Effects of Bi(Zn
2/3Ta
1/3)O
3-Substitution on the Ferroelectric and Piezoelectric Properties of BiFeO
3-BaTiO
3Ceramics
Jin Su Park · Myang Hwan Lee · Da Jeong Kim · Myong-Ho Kim · Tae Kwon Song
∗School of Materials Science and Engineering, Changwon National University, Changwon 641-773, Korea
Sung Jin Han · Won-Jeong Kim
Department of Physics, Changwon National University, Changwon 641-773, Korea
Dalhyun Do
Department of Advanced Materials Engineering, Keimyung University, Daegu 704-701, Korea (Received 20 April 2015 : revised 7 June 2015 : accepted 23 June 2015)
Lead-free ceramics with compositions of (1-x)[0.67Bi1.05FeO3-0.33BaTiO3]-xBi(Zn2/3Ta1/3)O3(x
=0.00, 0.01, 0.02, 0.03, 0.04 and 0.05) [BF-BT-BZTx] were prepared through a conventional solid- state reaction method. The effects of BZT substitution on the crystal structural, microstructural, piezoelectric and electrical properties of the ceramics were investigated. The X-ray diffraction patterns showed that all ceramics were crystallized with the perovskite phase. The grain size decreased with increasing BZT content. For x = 0.02, good ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties were observed: 2Pr= 42 µC/cm2and 2Ec= 55 kV/cm. The static- and the dynamic-piezoelectric constants were observed to be 130 pC/N and 290 pm/V, respectively.
PACS numbers: 77.65.-j, 77.65.Ly, 77.80.-e, 77.84.Dy
Keywords: Piezoelectric, Ferroelectric, Lead-free, BiFeO3, BaTiO3
Bi(Zn
2/3Ta
1/3)O
3V ò ÿT & BiFeO
3-BaTiO
3: g à k Ä 8 ý P ê s ¥ ¹ Å õ m Í ° q ¹ Å ¤V R Ë; c Q
V À W ¥ W _ Ë] §
. > ¬ £ · T ' å Z 9 · » + ä · »' å Ú · ö ¶ B? - ! H
∗
½Ó"é¶@/<Ƨ èF /BN<ÆÂÒ, ½Ó"é¶ 641-773
 6
Ò) ç . > · » 4 w H+ ä
½Ó"é¶@/<Ƨ Ótüo<Æõ, ½Ó"é¶ 641-773
|
¡î m g ` @
>
"î@/<Ƨ èF/BN<ÆÂÒ, @/½¨ 704-701
(2015¸ 4Z4 20{9 ~ÃÎ6§, 2015¸£ 6Z4 7{9 ú&ñ:r~ÃÎ6£§, 2015¸ 64 23{Z 9 >FSX&ñ)
q
±ú> [jb (1-x)[0.67Bi1.05FeO3-0.33BaTiO3]-xBi(Zn2/3Ta1/3)O3 (x = 0.00, 0.01, 0.02, 0.03, 0.04 and 0.05) [BF-BT-BZTx]`¦ {9ìøÍ&h ¦©ìøÍ6£xZO`¦6s x # ]j¸ %i. BZT u¨8`¦ :x #
&ñ½¨¸, p[j½¨¸, ·ú$, í l&h :£¤$í`¦¸ %i. X- r]X J õ ¸H[jb\"f s
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
© \Os ` ÐÚÔÛ¼sàÔ ½¨¸\¦þA$+í Hכ `¦a'¹1Ï %i. p[j½¨¸ ±ú ·ú_ ß¼lH BZTªs 7£x
½
+Éú2¤ yè %i. x = 0.02 \"f a%~Ér y©Ä» :¤$£õí ·ú :£¤$ísa8'£¤÷&%3: 2Pr = 42 µC/cm2 Õ
ªo¦ 2Ec= 55 kV/cm. &ñ·úõ %i·ú©ÃºHyy 130 pC/N ü< 290 pm/VÐa8'£¤÷&%3.
