Study on Partition Function Zeros by Using the Monte Carlo Method

(1)

Ã X

Ø? _ õ u §z º U ê s0 n Éù p § T Ó Þ X ¢ Ä Z Ø9 0] K ¤ ¤ ¿ R < T Â ] Ø ì Å

»ûBa:@

² D

GwnØæÅÒ@/<Æ§ §ªõ&ñÂÒ, ØæÅÒ 380-702

ø¶B)Ö< · ».> *> ^∗

Õ ü

æz´@/<Æ§ Óüto<Æõ x9 ìr[O>½¨G'p', "fÖ¦ 156-743 (2009¸ 4Z4 20{9 ~ÃÎ6£§)

L × L y sfç¸+þA(L = 4 ∼ 20)\"f 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZOÜ¼Ð %3Ér H&h ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦

^

>&hs¦ ½¨^&hÜ¼Ð ¶ú(RÐ¤. >_ ß¼l &4R¸ Óüto&hÜ¼Ð _p eH 'Í P: Hõ Õª ÅÒ 0

A\"fH 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO_ H&h õ &ñSX<Ê`¦ ·ú Ãº e%3. \P%i<Æ&h FGôÇ\"f 7H_\¦

Ð «ÑÐÂÒ' e>&h °úכÜ¼Ð 0.4209(78)`¦ %3%3Ü¼ 9 \P»¡¤'tÃº °úכÜ¼Ð 0.992(55)`¦ %3%3. %3x9ôÇ

õ[þtõ q§KÐ s[þt °úכ[þtÉr 1 % ?/ü@_ ¸ \¦ Ð%i.

PACS numbers: 05.50.+q, 05.70.−a, 64.60.Cn, 75.10.Hk Keywords: ìrC<ÊÃº H, 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO, sfç¸+þA

I. "e Â]Ø

>\"f © Ð¼#&h &³© ©sü< e>&³©

`

¦ [O"î l 0AôÇ ìrC<ÊÃº H(partition function zeros) s

:rÉr 1952¸\ ª(Yang)õ o(Lee)\ _K %6£§Ü¼Ð ]

jîß÷&%3 [1]. 1964¸\ x39(Fisher) 4¤èÃº :r¸

¨ î

(complex temperature plane)\"f_ ìrC<ÊÃº H_

>

h¥Æ`¦ ]jîß ¦ [2] 1983¸\ ìrC<ÊÃº H_ Ä»ôÇ-ß¼l

»

¡

¤'(finite-size scaling) ZOgË:s ¸{9÷&"f [3], ©s ü

< e>&³©\ 'aôÇ ªôÇ s:r[þt ×æ\"f ìrC<ÊÃº H s

:rs © ÅÒ3lq~ÃÎl r %i. þjH\ [þt#Qü<"f ( É

Ó' ×¼J?#Q x9 7H_\¦Ð(Monte Carlo) ~½ÓZOs Ø

Ô> µ1Ï # 4¤èÃº :r¸ ¨î\"f_ ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt

`

¦ z´6 x&hÜ¼Ð >íß H כ s 0px > ÷&"f ìrC<Ê Ã

º H s:r`¦ s6 xôÇ ½¨ 7HëH[þt_ Ãº q&hÜ¼Ð Zþt

#

Qz¤ [4–30]. ìrC<ÊÃº H s:r_ :x&h &h6 xìr

:x>Óütoü< 6£x|9Óüto ü@\¸ ÙþÓüto [11–13], {9Óüt o

[14–21] x9 ÒqtÓüt<Æ [22–30] ìr 1px\"f¸ ìrC<ÊÃº H s

:rs Ö¸µ1Ï > 6 x÷&¦ e. þjH_ 6£x6 x\"f © Z

tîr &hÉr z´+«>Óüto<Æ($í^ [8–10] x9 "é¶Ùþ [11,12]

1 p

x)\"f %3#Q X<s'_ ìr$3\"f¸ ìrC<ÊÃº H s:r s

6 x÷&¦ eH &hs.

