The Electrochemical Characteristics of Surface-modified Carbonaceous Materials by tin Oxides and Copper for Lithium Secondary Batteries
Joong Kee Lee
♠, D. H. Ryu*, Y. G. Shul*, B. W. Cho and D. Park
Clean Technology Research Center/Battery and Fuel Cell Center
Korea Institute of Science and Technology, P.O. Box 131, Cheongryang, Seoul, Korea
*Dept. of Chemical Eng., Yonsei University, Shinchon, Seoul, Korea
♠e-mail: leejk@kist.re.kr
(Received November 28, 2000; accepted January 19, 2001)
Abstract
Lithium intercalated carbon (LIC) are basically employed as an anode for currently commercialized lithium second- ary batteries. However, there are still strong interests in modifying carbon surface of active materials of the anode because the amount of irreversible capacity, charge-discharge capacity and high rate capability are largely determined by the surface conditions of the carbon. In this study, the carbonaceous materials were coated with tin oxide and copper by fluidized-bed chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method and their coating effects on electrochemical characteristics were investigated. The electrode which coated with tin oxides gave the higher capacity than that of raw material. Their capacity decreased with the progress of cycling possibly due to severe volume changes. However, the cyclability was improved by coating with copper on the surface of the tin oxides coated carbonaceous materials, which plays an impor- tant role as an inactive matrix buffering volume changes. An impedance on passivation film was decreased as tin oxides contents and it resulted in the higher capacity.
Keywords : Lithium Secondary Batteries, Fluidized-Bed CVD, Surface Modification.
1. B
*Ò Z&Ï ;VV~ ÿ *öb 6Ò ÒÏ> ®º ÒÒ N *æ~ ¦b ÒÒ .³, ê²Òò 5 ÒÒ alloys f high energy densityf lightest weight¢ <º * Òò
& **& -3.045 V &Ë Ôf *VrWê¢ <V r^ö ·
Nj ;W~Vö &Ë £² *¶¢ ~º r Òò.
¾ ÒÒ .³f ÏÁO* >w ê¯>º ÿn ÒÒ .
³~ ö dendrite~ ;Wb Ò >«~ 6² 5 n;W GöB N*æ ÒÏ~Vöº ç ^B¢ n
®. ^B¢ Ö~V * r >wö inter- calation *ç Ï>º rocking-chair Bv ê«>î[1- 3]. ¯, ÒÒ .³j Ôf *Vz **öB ÒÒ Nj &
'b > O > ®º ê² host &Ú~º ©
. *æº ÒÒ .³ *æö j energy densityö
®ÚB Ôf 6²¢ , Ò >« 5 n;W GöB Ò ê¯>º ÿn j& >wö ~ Ïï ¶ ^B
¢ n ®.
V¢B ê² Òò~ &n' bî Ò>î, Ö Ò Ò .³j & > ®º ÒÒ alloys~ ÒÏö & VÞ
æ² >î. ÒÒ alloys~ ' specific chargesf charge densitiesº lithiated graphites(LiC6) ¸b, ÒÒ
metal alloys~ packing densities, ¯ charge densitiesº .³ Ò Òö &[4-8]. LiC6ö j ÒÒ alloys~ 6 ßûf host metal '.® FB, ·ÿ **& ÒÒ .³~ *
ëÏ ÒÒ N *æöB ê² Òò& anode 6Ò ÒÏ>º
Fº .³ ÒÒ" alloying >wj ê¯~B ¦bf
ö ®Ú ç æz¢ >>~V r^. lithium-freef lithiated host Ò~ ¦b Nº *;'b 100~300% ;ê
. Ö"'b ÒÒ alloys~ ãÖ Ïïf ¸æò alloying/
dealloying >w~ >ö V ç ¦b æz
morphological æz¢ ¢bB Ò >«~ 6² ^B¢ ¢ bʲ B[9].