PACS numbers: 77.65.-j, 77.65.Ly, 77.80.-e, 77.84.-s Keywords:·ú^, y©Ä»^, q±ú>[jb, BiFeO3, BaTiO3
I. " e  ] Ø
q
±ú> qÛ¼ÁºÛ¼\¦l:r¼ÜÐ ôÇ ` ÐÚÔÛ¼sàÔ ·ú [
jbÉr Pb(Zr,Ti)O3 (PZT)\¦ @/^½+É Óüt|9Ð"f ÅÒ3lq
~ Ã
Φ e. PZTH ĺúôÇ ·ú :£¤$í`¦ °úl M:ëH\ y 7
áx G'p"f x9 "loÆÓ\s'Ð"f V,o 6 x÷&¦ e. ÕªQ
±úÉr ^\ u"î&h ׿1q ël H]j\¦ÏÒµ1qt rv 9, ]j
¸õ&ñ\"f ´ú§rÉ Ä»KÓüt|9s µ1ÏÒqt÷&#Q ¨8â¸%i`¦ Ä» µ
1Ͻ+É Ãº eH ëH]j&h`¦ t¦ e [1–3]. s ëH]j
&
hܼР±ú`¦ í<Ê t ·ú§Ü¼"f a%~Ér ·ú:£¤$í`¦ t
H F«Ñ_ >hµ1Ïs 9כ¹ . &³F, ´ú§s ½¨ ÷&¦ eH q
±ú> ·ú F«Ñ_ ÊêÐÐ"f, (Bi0.5K0.5)TiO3 (BKT), (Bi,Na)TiO3 (BNT), (K0.5Na0.5)NbO3 (KNN) 1pxs a%~
É
r ·ú:£¤$`í¦ tH Üכ¼Ð Ц ÷&¦ e. ÕªX<
BiFeO3 (BF)H Z}Ér ©s Ç©o :r¸ (Tc ∼ 1,103 K) ü
< a%~Éry©Ä»$í`¦t¦ e [4–6]. tëß BF\¦ 6£x 6
x l 0AK"fH Z }Ér ¾º[OÀÓ\¦ tH ëH]j&hs e
. ¾º[OÀÓ\¦ צsl 0A # ±úÉr¾º[OÀÓü< a%~Ér·ú
:£¤$í`¦ tH BaTiO3 (BT)< ü ¦6 x^\¦ ëß[þt#Q ¾º [O
ÀÓ x9 ¾Ó©)a ·ú:£¤$í`¦ Ц ¦ e [7–9]. y© Ä
»:£¤$íÉr ïßÀÓ ìrFG (Pr)s 15 ∼ 22 µC/cm2, &ñ·ú
:£¤$í>ú d33H 43 ∼ 116 pC/N, %·iú:£¤$í 0AH 0.12 ∼ 0.14%`¦¸$ís x = 0.3 ∼ 0.4\"f Ц÷&¦ e
[10,11]. #l\ Bi\¦l:rܼРôÇ Bi(Mg1/2Ti1/2)O3 ü< Bi(Ni1/2Ti1/2)O3 ¦ (1-x)BiFeO\ 3-xBaTiO3ü< $í ì
r> ¦6 x^\¦ [ßëþt#Q 8¹¡¤ Ó¾©)a :£¤$í`¦ Ðs¦ e
[12–14]. þjH 0.71BF-0.29BT[jb\"f Bo\ (Mg1/3Nb2/3)4+\¦u¨8# 158 pC/N _ ¾Ó©)a·ú
:£¤$í`¦ Ц %i [15]. r: ½¨\"fH ©â>%ò
%
iܼР·ú94R eH 0.67Bi 1.05FeO3-0.33BaTiO3 [jb
\
(Mg1/3Nb2/3)4+ü< °ú Ér ú\¦ t¦ eH Znõ Ta\¦ ×þ # Bi\¦ lr:ܼРôÇ (Zn2/3Ta1/3)3+ u¨8
# ¦6 x^\¦ [ßëþt âĺ ¾Ó©)a ·ú :¤$£í`¦ l@/½+É Ã
º e#Q ½¨ %i. (1-x)[0.67Bi1.05FeO3-0.33BaTiO3]- xBi(Zn2/3Ta1/3)O3(x = 0.00, 0.01, 0.02, 0.03, 0.04, 0.05, BF-BT-BZTx)_ ¸$íܼР&½ñ¨¸, p[j½¨¸, y©Ä»
$í
, ·ú :£¤$í\ @/ôÇ ½¨\¦ ' %i.
