한수지 49(6), 766-771, 2016
766
Copyright © 2016 The Korean Society of Fisheries and Aquatic Science pISSN:0374-8111, eISSN:2287-8815
Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 49(6),766-771,2016
Original Article
서 론
굴
(Crassostrea gigas)
은다른어패류와는달리상쾌하면서시 원한풍미를지니고있으며,
이로인하여굴과그가공부산물 들은오래전부터수산가공및조리분야에서풍미계조미소재 로주목을받아왔다.
또한근년들어글루탐산나트륨(monoso- dium glutamate, MSG)
과같은생합성발효조미료의안전성문 제및미각의다양화,
고급화에수반하여다양한풍미를지닌천 연어패류소스,
과립상또는분말조미료같은풍미계천연조미료의수요가증가하는추세에있다
.
저자등은상품성을거의 상실한장기저장개체동결(individually quick-frozen, IQF)
굴 을이용하여풍미계조미료의주소재로활용할수있는유효엑 스분의복합추출조건과향미증진을위한reaction flavoring
최 적화반응조건을구명하였고,
이를이용한굴소스의개발및품 질특성에관하여보고한바있다(Hwang et al., 2014; Hwang et al., 2015).
지금까지굴의식품학적성분특성과이용,
그리고 굴통조림제조시부산물로얻어지는굴자숙액의효율적이용 에대하여국내외에서연구가수행되어져왔으나,
이들연구의개체동결 굴(Crassostrea gigas) 엑스분을 이용한 굴 풍미계 과립조미료의 제조 및 품질특성
황석민·조준현
1·김상현
2·이인석
1·오광수
3*
한국국제대학교 외식조리학과, 1경상대학교 해양식품생명의학과, 2부산테크노파크 해양생물산업육성센터,
3경상대학교 해양식품생명의학과/농업생명과학연구원
Processings and Quality Characteristics of the Oyster Crassostrea gigas Granular Flavor Seasoning from IQF Oyster Extract
Seok-Min Hwang, Jun-Hyun Cho
1
, Sang-Hyun Kim2
, In-Seok Lee1
and Kwang-Soo Oh3
*Department of Food Service and Culinary, International University of Korea, Jinju 2833, Korea
1
Department of Seafood and Aquaculture Science, Gyeongsang National University, Tongyeong 53064, Korea
2
Marine Life Industry Promotion Center, Busan Technopark, Busan 64048, Korea
3
Department of Seafood and Aquaculture Science/Institute of Agriculture and Life Science, Gyeongsang National University, Tongyeong 53064, Korea
The pacific oyster Crassostrea gigas has a desirable taste and flavor that differs from those of other fish and shellfish.
In order to develop a high value-added product from individually quick-frozen oyster extract (IQFOE), we prepared an oyster granular flavor seasoning (OGS) from IQFOE and characterized its qualities. The OGS was prepared by granular molding and fluidized bed drying with inosine monophosphate (IMP, 0.1%), yeast extract powder (1.4%), tangle extract powder (0.6%), monosodium glutamate (MSG, 5.0%), microcrystalline cellulose (0.6%), lactose (27.5%), salt (33.0%), spray-dried IQFOE (22.5%) as a powdered materials, and IQFOE (Brix 25°, 7.0%), soy sauce (0.4%) and water (1.7%) as a liquid materials. The moisture, crude protein, pH and salinity of the OGS were 3.4%, 12.5%, 6.50 and 32.0%, respectively. Especially, the OGS revealed very higher amino-N content (1,856.0 mg/100 g) than that (1,291.2-1,610.2 mg/100 g) of other commercial flavor seasonings. In taste-active compounds, free amino acid contents was 1,359.0 mg/100 g, and major ones were glutamic acid, taurine, hydroxyproline, glycine, lysine, phosphoserine, proline in order. And OGS showed good organoleptic qualities for taste, odor and general preference compared with commercial flavor seasonings on a local market.