ôf &f j& Ïï, ÏÁO* Ïï 5 high rate capability& ê²~ çö ² ~~V r^ö ê²
~ Bîö &j &^J ®. öBº &n'
¦ bî~BBj * ê²Òò ö Fÿç zVç ÃO»j ê«~ "CÖzb 5 Ò¢ z+b * Vz' Î"¢ ¦Ã~¶ ~&. ¯, V~ ê²Òòf ÒÒ alloys~ Ë6j ֦ΠÒÒN*æÏ *bîj B~ *Vz' ßWj ¦Ã~&.
2. þ
ò
bîB ï «ê& 10µm 2800oCöB ¾ÒB MCMB1028(Osaka gas)j ÒÏ~&b, ö Ò~º Û V 6º J"bj B~V * 80oC vacuum ovenöB ~
ÿn V.
Bî Ë~
Fÿç zÃO Ë~º *Ú FV.³(metallic organic compounds)Wªj /~V * Ê, *Òò¢ Fÿz ç òÚB ¢ z+Î"¢ &Ë~² ~º &滅 Fÿç zÃO Ë~~ BÛê, Ú' W º² Fÿz 5 *Ú ÿ>&Ê /Êf *Òò~ Fÿ zö jº &Êï" FV.³ *Ú~ ÃV{ö V ;{
/j * Ú>&Ê¢ MFC(mass flow controller)¢ Ò Ï~ .~&. FV.³ *Ú /f ÃObî~ &Ë
" /j * Ë~ bubblerö Ú 6º Ú~ ÃObî j I Nê¢ ¸ ÃVzB ÃObj /~º Ë~ W>Ú ®. Fÿç >wVº çã 2~ quartz&b B·
>Ú ®b, f zÃOö ~ *Ú ª >w" *
Òò~ Fÿz& ÿö ¢Ú¾B *Òò~ Bî
ê¯>º ¦ªb *Ú ªÒ¢ * ¶&, [Ú bî
*Òò~ /¦, Fÿzö V [Ú bî bj z× Ï
~² ~V * v>Vf zÃO >wö jº ö.æ
/j * ®V& >wV ãö J~>Ú ®. jÖbî catching Êf Ò" 200 mesh stainless steelb
B·B jV W>Ú ®. Êf Fÿç zÃO
>w j;ç 6º ;çç ëöB jÖ>Ú Æj&º
^ *bîj ÷~, >w{K.ö jº {K. ^ 2~ ^¢ * J~~&. {KBÚÊf Bî J
;j * _f Òò~ *¾Ò¢ * >wV {K.¦ªb
{KbB, {K.^2, ê²* b W>î. 6
>w&Ê ¾ÒÊj ê²* êö J~~&º,
&W >w&Ê 5 >w *Ú ªbj ²f scrubbingj Û~ ö&Ê¢ ¾Ò~ OÂʺ VËj æ î ®.
Fÿç zÃO >w
þöBº Fÿç zÃO ;j Ï~ "CÖz b" Ò¢ MCMB1028~ ö ÃO~&. .³ *Ú
º Òf "CÖzb '' Cu(hfac)2, (CH3)4Snj ÒÏ~&
b, ßWj Table 1ö B~&. Nê~ J;f ^òj
^~&b[10-11], G;B Ú¦ Nêº Fÿz¢ ¢bʺ
&Ê~ Nê ê² Òò ¶Ú~ Nêfº N& ®. >w 5 Ú> VÚº î², >²(Ò~ ãÖ), Ö²("CÖzb~
Cu(hfac)2(l) + H2(g) Cu(s) + 2H(hfac)(g) (1) (CH3)4Sn( l ) + O2(g) SnO2(s) + 4CO2(g) + 6H2O(g) (2)
ò~ ªC
Fÿç z Vç ÃO»ö ~ ê²Òò ö z+B .³ 5 .³Özb~ ªf «¶ V 5 Z²j 5 W j SEM(Hitachi, S-4200), XRD(Rigaku, RINT/DMAS-2500), ICP(ASH, Thermo Jarrel POLYSCAN 61E), EPMA(Jeol, JXA- 8600) j Ï~ rj~.