∗E-mail: [email protected]
II. ÷ m Ç] M ö U ê s0 n É
BF-BT-BZTx (x = 0.00, 0.01, 0.02, 0.03, 0.04, 0.05) [
jbÉr {9ìøÍ&h ¦ ì© øÍ6£xZOܼРBi2O3, Fe2O3, BaCO3, TiO2, ZnO Õªo¦ Ta2O5 (>99.9%, Sigma- Aldrich) ìr´ú`¦ s6 x # ]j¸ %i. tØÔïm ^¦
`
¦s6 x # ¸$í\ gA|¾ÓôÇ ìr´ú`¦ú·ï`¦õ <Êa 12rçß 1lx ßîD¥½+Ë x9 ìrW %i. | ¸ Êê\ 700◦C\"f 2rçß 1lxîß 1 è (calcination) ¦, ìr´ú_ çH|9$í`¦ Z
}sl 0AK _þvd x9aAõ | ¸\¦ìøÍ4¤Êê 800◦C\"f 2r ç
ß 1lxîß 2 è %i. þj7áx èôÇ ìr´ú`¦+$íþA`¦0A ô
Ç ½+Ë]jÐ 5 wt% e¦o qu´ ·úï`¦`¦' # } µ
1Ï\"f ¦ÀÒ [OÉrÊê 150 µm ^Ð ^2£§ %i. r¼#_
$í
+þAÉr {9»¡¤·ú $í+AZþOܼР·ú§4`¦K, t2£§ 10 mm,
¿
ºa 0.6 mm_ "é¶óøÍ+þAIÐ r¼`#¦]j¸ %i. ¸H¸
$í
_ r¼#Ér 1,000◦C \"f è %i¦, ©:rt /åLÍt y
~½ÓZO`¦s6 x # [jb`¦]j¸ %i [16]. [jb_
½
¨¸H X- r]X ìr$3l (XRD, Miniflex II, Rigaku)\¦ s
6 x # ©:r\"f ¸ %i. [jb_ ³ð p[j½¨
¸HÅÒ &³pâ (SEM, JSM-5610, Jeol)`¦s6 x
#
¶ú(R Ф. l&h :£¤$`í¦ 8£¤&ñ l 0A # [jb
³
ð\ Û¼('aA`¦s6 x # ÑþFK~ÃÌ}`¦ ïhAôÇ Êê Õª 0
A\ Ér` sÛ¼àÔ\¦ s6 x # FG`¦ {9+ÀI. y©Ä» s
§ 4
/BGÉr Radiant_ Precision LC q©\¦s6 x # 10 Hz_ ÅÒú\"f 8£¤&ñ %i. ·ú:£¤$í`¦ 8£¤&ñ l 0A
#, z´oBH¸{9\ 30ìr1lxîß 66 kV/cm fÀÓ l©`¦
# ìrFG%o (poling) %i. &·ñú©ÃºH d33-p '
(ZJ-6B, HC Materials)\¦s6 x # 8¤&£ñ %i. %i·ú
´òõH]X8ú¤d 0A 8£¤&ñ G'p"f (LVDT, Millimar 1240, Mahr)\¦s6 x # 50 mHz_ ÅÒú\"f 8£¤&ñ %i. e x
~Û¼ ìr$3l (HP 4192A)\¦6 x # :r¸ o\
É
rÄ»©Ãº\¦ 8£¤&ñ %i.
III. + s ÇÊ Ý õ m Í À X Ø8 ý
Fig. 1Ér BF-BT-BZTx[jb_ X- r]X J`¦Ð
#
ÅÒ¦ e. 8£¤&ñ õ&ñ\"f µÏÒ1qt H ¸ \¦þjèo l
0A # z´oBH (99.999%) ìr´ú`¦s6 x # r]X y¸
Fig. 1. (Color online) X-ray diffraction patterns of BF- BT-BZTx ceramics.
Fig. 2. SEM microstructure images of (a) BF-BT- BZT0.00, (b) BF-BT-BZT0.01, (c) BF-BT-BZT0.02, (d) BF-BT-BZT0.03, (e) BF-BT-BZT0.04, and (f) BF-BT- BZT0.05.
\
¦ Ð&ñ %i. ¸H ¸$í\"f ` ÐÚÔÛ¼sàÔ ½¨¸\¦
Ðs¦ eܼ 9, 0xp&ñ>õ &ñ~½Ó&ñ>_ D¥Ë+½)a ½¨¸\¦
Ðs¦ eܼ 9, s ©ÉrÏ|1µ÷&t ·ú§¤. BZT u¨8
ª_ 7£x\ (110) xß¼ ±úÉr y Aá¤Ü¼Ð ¸FK ¹¡§ f
sHכ `¦'a¹1Ï½É Ã+º e. (110)xß¼_ s1lxÉr B-o s
:r Fe(0.645 nm), Ti(0.605 nm)_ ß¼l\ q # u¨8
)
as:r Zn(0.74 nm), Ta(0.64 nm)_ ß¼l &"f (110) x
ß¼ ±úÉry Aá¤Ü¼Ð s1lxôÇ כ ܼРÐ.