Key words: IQF oyster, Complex extract, Granular flavor seasoning
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licens (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
http://dx.doi.org/10.5657/KFAS.2016.0766 Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 49(6) 766-771, December 2016
Received 24 October 2016; Revised 4 December 2016; Accepted 5 December 2016
*Corresponding author: Tel: +82. 55. 772. 9144 Fax: +82. 55. 772. 9149
E-mail address: [email protected]
굴 과립조미료의 제조 및 품질특성
767
대부분은굴의성분특성
,
굴자숙액의탈염,
효소가수분해물의 추출조건및풍미성분에관한내용이주류를이루고있다(Lee et al., 1990; Shiau and Chai, 1990; Oh, 1998; Park et al., 2000;
Chung et al., 2006; Kang et al., 2010; Lee et al., 2012; Hwang and Oh, 2013; Hwang et al., 2014).
일부가공품에관한연구 도굴엑스분의단순가공품인굴소스(Hwang et al., 2015)
또는 분말조미료의개발에관한것으로상품성을거의상실한IQF
굴의유효활용과고부가가치를창출할수있는독자적인가공 품의개발에관련된연구는아직까지보고된바없다.
따라서 본연구에서는상기의IQF
굴유래복합엑스분을주소재로하 여풍미계천연조미료로활용할수있는굴과립조미료(oyster granular seasoning)
를제조하였고,
본시제품의성분조성및품 질특성에대하여살펴보았다.
재료 및 방법
재료
재료로사용한
IQF
굴(Crassostrea gigas)
은동결저장기간 이18
개월이상경과한것으로D
사(
경남통영시)
에서구입하여-20℃
동결고에저장하면서실험에사용하였다. IQF
굴복합엑스분의조제및풍미개선을위한조향
(reaction flavoring)
은전 보(Hwang et al., 2014)
에서구명한최적화조건에준하여실시 하였다.
본실험에사용한각종재료(ingredient)
는MSC (
주,
경 남양산시)
와인근마트에서구입하여사용하였다.
한편,
본굴 과립조미료의품질평가를위해2
종의유사풍미계조미료시 판품,
즉바지락과립조미료및홍합분말조미료를인근마트에 서구입하여실험에사용하였다.
굴 과립조미료의 제조
굴과립조미료의제조공정은
Fig. 1
과같다.
먼저Table 1
과같 은조성비로IMP,
분말효모추출물,
분말다시마추출물,
글루 탐산나트륨(MSG),
결정성셀루로오즈및유당을혼합한조미 베이스분말(seasoning base powder)
에식염, IQF
굴복합엑스 분분무건조분말및유당을혼합하여분체원료(powdered ma- terial)
를조제하였다.
여기에IQF
굴복합엑스분(Brix 25˚),
양 조간장및정제수등액상원료(liquid materials)
를첨가하여리 본믹서기(RM-100, Daelim Machine Co., Korea)
로혼합하였 다.
다음이를압출기(KCT 40, Kumsan Precision Co., Korea)
로과립성형·
조립하고,
유동층건조기(DSM-FD200, Daesung Chemical Machinery Ind. Co., Korea)
로60-65℃
에서유동층 건조시킨후냉각및선별과정을거쳐서굴과립조미료를제조 하였다.
굴과립조미료부원료의첨가량과조성비(formula)
는 시판유사조미료의성분조성을참고하였으며,
예비관능시험 을통하여결정하였다. Fig. 1
의제조공정에따라제조한굴과립 조미료시제품은Fig. 2
와같다.
일반성분, pH 및 염도
Table 1. Optimal formula of ingredients for the oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning
Material Ingredient Ratio (%)
Powdered
materials Seasoning base powder
IMP 0.1
Yeast extract powder 1.4 Tangle extract powder 0.6 Monosodium
glutamate (MSG) 5.0
Microcrystalline cellulose 0.6
Lactose 13.0
Powdered materials
Salt 33.3
Spray-dried IQF oyster complex extract 22.4
Lactose 14.5
Liquid materials
IQF oyster complex extract (Brix 25°) 7.0
Soy sauce 0.4
Water 1.7
Total 100.0
Salt IQF oyster extracts powder
Seasoning base
powders1 Lactose
Powdered material
Liquid material1 Mixing
Granular molding Fluidize bed drying (60-65℃)
Cooling (30℃) Screening (10-20 mesh)
Granular seasoning Cooling
Packaging inspection and Metal detection Retort pouched oyster soup
Blanching (90℃, 30 s)
Filling in
retort pouch
Base soup stock
1Oyster complex extract
Other ingredientsSealing
Hot-water circulating retort sterilization (Fo-value 10 min)
140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0
POS-1 POS-2
Temp. ( ℃ ) Fo -value (min.)