* B 5 *æ ã
r bî(active material)j B~V * .³ z+B ê²Òòf ÖB PVdF(polyvinylidene fluoride) [13 wt%
in NMP (1-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone)]¢ 94 : 6~ wt% jN D
'ï~ j^Êj Î&~ ³ v>V(5000 rpm)
¢~² v> ê, *~ ÷*Ú Cu meshö :w»j Ï
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of fluidized chemical vapor deposi- tion process.
Table 1. Properties of Cu & Sn precursor
Cu(hfac)2 (CH3)4Sn
Solid Liquid
Decomposition at T >400oC Decomposition at T >400oC Vapor pressure ~10 torr at 100oC Vapor pressure 100 torr at 25oC Melting point at 85~89oC Melting point at -54oC Boiling point at 220oC Boiling point at 78oC Specific gravity 1.35 Specific gravity 1.31 Formula weight 447.64 Formula weight 178.83
Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of Li secondary batteries.
~ z+~&. *j 80oCöB ~ ÿn B rolling press¢ ÒÏ~ {O ê *~ V¢ 2Ü2 cm2 ¶
ê 80oC, ê ~öB ~ V. jWB *vþº ÷
*Ú vþ¢ ~ 100µm.
*æ ãf Ûê& 0.3% ~ dry roomöB ¯~&b,
*æº >ã *æ(half cell)¢ W~ .³ z+B ê² *
~ *Vz' ßWj rj~. ·ë *b ê² *
, ç& *b ÒÒ foil, ªÒïb *î B PP(poly-propylene)
1 M LiPF6(lithium hexafluorophosphate) " Ï>Ú ®º EC : EMC : DMC (1 : 1 : 1)¢ ÒÏ~&. Fig. 2ö *æ ã
Wê¢ ¾æÚî.
3. Ö" 5 V
öBº z+B "CÖzb~ · 5 Ò Î&ö V
Î"¢ rjV * 4&æ sampleö & *Vz' ß Wj Ò~&.
ò ªC
ICP ªCö ~ ê²Òòö & Z²j 5 >w j Table 2ö ¾æÚî. Table 2öB CS0º raw MCMB¢ ~
~, SN1f 1.37 wt%~ "CÖzbò z+>îj ãÖ, SN2º 0.93 wt%~ "CÖzbò z+>îj ãÖ, CS1f 1.83 wt%~ "CÖzb 5 0.14 wt%~ Ò¢ þ z+~&
j ãÖ¢ ¾æÞ.
SEMj Ï~ Òf "CÖzb z+B MCMB 1028
«¶~ ;çj Fig. 3ö ¾æÚî. (a)~ raw MCMB 1028º jÚ ;çj ~ ®b, (b), (c)º "C Özbò z+>îj ãÖB z+B "C Özb «¶~ V& ¢;j &V > ®b, MCMB1028~ *öB jv' ¢ ª¢ ¾æêj r > ®. (c)º (b) âö j~ "CÖzb~ ª &ê& Ôrj &V > ®b, (d)º ¸f ª &ê¢ <º "CÖzb *öB size& Ò~ ª¢ { > ®. 6 Fÿç zÃO»ö ~
raw MCMB1028~ ö ÃOB "CÖzbf £ 50 nm ; ê~ æªj <º ;j ¾æÚ, Òº £ 200 nm ;ê~
æªj <º ;~ ;çj j ®rj &V > ®. Table 2. Properties and preparation of metal coated carbons
Element Analysis Sample preparation method (Fluidized CVD reaction conditions) Cu (wt%) Sn (wt%)
CS0* − − −
SN1 − 1.37 tin oxides coating at Ca. 500oC for 30 min
SN2 − 0.93 tin oxides coating at Ca. 500oC for 10 min
CS1 0.14 1.83 tin oxides coating at Ca. 500oC for 40 min and subsequently copper coating at Ca.
450oC for 2hrs CS0*: raw MCMB
Fig. 3. SEM photographs of surface-modified MCMB1028 (×100K): (a) CS0 (b) SN1 (c) SN2 (d) CS1.
