A Review on the Local Loop Unbundling in UK

전체 글

(1)영국 가입자망 세분화제도의 고찰 A Review on the Local Loop Unbundling in UK.

(2) . .

(3) !"#$%& ' '()*+&,-./0123456789:;<=$>?(8@ 2ABC6DEFGH IJ#K LMNO./012A BPQRS4 2A )TUV&1WX4DY89Z#1 [\H]^_,#` 6#abcdefg8@h4ijkl8.. I. 영국의 가입자망 세분화정책. H :YKl }hKY ~ ~ _.. 1. 초 안. Kl}hKY fV{MX. >?.

(4) . d%#$,- ._`]. !"#$%. d%.f/¡ ¢G£X. &"'(%)*+,-./01. ¤¤R¥:cf ¢ ¦§. "/0234567+.89. _`f ¢¨© . :;<=>? @AB A . 89,. #$]:cfgªh« _¬rC. -CD"EF"GH/:I +,J. :cfg,«X>?w® :c. =KLM7NOPQ.RST>?A>. fgªh.K¯[\ <>°.±:²³´. UVGH/:WX89:YZ. Oµ²¶,_K·>? 7NOPQ]¸¸¹º» q¼.. C.[\]^5_` ab,c. :cfg,ªhl.½²¶¾¿QOÀOµ²¶³À³PÁ. M>? 7NOPQ]d_ e :cfg.. V `K ¡" _`f" Â Ã: f. hV-ab.ci>jk,l. Ä7OÅPÁ!µ½P¶¾PÆ7³PÁÀO²Á¾Ç7!7ÈÉÊ0. m"nopq.rC:cfg.hV-. £5_`K.YËÌ. ._` s]tuvwx%y. ÊVÍÎ>?. z>?@{p|!!"#$%&"}~C,. @jv.m0.£. -+.vHpq:. pq:Ïx:cfg.^YË. 8 <]Kl}hg9Kx :;. Ð§jk,lÑ>? <jeX±:.. :Y9[\>?pqg. ²³Oµ²¶,_K·>?²³Oµ²¶"ÒÐH/:c 97.

(5)

(6) .

(7) !" #$%& ' ()*. /. j zG. +,-./0123. vsvGjG lG. vsvGw lG. 가. option 1: Unbundled Local Loop. <=>8?@A@7>BCD%EF GHI/356JKL4MNON)> <= @A@" 7:#4 PQR N) ST<$ >UL44QVW"N)ST<=( )*+,<XO/3YZ[\>7()*+ ,564(@A@\]^<"_`Fa$bc 56]&()*d56efgWHD"/hi jjk()*>l7mFn/3YQo7: #'+p;7n@A@]&()*deq rO()*s;CD/3 14("7:.

(8) . /~]>()*7$bifg4)FJK ^ve$bi;fg<[\ yzL O/3<}~ 1{7}\_ ]&()* 8?% _O/3 Yu " Z vwxyz%/3 다. option 3: Bitstream Access. #'+p@A@4Xtk/3Yu1c Z 1vwxyz%/3. . u{wVwvpG. i{GwG iG sGj. 14(" 567 8 9 7:#;. @A@77:#J4AS)N <}$567AdqrS)N<. /. tkmG. u{w. XO/3YZ[\@A@"K84JK ^ K84( { fg\ 8 #{. jG zG. tkmG. vsvGwG sGh lG mGi{G. i{GsG jGi. fgO/3 <4(">7PQR( )* +,<" 8? _< ¡% ]&() *8?"_W}"/3Yuc . vsvGj lG. r GGGGGaG. vwxyz%/3 . tkmGGGGGdGGtGkGmG u{wGGGGGdGGuG{GwG kzsGGGGGGdGGkGzGsG kzshtGGdGGkzsGhGtG wvpGGGGGGGdGGwGGpG.

(9) . 나. option 2: Partial Baseband Leased Circuit 1{|8<}~56e@A@iq 4DH/hXO/3\$b{J K ^v8]>;XWH 7:#c56'+<4H7XW"/3 98. /jGz u{w. tkm. kzs t. i{GG i j. u{wVwvpG kzsG tG vsvG j l. .

(10) . 라. option 4: Permanent Virtual Circuit Access 567A()*'<=$G¢QR;@A@ 4X+,<"\7:e@A@K8£Q.

