Study on Fiber Cutting Performance of Isometric Straight Bar Plate with Different Bar Angle
Huan Liu
1,2†, Jixian Dong
1,2‡, Xiya Guo
1,2,3, Chong Luo
4, Xiaohui Tian
4, Xiaojun Jiang
5, Sha Wang
1,2, Ruifan Yang
1,2, Chuanwu Duan
1,2, Bo Wang
1,2and Kai Qi
1,2Received July 22, 2019; Received in revised form September 14, 2019; Accepted September 18, 2019
ABSTRACT
The refining plate is a direct-acting component of refiners in pulping, and the bar profile of it have a major impact on fiber cutting, which affects the paper forming and strength of the formed paper. In this paper, the fiber average length, the fiber length distribution, the original fiber cutting rate and adjacent fiber cutting rate of samples collected in different refining time are used to analyze the fiber cutting mechanism of the isometric straight bar refining plates with different bar angles. The results show that the fiber cutting perfor- mance of plates gradually decreases and the limit fiber cutting length of the plate increases with the increase of the bar angle which is opposite to the conclusion predicted by specific edge load (SEL). However, the fiber cutting action of plates is gradually weakened until the average fiber length is reduced to the limit cutting length of plates. Meanwhile, the cutting mechanism of the straight bar plates with different bar angles is different. The larger bar angle of plate, the lower fiber cutting rate and the adjacent cutting rate of which is basically kept constant during refining, while the adjacent cutting rate of smaller bar angle plate on fibers gradually decreases with refining and finally remains constant. The study on the cutting performance of different bar angle plates has positive significance for the selection and design of refining plates for different pulping process.
Keywords: Papermaking, disc refiner, straight bar, bar angle, fiber cutting
Printed in Korea http://dx.doi.org/10.7584/JKTAPPI.2019.10.51.5.16
1 College of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, Shaanxi University of Science & Technology, Xi’an, Shaanxi Province, 710021, People’s Republic of China
2 China Key Laboratory of Light Industry Equipment Manufacturing Intelligence,Xi’an, Shaanxi Province, 710021, People’s Republic of China
3 College of Art and Design, Shaanxi University of Science & Technology, Xi’an, Shaanxi Province, 710021, People’s Republic of China
4 Henan Cigarette Industry Sheet Co., Ltd., Henan Province, 461100, People’s Republic of China 5 Nantong Huayan Casting Co., Ltd., Nantong, Jiangsu Province, 226403, People’s Republic of China
† Corresponding Author: E-mail: [email protected]
‡ Co-corresponding Author: E-mail: [email protected]
1. Introduction
The disc refiner is an important equipment for improving the properties of fiber and pulp in the pulp and paper industry. During the refining, the pulp is fed into the grooved-typed rotating refining zone composed of the stator and the rotor, and undergoes complex mechanical action such as shearing and compression of the bar aiming to im- prove fiber and pulp properties through fiber internal fibrillation, external fibrillation, fines production, fiber cutting, fiber curl and straight.
1-5)Fiber cutting is a phenomenon during refining in which the fibers are laterally broken due to shear between the bar and fibers and friction among the fibers during refining, as shown in Figs. 1 and 2. It was found that the fiber cutting in the low consis- tency refining is directly derived from the shearing action of the “scissors” formed by the “knife” and
“knife”, which refers to the bar of refining plate.
6)However, the pure shearing was almost non-exis- tent during refining, and the impact of the bar on fibers was transmitted between the plurality of fibers in the form of strain which implies no direct bar shearing action on the individual fibers exist.
7)From another point of view, the pulp refining was a fatigue process and the change of fiber morphology was caused by cyclic bar impacts on fibers.
8,9)But Olson et al.
10)believed that fiber cutting was not a fatigue process, more energy was applied to the
Fig. 1. The schematic diagram of fiber cutting.
pulp in high-intensity refining and the proportion of fiber cutting would be increased, which means that the onset of fiber cutting does not require critical impact times. Therefore, the fiber cutting can be considered as a result of the joint action of the shear action by bars and the bar impact fatigue damage.