- ê²Òò ö z+B ·ö V¢ .³ 5 .³ Özb
~ «¶ ª& cluster ; jv' ¢~² ªÖ>Ú ® rj { > ®.
Fig. 4º "CÖzbò z+B MCMB1028~ SEM image 5 &w~º "C~ EPMA mappingj ¾æÞ â.
EPMAº ê² *öB ª>Ú ®º "C 5 Ò ?f
W ö²~ ;W 5 ;ï ªCj ~º ÒÏ~º O»b
Wª~ ßW X-ray Ê¿Þ"j G;~ ©j mappingö ~
standard intensityf jv~º O. âöB "C
ê²Òò «¶ *öB jv' ª¢ ¾æÚ ® rj r > ®. Fig. 5º "CÖzb" Ò¢ z+ ò
~ SEM image 5 ö &w~º "C" Ò ''~ EPMA mappingj ¾æÞ âb "C ¸f ª &ê¢ ¾æÚ
9² ª>Ú ®rj { > ®b, Òº Ô f ª &ê¢ ¾æÚ ®º, ©f 'f z+ ·ö ~
©b ÒòB.
*Vz' ßW ªC
3.2.1 "CÖzb~ z+B ·ö V Î"
.³ z+B MCMB 1028~ "C Özb~ ·ö V *V z' ßWj rjV * '' 0.93%, 1.37%, 1.83%~ "
C FNj <º ê² *ö & ;*~(Galvanostatic)»
z+B ê² *~ Ñ ® Ò" v ® ÒöB~
ÏÁO* curveB Ñ ® Ò~ Ï* £ 0.8V **
"¾öB ïê **¢ &V > ®b, z+B · Ã&
> ïê **º Ã&j { > ®. ¯, Ï* Ïï
Ã&j { > ®. ©f Ñ ® Ò~ Ï* "
;öBò ¾æ¾º ©bB v ® Ò êöº &V>
æ pº. ¯, >w j&'b ê¯> ®rj ~~
®. j& ";f "CÖzb 7~ "Cj ~ö
ʺ V ÒÒ~ ²j ©b, Ï* Ï
©f Fig. 7~ CV curveöBê &V > ®. z+B "C Özb~ ·ö V¢ Ñ ® Ò~ ~ö peak& 0.7V **
"OöB Ã&j &V > ®º, ©f ÏÁO* curve Fig. 4. (a) SEM photographs of tin oxides coated MCMB and
(b) corresponding EPMA mapping of Sn.
Fig. 5. (a) SEM photographs of tin oxides and copper coated MCMB and corresponding EPMA mapping of (b) Sn & (c) Cu.
Fig. 6. 1st, 2nd charge/discharge curves of surface-modified MCMB1028. (a) CS0 (b) SN1 (c) SN2 (d) CS1.
Fig. 7. Cyclic voltammograms of surface-modified MCMB1028 with scan rate of 0.1 mV/s (0.0 V : 3.0 V); (a) CS0 (b) SN1 (c) SN2 (d) CS1.
~ ïê **öBf îR&æ j& ";ö ~ ÒÒ
Öz>Ú ²j> ®rj ~~, v ® Ò êöº &V>æ prj { > ®.
Courtney and Dahn[12-13]ö ~~, Li-Sn alloy~ ãÖ, Ñ
® Ï* ";ÿn ÒÒf Ö²(.Vö "C" ÖB)f Ö
~, Özb »Z>B "C" amorphous ç
~ Li2O¢ ;W~, >wö ~ ~öB "Cf Li4.4Sn
~ ' W êræ ÒÒ" Ö~º alloying >wj ê
¯~² >º ©b > ®.
"CÖzb z+B ê²Òò~ ãÖ, f ?f mechanism b >w ê¯Nj { > ®º, Fig. 8f "
CÖzb "Cb ~ö>îrj ¾æÚ ®º XRD data
. Ò *~ "CÖzbf 30 Ò ê¯B êöº
peak¢ &V > ìb, æ ~öB "C peakòj {
> ®.