ì

rC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ ½¨ l 0AK"f © ´ú§s s6 x÷&¦ e

H ~½ÓZOÉr þjH\ µ1ÏôÇ &³@/&h 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO

∗§ $: [email protected]

s

[4–6,15–28]. &ñSXôÇ ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ %3l 0AK"f

H $ ìrC<ÊÃº\¦ %3x9 > ·ú ôÇ. tëß 7H _

\¦Ð ~½ÓZO`¦ s6 x ìrC<ÊÃº\¦ H&hÜ¼Ðëß ·ú Ã

º e. "f 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZOÜ¼ÐH &ñSXôÇ ìrC<Ê Ã

º H[þt`¦ ·ú Ãº \O.

1984¸\ oo(Marinari)H 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO`¦ s

6 x # éßíH{9~½Ó(simple-cubic lattice) sfç¸ +

þ

A(Ising model)_ ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ >íß %i [4]. éß í

H{9~½Ó sfç¸+þA_ âÄº 4 × 4 × 4 \"f %3x9 ô

Ç ìrC<ÊÃº ·ú94R e [31]. ooH 4 × 4 × 4

\"f &ñSXôÇ ìrC<ÊÃº H[þtõ 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZOÜ¼Ð

% 3

Ér H&h ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ q§ # (Óüto&hÜ¼Ð _

p eH) ª_ z´Ãº»¡¤\ © îr ìrC<ÊÃº H - :

x©&hÜ¼Ð 'Í P: H(first zero) ¢¸H ¸ H(leading zero)s¦ Ô¦aË> - Ér "fÐ _ {9u<Ê`¦ ·úÍÇx. 7£¤ 4 × 4 × 4 éßíH{9~½Ó sfç¸+þA\"fH 7H_\¦Ð ~½Ó Z

O

Ü¼Ð %3Ér H&h 'Í P: H`¦ ø@½+É Ãº e. t

ëß 4 × 4 × 4 éßíH{9~½Ó sfç¸+þA\"f_ õëßÜ¼

Ð Ér ¸H Óüto>\"f 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZOÜ¼Ð %3Ér H

&h ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt_ õ[þt`¦ &ñ{©o½+É ÃºH \O.

s

7HëH\"fH :r(Onsager)_ &ñSXôÇ K(exact solution) [32] >rF H ÅÒl&h â>¸| (periodic boundary conditions)`¦ L × L y(square lattice) sfç¸+þA(L = 4 ∼ 20)_ ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ Mg-êøÍ

Äº(Wang-Landau) 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO [33]Ü¼Ð ½¨ 9¦ -667-

(2)

ô

Ç. sXO> %3Ér H&h ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt_ õ[þt`¦

% 3

x9ôÇ õ[þtõ q§ # 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZOÜ¼Ð %3Ér H

&h ìrC<ÊÃº H[þt`¦ s6 xôÇ ©sü< e>&³©

½

¨[þt\ @/ôÇ ø@¸\¦ &ñ|¾Ó&hÜ¼Ð 0puKÐ¦ s[þt

½

¨[þt\ @/ôÇ ½+Ëo&h &ñ{©$í`¦ ÂÒ# 9¦ ôÇ.

II. TÇSË{¢]kù

þ

jH]X sÖ© © ñ6 x(½+Ë[jl J)õ ÅÒl&h â>¸

|

`¦ L × L y sfç¸+þAÉr H = −JX

hi,ji

σiσj (1)

_

Kx9Ðmîß\ _K"f &ñ_)a. #l\"f σiH

&

h

 i(= 1, 2, ..., L²)\"f |9 Ãº eH Û¼2; °úכÜ¼Ð +1õ

−1`¦ 2[½+É Ãº eÜ¼ 9, ½+ËÉr ¸H 2L²>h_ þjH]X sÖ© [

þ

t(nearest neighbors)\ @/ôÇ כ s. %ò ¢¸H ª_ &ñÃº

° ú

כëß`¦ 2[½+É Ãº eH \-t E\¦ 6£§õ °ú s &ñ_ E = 1

2 X

hi,ji

(1 − σiσj) (2)

K

x9Ðmîß`¦ H = 2J(E − L²)ü< °ú s jþt Ãº e.

d

(2)\¦ s6 x ¸H 0pxôÇ ©I[þt\ @/ôÇ ½+Ë ìr C

<ÊÃº

Z = X

{σn}

e^−βH (3)

\

¦(βH kBT _ %iÃºs 9 kBH ^¦ÞÔëß ©Ãº, T H :r¸s

) 6£§õ °ú s jþt Ãº e.