(11) . £\fg/37:¤4(" {9 ¥<}~7:7@A@e¦x\fgW "§¨¡/©&Oª«d7:\¬« ª« ®; ¯./" /3 4 °hvwxyz%"Yu e±/3. 2. 가입자망 세분화 의견수렴에 따른 Oftel 의 잠정결론 ¼½4(+v!7} 4Q¾ ¿;CÀg{ e 4qÁ §Â"ª 56" PQR ()* +,<" ª". . ~\% Ã</" ¿; ÄÅ<Æ/3. /. u{wG. <}~ @ :Sc # $%&7 ÇÈ</". u{wVwvp kzsG tG. kzshtG. £;¯}<$7:#É&ÊQ()* 4 %WHI/":SË/023. vsvGGzw. sG jG iG. 7:# É& Ê -Ì\ GÍ; sc h{tGzG GpwGyG wG wG }G jG jG {GvsvGGzw. . e ) <` _`ª «'o4>W"G¢CQR~;´%\ BCÎvÏÐ4@A@4X(ª«()*s vF("vÑ48><ÒÓÔ]&()*% @A@()*>FI<"J£D/3 ÕÖ567:#AA×Ø+QO |"¼$kª«()*+,<v=.

(12) . ZQ½©4(7S¥Ùx\8>W"'o# 56 #Ëv ÏÐ/3 1ÚÚÚÛaÜK. 마. option 5: Indirect Access !4(AcPQR,© ^#{ fgW"ªfg;F(>78?²³ .´µ¶8><"-./3"·¸¹6º4 ( 8>W" ij jk{ 9¥ -.; »<= @A@efgO/3 4°hvwxyz%" Yu!e±/3. ÝÞc!ßàá*â;ã$DËä 7:åc1æà4l{çvÏÐ47:#è!à +,<"567éêS}ëê;7n8? Æ/3ìCÈ¤4(7³4(£íî7< $D"áïðáñòó()*4QÈô7 î7W$D©õv?4("]>;> 'oc>Èö$7Æ/3YZ[\÷ÀÈö. . \>7m¼$kª«()*ÇÈ. /. u{wG kzsG tG. kzsht. h{tG. sG j iG h{tGzG wG vsvG zG }G jG jG. QøO/3. {GG wG u. <}~ e 4QF(%J£ D/3²ù 4QF(567Ùú<Æ"ª. vsvGyG hG} zGjG u{wVwvp. ! !

(13) " . >B_`()*+,4°¡8 . 7: _û8?4X $*üù ]ýX W HCþ&W$\¯<=567<$ D"A()*Ê4í;"/"Ë /3 ôäN)G¢CqóÐ+£;F g<v F(" }kx¯ k7 H I <[\A()*Ê}f CD/"£ 99.

(14)

(15) . ;}x<Æ/3 _`ÊWª«'o4. $%&'()*+,4¼£;'(Ë/3. >W" $G¢C QR~; <= _û8?4. )*É*S4(éêS}ëê;7}$D. X+,<vÏÐ4JviL4]KG >7. aiZ+1S}ëêck|}. :e ©õv? a¬4 PQR()* +. \ã+vÏÐ/3ìAvw;,>. ,BCDH

(16) _û; n<X \J. 7:# $%& 'F PQR()* +,. <Æ/3<}~()*4>W"N)'+p. -¸ê . L¸WH D/$ ã+v ÏÐ/3. 564X DH _û8?" N) îN d \. 4í-³gc e 4¼£. ?YO()*+,HXO/"J£. '(H D"ª¾Fq:S;/0ã. D/3. /Ó{±/3. Y|"1í¼½4(}xe±56"\. <}~ZÐ+£4%lô<$@ c56 AÊ{ lH Ê;Ø ³<Æ"ª)EÝÞóóS\¯<= 567 A; ÊB |¯ Dv" <}~ '<=¼$kª«()*+,|¯;

(17) n<$/3ìAA×Ê}R; }R\B¯}§¨?Y ' #$%&7 Hn }R\ B ¯} g;}Ë/3@ c]K;Q\AA× Ê<=I/$g}Ë"ªc567²³ PQR()*7+, CÎ"-.\#;$% &BCDvÏÐ456"vwxc()*+ ,47D}"cAA×Ê<= I/"g;L/3. 3. 가입자망 세분화 최종안 1ÚÚÚÛ11@ cAA×4Q:S; ÄÅ<Æ/023½4("]we±³ ã&4°hPQR()*F("7:# j©È</";}x<Æ/3·¸AÝ Þ ()* ó / ()*. 가. 이행 옵션에 대한 이해관계자들의 입장 1#1Ü8? PQR()*4QCÈÃ2ývFØ +37ÇÈ</"@ ¿{ () *+,-.49<":S/3<}~YQ7" A4564,')7? F I/" ¿;+<Æ/3ì.c#1Üc 78h¥L49W};_ò4X +,W"}Rc:567A()*9 \v7;H/"£;`<<Æ/3 ()*+,8? ()*+,8?%@ g³49<" :S9x¯_û;7 =\%<Æ /3 'F(56A()*ã/> c Èöý}\ ()* +,B C D; \ ã$D/3 >d>?J. '¼$k¯«()* @-!"#"d. >c$kQR()*+,S4(567. )#"()*K$4X+,BCD. S}ëx¯4D";-}BCD"@. ¡%<$D/3. A¨B\( 7:# y-4 QF C³x\. Z/()*+,<vF("(). D¾<$D%EFHG}Rä_. *jd()*+,4&âD"_û;%. +x\¬|<}HI4X%JKL§7. :<"¡J<Æ²ù569L#. vM<Æ/3. 100.