6 þöBº *~ >w~ Ö"ö ~ Z "C
ÒÒ" Ö~ LixSn W>º .>w(alloying reaction)
öê ê²Òòf ÒÒö ~ *;' ã«>w (intercalation reaction) ÷¯~ ÏÁO* >wj ê¯~²
xLi + 6C LixC6 (3)
xLi + SnO2 Li2O + Li + Sn Li2O + Li-Sn (4) 3.2.2. Ò Î&ö V Î"
Fig. 9º C-rate¢ C/5 ;*~ þj ê¯~&j ãÖ~
Ò WËj ¾æÞ ¾*. âöB r > ® "
C Özbò z+B MCMB1028~ ãÖ .V ÒöBº raw MCMBö j~ çßB Ïïj "æò Ò ê
¯Nö V¢ Ò ßW~ &~¢ { > ®. 6 z +B "CÖzb~ · Ã&> O* Ïï Ã&j r > ®. Li-Sn alloy anode~ ãÖ "CÖzbò z+>î j ãÖöº Ò ê¯Nö V¢ "C aggregation ;
Ò~Jº ãË 5 alloying/dealloying >w ê¯>B ç ¦b æzö ~ morphological æz¢ ¢bB Ö"
'b Ò >«~ 6²¢ ¢bʺ ©b > ®
[9]. þöBê ê²Òòö "CÖzbj z+~ Ò
ßW &~>º ©b j Li-Sn alloy anodef mechanism
jÝj { > ®. lithium alloy~ Ò
WËj BF~V * lithium metal alloy~ ãÖ, B> .
³ &ö intermetallic¾ composite host¢ ê« 'Ï~&
º, V Bvf ÏÁO* ß; ê ¯, ß; **öB composite¾ intermetallic~ Wªf ÒÒj &Ë > ®º (>», cc~º) reactantB~ j ~² >, Wª f jWbB reactant~ ccj jzB"º matrix
Özb~ ç ¦b æzö ~ Ò >«~ 6²¢ Ö~V * inactive matrixB Ò¢ Î&~ Ò >
«j BF~&. öBê V' BvöB Â B~ þ Ö", âöB "CÖzb z+B ê
²Òòö Ò¢ Î&bB ~ Ò >«~ 6² ^ B¢ Ö > ®² >î.
3.2.3. SEI(Solid electrolyte interphase)öB~ æz
Fig. 10f 2® ÏÁO* ÒöB~ AC impedance 5 EVS (Electrochemical voltage spectroscopy) curve¢ ¾æÚ
®. Öz ~ö ";~ Î **ö ®ÚB "CÖzb z +B *~ semicircle~ æª ¯, impedance& raw material ö j /Ï® 6²j { > ®b, z+B "CÖz b~ · Ã&> êöB~ ªb~ʺ 6²j {
> ®. CS1 ò~ z+B "CÖzb · SN1 ò~
"CÖzb · ôæò impedance& Ã&~ G;B Fº ÒÒ" >wj ~º ¯, W "CÖzbö j ÒÒ
" >wj ~æ pº ¯, jW Ò~ Î& .¾ B Ö" ÒòB. ¯, Ò~ Î&º Ò >«j BF~
æò impedanceº Ã&Új { > ®. 6 SN1"
SN2¢ jv~&j ãÖ, z+B "CÖzb~ · Ã&>
êöB~ impedanceº 6²j { > ®.
3.2.4. C-rateö V Î"
"C Özb z+B ê² Òò~ C-rateö V ßWj r jV * '' C/5, C/3, C/2ö &~ ;*~»b þ j ~ Ò 7 maximum discharge capacity¢ Fig. 11 Fig. 8. X-ray diffraction diagrams of the carbon electrode
before and after cycle.
Fig. 9. Cycle performances of surface-modified MCMB1028.