The parameters affecting the fiber and pulp properties during refining mainly include the gap between stator and rotor, rotation speed, bar profile, etc. Especially, the bar structure has a great influ- ence on the fiber morphology change under the condition of constant gap and rotation speed. Pre- vious studies have been carried out on two main parameters of bar profile, bar width and bar height, by Li et al. and Liu et al.
11-13)It was found higher pulp quality and lower energy consumption were obtained when refining with a higher bar height plate. Meanwhile, the bar width had a certain influence on both of them in medium consistency refining, which had been certified that the pulp freeness decreases slowly as the bar width increases.
The bar angle, which is usually represented by the angle between the bar and the radial direction, is another important parameter of the refining plate, while no standard definition exists for it.
The direction and magnitude of the bar angle will have an impact on the flow rate and pulp refining effect. When the bar tilting direction tends to be opposite to the rotation direction of the plate, the
Fig. 2. SEM image (4kx) of fiber cutting in low
consistency refining process.
pulp will be pumped to the outlet by plate which means a lower pulp residence time in refining zone and higher intensity.
14)Vomhoff
15)studied the influence of the disc refining plate bar angle on the refining effect, and analyzed the total bar interac- tion area, the number of interlacing points and the total bar edge length by simulating the interlacing process of stator and rotor. Siewert et al.
16)found the freeness change of pulp was different when refining with different bar angle plates under the same refining process. Brecht et al.
17)showed refining by plates with smaller bar angle would reduce the refining time and energy consumption when the same pulp freeness was obtained.
At present, the research on the bar angle is rela- tively lacking, including the definition of it, the influence of the bar angle on the fiber cutting. In this paper, the theoretical analysis of isometric straight bar refining plates with a clear bar angle definition is carried out. And the cutting perfor- mance and cutting mechanism of different plates is analyzed and evaluated by the original cutting rate, the adjacent cutting rate and the fiber length distribution of different lengths in low consistency refining which has a positive significance for pro- moting the design and selection of refining plates.
2. Experimental
2.1 Bar angle of straight bar plate
The angle between the bar and the radial direction was called the bar angle, as shown in Fig. 3. The bar angle of the different bars in a segment varies with the position of bars, such as α
1-1and α
1-i, which was not conducive to characterizing the bar angle of the segment or refining plate.
Currently, there were two main definitions of the bar angle of the isometric straight bar plates or segments. Firstly, the bar angle was defined as the angle α
1-1between the first bar and the right edge
of segment, as shown in Fig. 3; secondly, the de- gree of bar inclination could be measured by the angle α
2between the center axis of the segment and bar, as shown in Fig. 4. According to the geometry, the relationship between them can be expressed by Eq. 1.
2
1 12 [1]
Where β is the center angle of the segment.
It can be obtained from the Eq. 1 that the bar angle α
1-1and the center angle of the segment directly affect the bar angle α
2, and the size of α
1-1and α
2depends on each other in the case of a specific central angle β which means the nature of them is
Fig. 3. Definition 1 of bar angle.
Fig. 4. Definition 2 of bar angle.
Based on the SEL theory, the refining intensity of isometric straight bar refining plates was analyzed in this paper. And the CEL of a straight bar plate was specified by the TAPPI standard TIP 0508-05 (1994),
20)and the expression of it was
CEL n r n r dr
R R
r s
i
0
( ) ( )
cos [2]
Where r
1was the inner radius of plate (mm), r
2was the outer radius of plate (mm), n
rand n
swas the total bar number of a rotor and a stator, and α was the bar angle of the plate (°).
The refining effect of plates on pulp or fibers was directly related to the refining intensity. If the value of it was 3 to 5 J/m, it was suitable for the refining of long fiber pulp, which had a strong cutting effect on fiber allowing for high-intensity refining. The short fiber pulp was better for a good fibrillation during low-intensity refining when it was 0.5 to 2 J/m.