1 6 11 16 21 26 31 36 41 46 51 56
Processing time (min.)
POS-1 POS-2
12 10 8 6 4 2 0
Fig. 1. Flow sheet for preparation of the IQF oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning.1,2Refer to the comment in Table 1.
일반성분의조성은상법
(KSFSN, 2000a)
에따라수분함량은 상압가열건조법,
조단백질함량은semimicro Kjeldahl
법,
조지 방함량은Soxhlet
법,
회분함량은건식회화법으로측정하였다.
pH
는시료에10
배량의순수를가하여균질화한다음pH meter
(Accumet Basic, Fisher Sci. Co., USA)
로측정하였고,
염도는 염도계(Salt meter ES-421, Atago Co., Japan)
로측정하였다.
황석민
ㆍ
조준현ㆍ
김상현ㆍ
이인석ㆍ
오광수768
휘발성염기질소, 아미노질소 및 TBA 값
휘발성염기질소
(volatile basic nitrogen, VBN)
는Conway unit
를사용하는미량확산법(KSFSN, 2000b)
으로측정하였고,
아미노질소(NH
2-N)
함량은Formol
적정법(Ohara, 1982)
으로 측정하였다. TBA
값(thiobarbituric acid value)
은시료5 g
을 정평한후Tarladgis et al. (1960)
의수증기증류법으로측정하 였다.
색조
색조는직시색차계
(color meter ZE-2000, Nippon Denshoku Ltd., Japan)
를사용하여시료의표면색조에대한L
값(
명도), a
값(
적색도), b
값(
황색도)
및ΔE
값(
색차)
을측정하였다.
이 때표준백판(standard plate)
의L, a
및b
값은각각99.98, 0.01
및0.01
이었다.
유리아미노산
시료에
3
배량의70% ethanol
용액을 가하여 균질기(Ultra Turrax T25, IKA, Janke & Kunkel GmbH & Co., Germany)
로균질화한후15
분간원심분리(5,000 g)
하였다.
이상등액 과이조작을2
회더반복하여얻은상등액을모아감압농축한 후증류수로일정량정용하였고,
여기에5’-sulfosalicylic acid
및
ether
를 첨가하여하룻밤방치한다음여과하여 유리아미노산분석용시료액으로사용하였다
.
유리아미노산은시료액 을일정량취해감압건고한다음, 0.20 M lithium citrate buf- fer (pH 2.20)
로정용한후아미노산자동분석기(Biochrom 30, Biochrom. LTD, England)
로분석하였다.
관능검사
관능검사
panel
은시판패류풍미계조미료의관능적특성에익숙하도록훈련시킨
20
대의남자5
명과여자4
명으로구성하 였다.
관능검사는시판바지락과립조미료를3
점기준(
보통)
으 로하여굴과립조미료와시판홍합분말조미료의맛,
냄새,
색 조및종합적기호도등풍미에대한관능적특성을5
단계평점 법(5,
매우좋다; 4,
좋다; 3,
보통이다; 2,
좋지않다; 1,
매우좋 지않다)
으로평가하였다.
통계처리
실험결과에대한통계처리는
SAS program (Statistical ana- lytical system V9.1.3)
을이용하여One way ANOVA
법으로 분산분석을 실시하였으며,
평가 항목들 간의 유의성검정은Duncan
의다중검정법으로P<0.05
수준에서실시하였다(Kim and Goo, 2001).
결과 및 고찰
일반성분
굴과립조미료시제품과시판중인유사풍미계조미료
2
종,
바 지락과립조미료및홍합분말조미료의일반성분을측정한결 과는Table 2
와같다.
굴과립조미료시제품의수분은3.4%,
조 단백질12.5%,
회분33.6%
로수분과단백질의경우시판유사 제품과서로비슷하였으나,
회분의경우는시판유사제품들과 약간의함량차이를보였다.
이는과립혹은분말조미료제조시 첨가하는식염량의차이에서기인한것으로보인다.
pH, 염도, TBA 값, 아미노질소 및 휘발성염기질소 함량
굴과립조미료시제품및시판유사조미료2
종의pH,
염도, TBA
값,
아미노질소및휘발성염기질소함량을분석,
비교한 결과는Table 3
과같다.