Fig. 2H BZTª\ Ér³ð p[j½¨¸ s.
^
&hܼРÐsH ux9ôÇ p[j½¨¸\¦ :x # è õ&ñ
×
æ ux9o ¸ú ' ÷&%36£§`¦·ú ú e%3. BZT\¦u
¨8
Hªs 7£x<Ê\ , ±ú ·ú_ ß¼lH&h yè
Hâ¾Ó`¦Ðs¦ e. ± ·úú_ ß¼l yè HsÄ»H u
¨8ôÇ Zns:rõ Ta s:rs ± ·úú_ $í©`¦%3]j %il M
:ëHܼРÐ.
Fig. 3(a)H©:r\"f 8£¤&ñôÇ %i·ú ´òõ 0A-l
© (S−E) /BG`¦Ð#ÅÒ¦ eܼ 9, Fig. 3(b)HsÐÂÒ'
½
¨ôÇ %i·ú >ú (d33∗)ü< d33-p'\¦s6 x # 8£¤&ñôÇ
Fig. 3. (Color online) (a) Bipolar strain vs. electric field (S − E) loops BF-BT-BZTx ceramics and (b) static piezoelectric constant (d33) and dynamic piezoelectric constant (d33 ∗) of BF-BT-BZTx ceramics.
&
ñ·ú>ú (d33) X<s's. Fig. 3(a)_ %i·ú ´òõ
H BF-BT-BZT0.01 ∼ 0.05 ¸$í\"f 60 kV/cmt l
©`¦ # 8£¤&`ñ¦ %i. tëß, BF-BT-BZT0.00
¸$í\"fH ©@/&hܼР¾º[OÀÓ Z} 55 kV/cm \
"
f 8£¤&ñ %i. BF-BT-BZTx[jbrÉ ¸ú µ1ϲú)a q
¸ª_ /BG`¦ Ðs 9 þj@/ 0A (Sm)ü< 6£§_ 0A (- Sn)\¦ ¸ú Ðs¦ e. íHúôÇ BF-BT_ r¼#Ér+þA&h
q¸ª_ y©Ä»^ :£¤$í /BG`¦ ¸ú Ðs¦ e.
Õ
ªo¦ l©s ½Ól© (Ec)\ ¸²úÙþ¡`¦ M:
H 6£§_ 0A (-Sn) -0.15% &ñ¸Ð Hכ `¦·ú ú e
[17]. tëß BZT 0.01 mol ' ÷&"f 6£§_ 0A
ß¼> yè %i¦ 0.01 molÂÒ' 0.05 molt '
% i
`¦ M: q5pwôÇ 6£§_ 0A °úכ`¦ Ðs¦ e. ÕªQټРBZT_ ªs 7£x ½+Éú2¤ Sn °úכs yè H `כ¦ 'a¹1Ï
½
+É Ãº e. Õªo¦ BZT ªs 7x£ ½+Éú2¤ Sm °úכÉr
"
f"fy 7£x Hâ¾Ó`¦Ðs¦, 0.02 (Sm= ∼0.18%)\
"
f © Z}Ér°úכ`¦Ðs¦ e. tëß, BF-BT\ BZT u
¨8ªs 0.02 molÐ 7£x½É +âĺ Sm °úכs yè H
â
¾Ó`¦Ð%i. © a~%Ér0A °úכÉr BF-BT-BZT0.02\
"
f d33∗= 290 pm/VܼР8£¤& ÷ñ&%3. BF-BT [jb\ BZTªs 7£x½+Éú2¤ ²DIrÉ+þAI_ S − E /BGs ÁºÉr+þA I
_ S −E /BGܼРo %i. íHúôÇ BF-BT\ q
Fig. 4. (Color online) Room-temperature P − E hystere- sis loops of BF-BT-BZTx ceramics.