Z(y) = e^2βJL²

2L²

X

E=0

Ω(E)y^E (4)

#

l\"f Ω(E)H ©Ix9¸(density of states)s¦ yH e^−2βJÐ &ñ_)a ªs. Ãº yH T = 0\"f 0s¦ T =

∞\"f 1sl M:ëH\ ÁºôÇôÇ ^ :r¸ %ò%i`¦ 0õ 1 s

_ Ä»ôÇôÇ ½¨çßÜ¼Ð ³ð&³K ïr.

'

pàÔÐxH ©Ix9¸ Ω(E)\ ÐÕª\¦ 2[ %3

# Q.

S(E) = kBln Ω(E) (5)

"f ìrC<ÊÃº Z(y)H 6£§õ °ú s ³ð&³)a.

Z(y) = e^2βJL²

2L²

X

E=0

exph S(E) k_B

i

y^E (6)

III. ÃXØ?_õu§zº Uês0nÉ

Å

Òl&h â>¸| `¦ y sfç¸+þA\"fH :r

> %3`¦ Ãº e [34]. s 7HëH\"fH Mg-êøÍÄº 7H _

9¦ ôÇ. Mg-êøÍÄº ~½ÓZO\"fH p(E1→ E2) = min

"

Ω(E1) Ω(E2), 1

#

(7) _

sSXÒ¦(transition probability)`¦ s6 xôÇ [5, 33].

#

l\"f \-t E1H ×þ)a Û¼2;`¦ +'|9l(spin flip)

_ >_ \-ts¦ E2H +'|9Ér Êê_ \-ts.

$

q

t$íôÇ [5,33].

M

(modification factor) f (> 1)\¦ 6£§õ °ú s

Ω(E) → f Ω(E) (8)

6 xôÇH &hs. 'Í P: Mg-êøÍÄº 7H_\¦Ð r Ð

3

x?/l(simulation)\"fH Ãº&ñ\¦ f1= eÐ ×þ 9, M

g-êøÍÄº 7H_\¦Ð rÐ3x?/l ìøÍ4¤Hd\ Ãº&ñ

(i = 2, 3, ..., 30)\¦ fi=p

fi−1 (9)

Ð ×þôÇ [33]. s 7HëH\"fH 30r_ Mg-êøÍÄº 7H_

\¦Ð rÐ3x?/l\¦ z´'Ùþ¡Ü¼Ù¼Ð þj7áx&h Ãº&ñH f30= exp³ 1

2²⁹

´

= 1.00000000186 (10) s

. "f t}\H Ãº&ñ_ ´òõ _ \O#Q

"

f C0lw(Bhanot)_ 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO [5]õ Ä»K .

Ã

º&ñ f1\¦ s6 xôÇ Mg-êøÍÄº 7H_\¦Ð rÐ3x

?

Ã

\¦Ð ~½ÓZO[þtÐ s` ØÔ> "é¶ H õ\¦ %3`¦ Ã

º e.

s

7HëH\"fH L×L y sfç¸+þA\ @/K"f 31×

L²×10⁶_ 7H_\¦Ð íß`¦ Ãº' %i. 7£¤ L = 6\

"

fH 1.12 × 10⁹_ íß`¦ %i¦ L = 12\"fH 4.46 × 10⁹_ íß`¦ %iÜ¼ 9 L = 20\"fH 1.24 × 10¹⁰ _

íß`¦ z´' %i. Fig. 1Ér 14 × 14 y sfç

¸+þA\ @/K"f :r KÐÂÒ' %3Ér &ñSXôÇ 'pàÔÐx ü

< Mg-êøÍÄº 7H_\¦Ð ~½ÓZO`¦ s6 x # %3Ér H&h

'pàÔÐx\¦ <Êa Ð#ÅÒ¦ e. ÕªaË>`¦ Ð ¿º 'p à

ÔÐx _ {9u<Ê`¦ ·ú Ãº e.

Study on Partition Function Zeros by Using the Monte Carlo Method

Ã X

Ø? _ õ u §z º U ê s0 n Éù p § T  Ó Þ X ¢ Ä Z Ø9 0] K ¤ ¤ ¿ R < T Â ] Ø  ì Å 

Ø? _ õ u §z º U ê s0 n Éù p § T Ó Þ X ¢ Ä Z Ø9 0] K ¤ ¤ ¿ R < T Â ] Ø ì Å