본시제품의pH
는6.50
로시판풍미계 조미료의6.02
에비해다소높았고,
염도는32.0%
로유사시판 품의39.0
및40.4%
에비해다소낮았다.
제품제조중TBA
값 은본시제품이0.044
로시판품의0.163
및0.204
에비해매우 낮아시제품제조중지방질의산화가거의일어나지않았으며,
Table 2. Proximate composition of the oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning and commercial flavor seasonings
(g/100 g)
Product1 Moisture Crude
protein Ash Crude
lipid OGS 3.4±0.2b 12.5±0.2b 33.6±0.1a 0.3±0.1a
C-1 3.2±0.3b 11.1±0.2a 42.2±0.2b 0.3±0.1a C-2 2.8±0.2a 11.6±0.4ab 44.6±0.2b 1.0±0.2b
1OGS, oyster granular flavor seasoning by IQF oyster complex extract.C-1, short-neck clam granular flavor seasoning on Korean market.C-2, dried mussel flavor seasoning powder on Korean market. a-bMeans within each column followed by the same letter are not statistically different (P<0.05).
Fig. 2. Oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning.
이에따른산패취나갈변의발생도극히적었을것으로생각되 었다
.
한편,
주된정미성분인유리아미노산의함량을간접적으 로알수있는아미노질소함량은본시제품이1,856.0 mg/100 g
으로시판품의1,291.2
및1,610.2 mg/100 g
에비해상당한 함량차이를보였다.
또한, Table 5
에서와같이시판품에다량 의MSG(glutamic acid, 508.7 mg/100 g)
가포함되어있음을 고려하면,
본시제품에함유된아미노질소성분의대부분은천 연유리아미노산으로양질의천연풍미계조미료로손색이없 었다.
선도및어패류특유의냄새발현에관여하는휘발성염 기질소(VBN)
함량은시제품이12.6 mg/100 g
으로시판품의6.9
및8.1 mg/100 g
에비해다소높았다.
이는핵심정미소재 로서첨가한IQF
굴유래복합엑스분(Brix 25°)
과굴복합엑스 분의영향으로시제품의다양한풍미발현에크게기여할것으 로생각되었다
.
색조
굴과립조미료시제품및시판유사조미료
2
종의표면색조 를직시색차계로측정한결과는Table 4
와같다.
시제품은명도(L
값) 82.2,
적색도(a
값) 1.8,
황색도(b
값) 11.5, ΔE
값(
색차)
은17.5
로서시판바지락과립조미료와유사하였고,
홍합분말조 미료에비해서는상당히밝은색조를나타내었다.
유리아미노산 함량
굴과립조미료시제품과시판바지락과립조미료의유리아미 노산함량을분석비교한결과는
Table 5
와같다.
함질소엑스분 중수산식품의풍미발현에taste-active component
로작용하는 유리아미노산의총함량은시제품이1,359.0 mg/100 g
으로시 판바지락과립조미료의801.3 mg/100 g
에비해월등히많이 함유되어있었다.
시제품의주요유리아미노산으로는glutamic
acid
가335.4 mg/100 g
으로가장많았으며,
그다음이taurine 233.4 mg/100 g, hydroxyproline 122.2 mg/100 g, glycine 91.1 mg/100 g, lysine 81.1 mg/100 g, phosphoserine 72.1 mg/100 g
및proline 55.3 mg/100 g
등의순으로정미성아미노산들이 Table 5. Free amino acid contents of the oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning and commercial short-neck clam granu-lar flavor seasoning (mg/100 g)
Amino acid1 Product2
OGS C-1
PS 72.1 (5.3) 57.1 (7.1)
Taurine 233.4 (17.1) 30.9 (3.9)
PE 37.6 (2.8) 22.4 (2.8)
Hydroxyproline 122.2 (9.0) 67.0 (8.4)
Threonine 11.5 (0.8) 5.3 (0.7)
Serine 13.9 (1.0) 6.0 (0.7)
Glutamic acid 335.4 (24.7) 508.7 (63.5)
AAAA 12.8 (1.0) 1.3 (0.2)
Proline 55.3 (4.1) 7.5 (0.9)
Glycine 91.1 (6.7) 14.6 (1.8)
Alanine 33.2 (2.4) 13.2 (1.6)
Citruline 3.1 (0.3) 1.3 (0.2)
AABA 3.9 (0.3) 1.3 (0.2)
Valine 11.0 (0.8) 5.4 (0.7)
Cystine/2 33.8 (2.5) 12.8 (1.6)
Methionine 9.0 (0.6) 3.4 (0.4)
Isoleucine 37.4 (2.8) 5.2 (0.6)
Leucine 43.3 (3.2) 8.7 (1.1)
Tyrosine 5.2 (0.4) 1.3 (0.2)
ß-Alanine 30.5 (2.2) 3.5 (0.4)
Phenylalanine 11.3 (0.8) 4.9 (0.6)
GABA 23.8 (1.8) 5.7 (0.7)
Lysine 81.1 (6.0) 3.6 (0.4)
Histidine 19.4 (1.4) 5.3 (0.7)
Arginine 27.7 (2.0) 4.9 (0.6)
Total 1,359.0 (100.0) 801.3 (100.0)
1PS, phosphoserine; PE, phosphoethanolamine; AAAA, a-amino- adipic acid; AABA, a-aminoisobutyric acid; GABA, γ-aminobu- tyric acid. 2Refer to the comment in Table 2.