#
0.02 mol BZT\¦' %i`¦M: ýaĺ @/gA&hs 9 Z}
É
r °úכ`¦l M:ëH\ íß\O\"f ´ú§s 6£x6x ÷&HÓoÆÒ
\
s'Ð &h6 xs|¨c âĺ 6£x6x 0px$ís Z}¦ Òqty)a
. Fig. 3(b)H BF-BT-BZTx [jb\ BZT ª\ Ér d33õ d33∗_ o\¦Ð#ÅÒ¦ e. BF-BT-BZT0.02\
"
f &ñ·ú :£¤$ís Z© }Ér d33 °úכs 130 pC/NÐ 8
£¤&ñ÷&%3. Õªo¦ x 0.02s© 7£x ½+Éú2¤ d33°úכÉr y
è H כ ܼР'aÏ ÷1¹ &%3. Õªo¦ d33∗ °úכÉr BZT
ª
s 0.02 molt 7£x½+Éú2¤ 7£x Hâ¾Ós Ð%i¦ 0.02 mols© u8¨ ÷&%3`¦ M:\H r yè H â¾Ó s
Ð%i. BNT [jb\"f q5wpôÇ o\¦ Jo 1px [18]õ Hussain 1px [19]_ 7HëH\"f ¸ ú Ðs¦ e. 0A °úכ`¦ q
§K Ф`¦M: íHúBF-BT_ d33∗ °úכÉr 180 pm/Vs
%
3ܼ, BZT 0.02 mol`¦u¨8 %i`¦M: 290 pm/VÐ $í 0
p
xs ¾Ó©÷&H `כ¦ ^¦Ãº e [11].
Fig. 4H BF-BT-BZTx [jb_ 65 kV/cm l©\
"
f 10 Hz_ ÅÒúР8£¤&ñôÇ yÄ©» s§4 /BG s. BF- BT-BZT[jbÉr¸ú ío)a§s4/BG`¦Ð#ÅÒ¦ e.
BF-BT-BZT0.02\"f © HïßÀÓìrFG°úכ(2Pr) 42 µC/cm2 °úכ`¦?/¦ e. Fig. 4_ 'ÂÒ ÕªaË>Ér BF- BT-BZT [jb_ ü@ÂÒ l\© Ér Prõ Ec_ o
\
¦ ·p כ s. ÕªaË>\"f Ð1pws 2Pr_ âĺ BZT_
ªs x = 0.02t 7£x x = 0.03ÂÒ'H¸FKm y
è %i.
Fig. 5H BF-BT [jb\ BZT_ '\ :r¸
\
ÉrÄ» ©Ãº_ o\¦·p כ s. íHúôÇ BF- BTH ©â>%ò%isټРĻ©Ãº þj@/°úכ`¦ ?/
¦, BZT '|¾Ós 7£x<Ê\ TcH ?/9"f Ä»
©Ãº¸ yè H â¾Ó`¦ Ð. [jb_ Ļ֦\
%ò
¾Ó`¦puH ÐH ·ú±ú_ ß¼l, èx9¸, ½¨
Fig. 5. (Color online) Temperature dependent dielectric constants of BF-BT-BZTx ceramics at a frequency of 10 kHz.
¸ü< °ú Ér &ñ½¨¸_ "é¶s e`¦ ú eܼ 9, ±ú ·ú_ ß
¼l &t¦ x9¸ Z}|9ú2¤Ä»©Ãº &¦
· ú
94R e [20]. Ä»©Ãº °úכ_ yè HsÄ»H íHú ô
Ç BF-BT [jb\"f BZT u¨8\ tHp[j
½
¨¸ü< XRD ©\"f èß °úכ_ 7£x "é¶ כ Ü
¼Ð Òqty)a.
IV. + s Ç Â ] Ø
:r ½¨\"fH (1-x)BiFeO 3-xBaTiO3 (BF-BT) ¸$í
`
¦l:rܼР# Bi(Zn2/3Ta1/3)O3¸$í`¦$íìr>Ð u
¨8 # ¦ ì©øÍ6£xZO`¦6s x # [jb`¦]j¸ %i.