21)The average fiber length and width of hardwood was 0.6 to 2 mm and 0.01 to 0.04 mm, respectively. And the commonly used SEL for it is 0.6 to 0.8 J/m, which was a typical low-intensity refining.
22)So three isometric straight bar plates with different bar angles and same other bar parameters were designed accord- ing to low-intensity refining, as shown in Table 1, same for measuring the angle of the segment.
However, the bar angle α
1-1would be easily used due to convenient measurement and it was used in this paper to measure the bar inclination.
2.2 Design and characterization of the refining plate
Refining intensity was an important parameter affecting the refining performance including spe- cific energy consumption (SRE), specific edge load (SEL), specific surface load (SSL), impact strength in the C factor theory et al. It could be divided into machine intensity and fiber intensity according to the benchmark of energy consumption,
18)and machine intensity can be summarized by SEL- based refining intensity and refining intensity based on bar interaction,
19)which meant that the characterization parameters of refining plate, comprehensively characterized the impact on pulp, can be divided into characterization parameters based on cutting edge length (CEL) and character- ization parameters based on bar interaction.
Under the same refining conditions, a larger value of the characterization parameter resulted in a smaller refining intensity which led to the reduction of the fiber cutting effect and the improvement of the fiber fibrillation.
Table 1. The bar parameters of three plates
Disc-1 Disc-2 Disc-3
Plate
Bar angle 5° 22° 39°
Number of bar 108 117 117
CEL (m/rev) 378.56 276.55 239.55
Common bar parameters
Bar width Groove width Bar height Inner radius Outer radius Center angle of segment
2 mm 3 mm 4 mm 82.5 mm 203 mm 40°
2.4 Fiber analysis and data processing
The length-weighted average fiber length, and the rate of different fiber length range, known as fiber length distribution, of the pulp samples were ana- lyzed by an FS5 fiber quality analyzer (Valmet, Espoo, Finland). And the original cutting rate and the adjacent cutting rate were defined in order to analyze the cutting effect of the different refining plates.
2.4.1 Original cutting rate
The original cutting rate indicated the cutting effect of plates on fibers relative the average fiber length of samples to the average fiber length of raw material fibers, which can be expressed as
K l l l
1 0
0
100
j
% [3]
Where K
1represented the original cutting rate of plates on fibers, l
0represents the average length of the raw fiber, and l
jrepresented the average fiber length of the sampled fiber.
2.4.2 Adjacent cutting rate
The adjacent cutting rate indicated the cutting effect of refining plates which was affected by the average length of the sampling fibers with the aver- age length of adjacent sampling fibers, which can and they were directly were directly processed by
Nantong Huayan Casting Co., Ltd. (Nantong, China) through the computer numerical control machine tools (CNC) machine (Shenzhen Dima Co., Ltd., Shenzhen, China).
2.3 Refining
In this experiment, bleached sulfate eucalyptus pulp board was used as the experimental material and it was soaked in distilled water for 4 h and then dissipated by a pulp disintegrator PD10 (TLS, San Sebastian, Spain), and its consistency was adjusted to 3%. The MD3000 single-disc experi- mental refiner (Regmed, Osasco, Brazil) was used, as shown in Fig. 5, and the refining experiments were conducted using the three isometric straight bar plates at a constant speed (1,460 rpm).
The pulp was circulated in the refining system, as shown in Fig. 5b, and 10 pulp samples were col- lected at a constant gap during different refining times. After a reasonable design, the pulp with a disc gap of 0.1 mm was sampled at intervals of 2 min. The samples collected at different times were centrifuged and dried by an electric blast drying oven 101 (Beijing Zhongxing Weiye Instrument Co., Ltd., Beijing, China) to calculate the moisture con- tent of the pulp for subsequent experiments.
Fig. 5. The MD3000 SD refiner (a) and the refining system (b) of the experiment.
be defined as Eq. 4 and visually described in Fig. 6.
K l l
l
2 1
1
100
j j
j