXHVRI &LQVSHOHRWKHPVLQ D%ULWLVKFDYHV\VWHP&KHPLFDO*HRORJ\
%DU0DWWKHZV0$\DORQ$DQG.DXIPDQ$/DWH 4XDWHUQDU\SDODHRFOLPDWHLQWKHHDVWHUQ0HGLWHUUDQHDQ UHJLRQIURPVWDEOHLVRWRSHDQDO\VLVRIVSHOHRWKHPVDW 6RUHT&DYH,VUDHO4XDWHUQDU\5HVHDUFK
%DVNDUDQ0DQG,OLIIH70$JHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRI UHFHQWFDYHGHSRVLWXVLQJH[FHVV3E$QHZWHFKQLTXH
*HRSK\VLFDO5HVHDUFK/HWWHU
%RQQLZHOO(&0DWLVRII*DQG:KLWLQJ3- 'HWHUPLQLQJWKHWLPHVDQGGLVWDQFHVRISDUWLFOHWUDQVLW LQ D PRXQWDLQ VWUHDP XVLQJ IDOORXW UDGLRQXFOLGHV
*HRPRUSKRORJ\
%UDGOH\ 56 3DOHRFOLPDWRORJ\ 5HFRQVWUXFWLQJ FOLPDWHVRIWKH4XDWHUQDU\$FDGHPLF3UHVV%XUOLQJWRQ
&UX]-U):%XUQV6-.DUPDQQ,6KDUS:'9XLOOHS 0&DUGRVR$2)HUUDUL-$6LOYD'LDV3/DQG 9LDQD2-U,QVRODWLRQGULYHQFKDQJHVLQDWPRV SKHULFFLUFXODWLRQRYHUWKHSDVW\HDUVLQVXE WURSLFDO%UD]LO1DWXUH
'RGJH5(DQG7KRPVRQ-7KHQDWXUDOUDGLR FKHPLFDODQGJURZWKUHFRUGVLQFRPWHPSRUDU\KHUPD W\SLFFRUDOVIURPWKH$WODQWLFDQG&DULEEHDQ(DUWKDQG 3ODQHWDU\6FLHQFH/HWWHUV
'RUDOH-$*RQ]DOH]/$5HDJDQ0.3LFNHWW'$
0XUUHOO07DQG%DNHU5*$KLJKUHVROXWLRQ UHFRUGRI+RORFHQHFOLPDWHFKDQJHLQVSHOHRWKHPFDO FLWHIURP&ROG:DWHU&DYH1RUWKHDVW,RZD6FLHQFH 'UXIIHO (50 .LQJ // %HODVWRFN 5$ DQG
%XHVVHOHU.2*URZWKUDWHRIDGHHSVHDFRUDO XVLQJ 3E DQG RWKHU LVRWRSHV *HRFKLPLFD HW
&RVPRFKLPLFD$FWD
)DLUFKLOG,-6PLWK&/%DNHU$)XOOHU/6SRWO&
0DWWH\ ' 0F'HUPRWW ) DQG (,0) 0RGLILFDWLRQDQGSUHVHUYDWLRQRIHQYLURQPHQWDOVLJQDOV LQVSHOHRWKHPV(DUWK6FLHQFH5HYLHZV )ULHGPDQ,DQG21HLO-5&RPSLODWLRQRIVWDEOH
LVRWRSHIUDFWLRQDWLRQIDFWRUVRIJHRFKHPLFDOLQWHUHVW 86*63URIHVVRU3DSHULQ'DWDRI*HRFKHPLVWU\WK HGLWLRQ..