Table 3. Quality characteristics of the oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning and commercial flavor seasonings
Product1 pH Salinity (g/100 g) TBA value (O.D. 531 nm) NH2-N (mg/100 g) VBN (mg/100 g)
OGS 6.50±0.01b 32.0±0.2a 0.044±0.010c 1,856.0±17.4c 12.6±0.11c
C-1 6.02±0.01a 39.0±0.4b 0.204±0.009b 1,291.2±11.2a 8.1±0.14b
C-2 6.02±0.01a 40.4±0.1b 0.163±0.012a 1,610.2±43.5b 6.9±0.33a
1Refer to the comment in Table 2.a-cMeans within each column followed by the same letter are not statistically different (P<0.05).
Table 4. Color value of the oyster Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning and commercial flavor seasonings
Product1 Color value
L a b
⊿
EOGS 82.2±0.3b 1.8±0.0b 11.5±0.2a 17.5±0.6a C-1 84.5±0.2b 1.0±0.1a 11.8±0.1a 16.6±0.5a C-2 63.9±0.4a 10.3±0.2c 23.9±0.2b 41.6±0.5b
1Refer to the comment in Table 2.a-cMeans within each column fol- lowed by the same letter are not statistically different (P<0.05).
황석민
ㆍ
조준현ㆍ
김상현ㆍ
이인석ㆍ
오광수770
비교적고루함유되어있었다
.
반면,
시판바지락과립조미료의 경우는glutamic acid
가508.7 mg/100 g
으로전체의60%
이상 을차지하고있었는데,
이는정미보강을위하여다량의MSG
를 첨가하였기때문으로추정되었다.
그외hydroxyproline, phos- phoserine
및taurine
을제외한나머지아미노산들의함량은미 미하였다.
이러한유리아미노산조성의차이는glutamic acid
에서유래하는감칠맛의경우비록시판품이다소강할지는모 르나,
전체적인풍미의조화나다양한천연의정미발현은시제 품이훨씬우수할것으로보인다.
여러연구자들(Hayashi et al., 1978; Hayashi et al., 1981; Kim, 1985)
은자숙게육의정미성 분중유리아미노산류가무기질과더불어가장중요한정미발 현성분이었으며,
이중특히glutamic acid, glycine, arginine
및alanine
등의역할이컸다고보고한바있다.
관능검사
시판바지락과립조미료를기준
(
관능평점3.0)
으로하여시 제품및시판홍합분말조미료의관능적품질을맛,
향기,
색깔 및종합적기호도면에대하여평가한결과는Table 6
과같다. Table 6
에서와같이시제품은맛,
향기및종합평가면에서시판품에비해월등히높은평점을받았으며
, 5%
유의수준에서타시료와유의적차이가있는것으로나타났다
.
이상의결과로미루어
IQF
굴복합엑스분을주소재로제조한굴과립조미료는기존의시판풍미계조미료들과비교해보아도식품성분과관 능적품질면에서전혀손색이없었고
,
다양한풍미를갖는천연 조미료로충분히이용가능하다는결론을얻었다.