BF-BT-BZTx[jb ±ú ·ú_ ß¼lH x_ ªs 7£x<Ê\
"f yè Hכ `¦ a'¹1Ͻ+É Ãº e%3. BF-BT-BZTx [
jb_ XRD JÉr ` ÐÚÔÛ¼sàÔ ½¨¸\¦ tH J
`¦Ð#ÅÒ¦ e¦, íHúôÇ BF-BT [jb_ âĺ 0px
&ñ>ü< &ñ~½Ó&ñ> ½¨¸ D¥Ë½+)aJ`¦ Ð# ÅÒ¦ e
BZTªs Zþt#Q ±úú2¤ßx¼_ 0Au ±úÉryܼРs
1xl H&³©`¦a'¹1Ͻ+É Ãº e%3. BF-BT-BZT0.02 [j
b\"f 2PrÉr 42 µC/cm2Õªo¦ 2Ec H 55 kV/cmÐ 8
£¤&ñ ÷&%3. Õªo¦ &·ñú >ú d33 = 126 pC/Nܼ
Ð 8£¤&ñ ÷&%3. ¢¸ôÇ, BF-BT-BZT0.02[ jb\"f %i·ú
0A°úכr 60 kV/cmÉ \"f 0.17% (d33∗= 290 pm/V)Ð 8
£¤&ñ ÷&%3.
P
c p 8 ý ò k >
s
7HëHÉr 2011¸¸ &ñÂÒ (pA½Ó¸õ<ÆÂÒ)_ F"é¶Ü¼
Ð ôDzDG½¨Féß_ t"é¶`¦ ~ÃΠú')a ½¨s 9 (No.
2011-0030058), &ñÂÒ (§¹¢¤ÂÒ)_ F"¶éܼРôDzDG½¨F é
ß_ @/<Æ×æ&h½¨è t"é¶\OܼРú'a)½¨{9m (No. 2012-045424, 2013R1A1A4A01010612). Õªo¦ í
ß\O:x©"é¶ÂÒ lÕüt+À:\OܼРt"é¶)a ½¨{9m (No. 10047914).
REFERENCES
[1] D. Lin, D. Xiao, J. Zhu and P. Yu, Appl. Phys. Lett.
88, 062901 (2006).
[2] K. G. Webber, Y. Zhang, W. Jo, J. E. Daniels and J. R¨odel, J. Appl. Phys. 108, 014101 (2010).
[3] R. Zuo and J. Fu, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 94, 1467 (2011).
[4] A. Hussain, C. W. Ahn, A. Ullah, J. S. Lee and I.
W. Kim, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 49, 041504 (2010).
[5] W. Jo and J. Rodel, Appl. Phys. Lett. 99, 042901 (2011).
[6] V. D. N. Tran, A. Hussain, H.-S. Han, T. H. Dinh and J-S. Lee et al., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 51, 09MD02 (2012).
[7] T-H. Wang, C-S. Tu, Y. Ding, T-C. Lin and C-S.
Ku et al., Curr. Appl. Phys. 11, S240 (2011).
[8] Z. Cen, H. Yang, C. Zhou, Q. Zhou and J. Cheng et al., J. Electroceram. 31, 15 (2013).
[9] H. Deng, M. Zhang, Z. Hu, Q. Xie and Q. Zhong et al., J. Alloys. Compd. 582, 273 (2014).
[10] H. Zhang, W. Jo, K. Wang and K. G. Webber, Ce- ram. Int. 40, 4759 (2014).
[11] S. O. Leontsev and R. E. Eitel, J. Am. Ceram. Soc.
92, 2957 (2009).
[12] Q. Zhou, C. Zhou, H. Yang, G. Chen and W. Li et al., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 95, 3889 (2012).
[13] C. Zhou, A. Feteira, X. Shan, H. Yang and Q. Zhou et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 101, 032901 (2012).
[14] I. Fujii, R. Mitsui, K. Nakashima, N. Kumada and M. Shimada, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 50, 09ND07 (2011).
[15] X. Zhou, C. Zhou, Q. Zhou, H. Yang and Z. Cen et al. J. Electron. Mater. 43, 755 (2014).
[16] M. H. Lee, J. S. Park, D. J. Kim, R. C. Kambale and M-H. Kim et al., Ferroelectrics 452, 7 (2013).
[17] J. S. Park, K. T. Lee, J. H. Cho, Y. H. Jeong and J.
H. Paik et al., J. Kor. Ceram. Soc. 51, 527 (2014).
[18] W. Jo, R. Dittmer, M. Acosta, J. Zang and C. Groh et al., J. Electroceram. 29, 71 (2012).
[19] A. Hussain, C. W. Ahn, A. Ullah, J. S. Lee and I.
W. Kim, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 49, 041504 (2010).
[20] H. W. Kim, S. C. Kim, B. M. Jin, C. W. Ahn and I. W. Kim et al., Sae Mulli 53, 56 (2006).