*HQW\'%ODPDUW'2XDKGL5*LOPRXU0%DNHU$
-RX]HO-DQG9DQ([WHU63UHFLVHGDWLQJRI 'DQVJDDUG2HVFKJHU FOLPDWH RVFLOODWLRQV LQ ZHVWHUQ (XURSHIURPVWDODJPLWHGDWD1DWXUH
*HQW\'DQG0DVVDXOW0&DUERQWUDQVIHUG\QDP LFVIURPERPE&DQGGHOWD&WLPHVHULHVRIDODPL QDWHGVWDODJPLWHIURP6:)UDQFHPRGHOOLQJDQGFRP SDULVRQZLWKRWKHUVWDODJPLWHUHFRUGV*HRFKLPLFDHW
&RVPRFKLPLFD$FWD
*LOOLHVRQ ' &DYHV SURFHVVHV GHYHORSPHQW PDQDJHPHQW %ODFNZHOO 3XEOLVKHUV 0DVVDFKXVHWWV
*RQ]DOH]/DQG/RKPDQQ.&&RQWUROVRQPLQHUS DORJ\DQGFRPSRVLWLRQRIVSHOHDQFDUERQDWHV&DUOVEDG
&DYHUQV1HZ0H[LFR,Q-DPHV13DQG&KRTXHWWH 3:HGV 3DOHRNDUVW 6SULQJHU9HUODJ 1HZ <RUN +DVDQ0%RGL]V'DQG&]LIUXV6$VLPSOLILHG WHFKQLTXHWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVHOIDEVRUSWLRQIRUVHGLPHQW VDPSOHV$SSOLHG5DGLDWLRQDQG,VRWRSHV +HOOVWURP-&DQG0F&XOORFK070XOWLSUR[\
FRQVWUDLQWVRQWKHFOLPDWLFVLJQLILFDQFHRIWUDFHHOHPHQW UHFRUGVIURPD1HZ=HDODQGVSHOHRWKHP(DUWKDQG 3ODQHWDU\6FLHQFH/HWWHUV
+HQG\&7KHLVRWRSLFJHRFKHPLVWU\RIVSHOHR WKHPV 7KHFDOFXODWLRQRIWKHHIIHFWVRIGLIIHUHQW PRGHVRIIRUPDWLRQRQWKHLVRWRSLFFRPSRVLWLRQRIVSH OHRWKHPV DQG WKHLU DSSOLFDELOLW\ DV SDOHRFOLPDWLF LQGLFDWRUV *HRFKLPLFD HW &RVPRFKLPLFD $FWD ,RDQQLGRX$0DQRORSRXORX0DQG3DSDVWHIDQRX&
7HPSRUDOFKDQJHVRI%HDQG3EFRQFHQWUDWLRQV LQVXUIDFHDLUDWWHPSHUDWHODWLWXGHV1$SSOLHG 5DGLDWLRQDQG,VRWRSHV
.LP-0.HQQHWW-33DUN%..LP'&.LP
*<DQG5RDUN(%3DOHRFHDQRJUDSKLFFKDQJH GXULQJ WKH ODVW GHJODFLDWLRQ (DVW 6HD RI .RUHD 3DOHRFHDQRJUDSK\
/LX=+DQG'UH\EURGW:'LVVROXWLRQNLQHWLFVRI FDOFLXPFDUERQDWHPLQHUDOVLQ+2&2VROXWLRQVLQWXU EXOHQWIORZ7KHUROHRIWKHGLIIXVLRQERXQGDU\OD\HUDQG VORZ UHDFWLRQ +2&2 ++&2
*HRFKLPLFD HW
&RVPRFKLPLFD$FWD
/X;DQG0DWVXPRWR(5HFHQWVHGLPHQWDWLRQ UDWHVGHULYHGIURP3EDQG&VPHWKRGVLQ,VH%D\
-DSDQ(VWXDULQH&RDVWDODQG6KHOI6FLHQFH 0F'HUPRWW)3DODHRFOLPDWHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIURP
VWDEOH LVRWRSH YDULDWLRQV LQ VSHOHRWKHPV D UHYLHZ 4XDWHUQDU\6FLHQFH5HYLHZV
0F*DUU\ 6) DQG &DVHOGLQH & 6SHOHRWKHP 3DO\QRORJ\DQXQGHUYDOXHGWRROLQ4XDWHUQDU\VWXGLHV 4XDWHUQDU\6FLHQFH5HYLHZV 0F1HDU\'DQG%DVNDUDQ0'HSRVLWLRQDOFKDUDF