~ ¾*öB jv~ ê~&. âöB z+B "
CÖzb~ · Ã&> O* Ïï Ã&~º ãËj
®æò, N O*b .> O* Ïï~ N& *Ú j r > ®. ©f &N O*öº z+B "CÖzb
ÒÒ" alloying reactionj ¢bÊVö Ϫ *j <²
>Ú ÏïÃ& ¾æ¾æò, N O*öBº "CÖzb"
ÒÒ"~ alloying >w³ê& ÒÒ~ O³ê ç&'b
¶J^B z+ Î"~ 'Ëj A² >Ú Ö"'b raw
material" Ïïö ®Ú N& ìº ©b ÒòB.
4. Ö
º *Ò çÏz>Ú 6Ò ®º ÒÒ N * æÏ ê² ¦~ &Ú bî BBj * ê²Òò ö F ÿç zVçÃO»j ê«~ "CÖzb 5 Ò¢ z+
b *Vz' Î"¢ ¦Ã~¶ ~&b, Ö
− Fÿç zVçÃO»ö ~ ê² Òò ö z+B "
C Özb 5 Òº cluster ; ê² Òò öB j v' ¢ ª¢ ¾æÚîb, "CÖzbf 50 nm, Òº 200 nm ;ê~ V¢ <º ;~ ;çj ¾æÚ
®î.
− z+B "CÖzb~ · Ã&> Ñ ® Ò~ Ï
* ";öB ÒÒ~ Öz 5 "C~ ~öö ~ j& >
wf væ² ¾æÒb, .VÎNö ®ÚB
~ 6²¢ .¾~&.
− "C Özbò z+>îj ãÖ .V ÒöBº raw MCMBö j~ çßB Ïïj "æò Òö ê
¯Nö V¢ ÒÒ" "C~ . >w~ >ö ~ ¦b æz 5 morphological æz Ò ßW~ &~¢
Fig. 10. Nyquist plots of surface-modified MCMB1028 at 2th cycle.
Fig. 11. C-rate effect of surface-modified MCMB1028.
{ > ®î. ¾ Ò >«~ 6²¢ Ö~V * inactive matrixB Ò¢ Î&~ Ò
>«j BF~&.
− &N O*öº z+B "CÖzb ÒÒ" alloying reactionj ¢bÊVö Ϫ *j <² >æò, N O
*öBº ç&'b >w * *² >Ú .³ z+ Î"~ 'Ëj A² >î.
− z+B "CÖzb~ · Ã&ö V¢ êöB~
impedanceº 6²j { > ®îb, 6 "CÖz b z+F ãÖ *êW~ Ã& Ïï çß>º
©b 6>î. ¾ jW matrix j ~º Ò~ Î&º Ò >«f BFVæò êöB~
impedanceº Ã&ʺ Ö"¢ .¾~&.
^^ò
[1] Murphy, D. W.; Cardies, J. N. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1979, 126, 349.
[2] Lazzari, M.; Scrosati, B. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1980, 127, 773.
[3] Auborn, J. J.; Barberio, Y. L. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1987, 134, 638.
[4] Yang, J.; Winter, M.; Besenhard, J. O. Solid State Ionics 1996, 90, 281.
[5] Besenhard, J. O.; Yang, J.; Winter, M. J. Power Sources 1997, 68, 87.
[6] Brandt, K. J. Power Sources 1995, 54, 151.
[7] Brnadt, K. Solid State Ionics 1994, 69, 173.
[8] Winter, M.; Besenhard, J. O.; Spahr, M. E.; Novak, P. Adv.
Mater. 1998, 10, 725.
[9] Dey, N. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1971, 118, 1547.
[10] Baliga, B. J.; Ghandhi, S. K. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1976, 123, 941.
[11] Chow, T. P.; Ghezzo, M.; Baliga, B. J. J. Electrochem. Soc.
1982, 129, 1040.
[12] Courtney, I. A.; Dahn, J. R. Progress in Batteries and Bat- tery Materials 1997, 16, 214.
[13] Courtney, I. A.; Dahn, J. R. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1997, 144, 2045.
[14] Huggins, R. A. “Handbook of battery Materials”, Part III, ch. 4. ed. Besenhard, J. O. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 1999, 359.