사 사
이논문은
2009
년도정부(
교육부)
의재원으로한국연구재단 의지원을받아수행된기초연구사업(No. 0074813)
의일부로 서이에감사드립니다.
References
Chung IK, Kim HS, Kang KT, Choi YJ, Choi JD, Kim JS and Heu MS. 2006. Preparation and functional properties of en- zymatic oyster hydrolysates. J Kor Soc Food Sci Nutr 35, 919-925.
Hayashi T, Yamaguchi K and Konosu S. 1978. Studies on flavor components in boiled crabs-Ⅱ. Bull Japanese Soc Sci Fish 44, 1357-1362.
Hayashi T, Yamaguchi K and Konosu S. 1981. Sensory analysis of taste-active components in the extract of boiled snow crab meat. J Food Sci 46, 479-483.
Hwang SM and Oh KS. 2013. Food component characteristics of dendely lamellated oyster(Ostrea denselamellosa) in Seomjin river. J Agric Life Sci 47, 167-176.
Hwang SM, Hwang YS, Nam SG, Lee JD, Ryu SG and Oh KS. 2014. Flavor improvement of a complex extract from poor-quality, individually quick-frozen oysters Crassostrea
gigas. Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 47, 733-739. http://dx.doi.
org/10.5657/KFAS.2014.0733.
Hwang YS, Kim SH, Kim BG, Kim SG, Cho JH and Oh KS.
2015. Processings and quality characteristics of the oys- ter sauce from IQF oyster Crassostrea gigas. Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 48, 833-838. http://dx.doi.org/10.5657/
KFAS.2015.0833
Kang JY, Roh TH, Hwang SM, Kim YA, Choi JD and Oh KS.
2010. The precursors and flavor constituents of the cooked oyster flavor. Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 43, 606-613. http://
dx.doi.org/KFAS.2010.0606.
Kim WJ and Goo KH. 2001. Food Sensory Evaluation Method.
Hyoil Pub Co., Seoul, Korea, 68-94.
Kim DH. 1985. Food Chemistry. Tamgudang, Seoul, Korea, 30- KSFSN. 2000a. Handbook of Experimental in Food Science 32.
and Nutrition. Hyoil Pub Co., Seoul, Korea, 96-127.
KSFSN. 2000b. Handbook of Experimental in Food Science and Nutrition. Hyoil Pub Co., Seoul, Korea, 625-627.
Lee YC, Kim DS, Kim YD and Kim YM. 1990. Preparation of oyster and sea mussel hydrolysates using commercial prote- ase. Kor J Food Sci Technol, 22, 234-240.
Lee YM, Lee SJ, Kim SG, Hwang YS, Jeong BY and Oh KS.
2012. Food components characteristics of cultured and wild oysters Crassostrea gigas... Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 45, 586-593. http://dx.doi.org/10.5657/KFAS. 2012.0586.
Oh KS. 1998. Processings of flavoring substances from low- utilized shellfishes. Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 31, 791-798.
http://dx.doi.org/10.5657/KFAS. 1998.0791.
Ohara T. 1982. Food Analysis Handbook. Kenpakusha Pub Co., Tokyo, Japan, 51-55.
Park PJ, Lee SH and Kim SK. 2000. Desalination of boiled oys- ter extract by electrodialysis. Kor J Biotechnol Bioeng 15, 167-173.
Shiau CY and Chai T. 1990. Characterization of oyster shucking liquid wastes and their utilization as oyster soup. J Food Sci Table 6. Sensory scores on the sensory evaluation of the oyster
Crassostrea gigas granular flavor seasoning and commercial flavor seasonings
Sample1 Item
Taste Odor Color Over-all
acceptance OGS 4.3±0.6c2 4.1±0.2c 2.8±0.1b 4.2±0.6c
C-1 3.0±0.0b 3.0±0.0b 3.0±0.0b 3.0±0.0b C-2 2.0±0.3a 1.8±0.6a 2.2±0.4a 2.0±0.5a
1Refer to the comment in Table 2. 25 scale score; 5, very good; 4, good; 3, acceptable; 2, poor; 1, very poor. a-cMeans within each column followed by the same letter are not statistically different (P<0.05).
55, 374-378.
Tarladgis ZG, Watts MW and Younathan MJ. 1960. A distilla- tion method for quantitative determination of malonalde- hyde in rancid food. J Am Oils Chem Soc 37, 44-48.