WHULVWLFV RI%H DQG3E LQVRXWKHDVWHUQ 0LFKLJDQ -RXUQDORI*HRSK\VLFDO5HVHDUFK'$WPRVSKHUHV
$$&$$&
0LFNOHU3-6WHUQ/$DQG%DQQHU-//DUJHNL QHWLF LVRWRSH HIIHFWV LQ PRGHUQ VSHOHRWKHPV *6$
%XOOHWLQ
0RRUH:6DQG.ULVKQDVZDPL6&RUDOJURZWK UDWHVXVLQJ5DDQG3E(DUWKDQG3ODQHWDU\6FLHQFH /HWWHUV
0XUUD\-:3DXO%'XQQH-3DQG&KDSLQ7
7K3E3RDQGVWDEOH3ELQWKHFHQWUDOHTXDWRULDO 3DFLILF7UDFHUVIRUSDUWLFOHF\FOLQJ'HHS6HD5HVHDUFK 3DUW,2FHDQRJUDSKLF5HVHDUFK3DSHUV 3DSDVWHIDQRX&5HVLGHQFHWLPHRIWURSRVSKHULF
DHURVROV LQ DVVRFLDWLRQ ZLWK UDGLRDFWLYH QXFOLGHV
$SSOLHG5DGLDWLRQDQG,VRWRSHV 5LFKDUGV'$DQG'RUDOH-$8UDQLXPVHULHVFKUR
QRORJ\DQGHQYLURQPHQWDODSSOLFDWLRQVRIVSHOHRWKHPV 5HYLHZVLQ0LQHUDORJ\DQG*HRFKHPLVWU\
7DQDKDUD$DQG7DLUD+'DWLQJRIVSHOHRWKHPV
$JHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIVWUDZVWDODFWLWHVE\3EPHWKRG -DSDQ&RQWULEXWLRQWRWKH,*&3
:DOOLQJ'(&ROOLQV$/DQG6LFKLQJDEXOD+0 8VLQJXQVXSSRUWHGOHDGPHDVXUHPHQWVWRLQYHV WLJDWH VRLOHURVLRQ DQGVHGLPHQWGHOLYHU\ LQDVPDOO
=DPELDQFDWFKPHQW*HRPRUSKRORJ\
:DQJ<-&KHQJ+(GZDUGV5/$Q=6:X-<
6KHQ&&DQG'RUDOH-$$KLJKUHVROXWLRQ DEVROXWHGDWHGODWH3OHLVWRFHQH0RQVRRQUHFRUGIURP +XOXFDYH&KLQD6FLHQFH
:RR.6+RQJ*+&KRL':-R.1%DVNDUDQ 0DQG/HH+0$UHFRQQDLVVDQFHRQWKHXVH RI WKH VSHOHRWKHPV LQ .RUHDQ OLPHVWRQH FDYHV WR UHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\RQWKHUHJLRQDOFOLPDWHFKDQJHIRU WKHUHFHQWDQGJHRORJLFSDVW*HRVFLHQFH-RXUQDO
:\QQ30)DLUFKLOG,-%DNHU$)ULVLD6%RUVDWR
$DQG0LRUDQGL5,Q3UHVV$WPRVSKHULFIRUFLQJRI VXOSKDWH LQ VSHOHRWKHP FDUERQDWH *HRFKLPLFD HW
&RVPRFKLPLFD$FWD
<DPDPRWR 0 6DNDJXFKL $ 6DVDNL . +LURVH . ,JDUDVKL<DQG.LP&.6HDVRQDODQGVSDWLDO YDULDWLRQRIDWPRVSKHULF3EDQG%HGHSRVLWLRQIHD WXUHV RI WKH -DSDQ 6HD VLGH RI -DSDQ -RXUQDO RI (QYLURQPHQWDO5DGLRDFWLYLW\
<XDQ'&KHQJ+(GZDUGV5/'\NRVNL&$.HOO\
0-=KDQJ04LQJ-/LQ<:DQJ<:X- 'RUDOH-$$Q=DQG&DL<7LPLQJGXUDWLRQ DQGWUDQVLWLRQVRIWKH/DVWLQWHUJODFLDO$VLDQPRQVRRQ 6FLHQFH
AÝ ¥ 5 Ý
M Ý ¥ 5 Ý
M¥-Ý ¥ 5 Ý