(18) . 56ÙV. • $b4Q$kjk()*d8>W"v. wc56JdJ4e<Df8?7. 56" @ + -½ N4 QF . 9¥3P\_û<";g<õ). Ð;+v<ÆäÓ]&7:#8> d QØ v?$b4 +,<" ()*4 Q A45647;+<Æ/3ì. Kp;+BCD/3 • $b{ 56 Fq7 ¥W} " _`. 567()*y}fý ä²³()*. O3P4 Ê4°hØ³; Q;Èô<Æ/3. 4Q>ÈôBCD/3 • 56"`]_ûS4( Èö\(). *Èö;õ)4X¬{BCD/3. 나. option 4의 시장구현 @ R4-³g4QSNTU;L V;56" e|8A ()*Wx\9<Æ4QôX x¯ô·(%úÄ<Æ/3/Ócô·4 QL>/3 • O3P4°¡56"%YZ;()*+,. 8?¹ä/h8?>7m<%E. ZÐ+£\¯<= e|8% Y()*+,;cK<}"+/3ì56Jd Avw;>()*"QX*É*@A ¨B¬¸|\HÃ7/"g; Lh/3 Ê4°hJ£\(" • Ø_+78¡i\¯()*jkM. 7l;7 =CD\¯<=Q. 56X()*+,8?7()*+,. ØAS}S;sX CD. <"{9¥3P\+,<%E/3 • 1ß{114+O}R4(Wx\9. <" A ()* %Y7c > a iß[!ß¢1WL4(g³/3 • 56"ßßßÛ¬«%YZ+,;9. B ; C\<Æ"ª ()* 9 ]]} ßßy ^v $%&\ v?7: e 7³>7: N^ æßß~ 7: | /3 56 A ()* 9 _S=¬" W( )*,=¬J<=g³B/3 @ c $k PQR()*4 Q õ) Èô4¬V<"Z564QF^Ü<. 56()*Ê4%}S;;CDÓ •. Ê<v m n d úD7m. Ù\¯&þ\(" • # &âx 1Ü4 Q 9v ¬=\. )>op;7 =CD\¯()* M7op • _û ,&\ ¯<= ()* Èö4 ¬{<. "v?nq;;¥CD\¯ ()*7<r 다. Oftel의 결정. ":S;ãÆ/3<}~jkS`]QX. v4( /0s e ± @ c e. ¸7Î"a4(56Avw;>(). 4()*+,;Ø³<ÆN. * Sc 7 D/" J4 °¡ e. x¯74$kQR()*>7m;t. |8 567 + -Ì~; ³b-!\ cK. Q&QCD%E<Æ/3²ù "$k. <}" +/3 Ð+£\ ¯.O ¬c /Ó{. QR()* S d *É* @A¨B _û;. ±/3. nBu~§¨¡56E8?v+Y 101.

(19)

(20) . $H#4B()*+,B}. Cqd#4¬TW"¾N)4QÄ. g³BCD%E<Æ/3w#ôxdí. |ÇÈ</3. 4Q³ã+,FGXWË/3. +,. 라. Option 2를 통한 서비스 제공. 56"¹5A6+,4vôxO*É*#4( :2. 1¹ 5 A6 ¹5A6"7:UL4(JK ^v y m n]} ô\ fgO 7:#\ ô WHD/3 F("JK ^vd7: UL4()*+,;F(S)NBC D#$%&4Hzvw;8><=% q</3<}~+,s"8?"7:# S{|ú<}%E<vF²³vwÄ|; °¡I/37]1:}4A7vÑ4ôxO ¹6º7:#;><=$kQR;'¾ #}~()*+,;7mÝ<"vw /3 Z ¹5A64FYW"7:#c$kQR ()* +, 7m<$ # $%& ><X <v F ZÄ|4 ¬NWHI~ /3 Z ZC|c\¸ó{±c=Z² Èõ7Ü!;|/3()*Zc7:# Avw{±c²³()*vw;}M<$# $%&4°h²³CÊ()*,Ô7m}= ¬4Fg³O/3 G¢Cq ¹5A6 ><" 8?c $k ()* $b4X+,<vF(¾v/hS)cKB _`'oS{|úóS{¥QD /3Z;õ&ývF²´G¢ .

(21)

(22) !"#$%&'()*+,-. $/0120345. 102. =| ;+,B%W\ 1 ; '<= ()* s" _`4~ T*7Hn/3Z¹5A6'()* $b>B_`56\¬«vÑ4+,sÒ ()* k >B} =¬ g³FI /3 $b()*]^<$<"ª=|Î / vÑ ; '<= ()* +,s" % 7m</3<}~_`4%56e¹5A6> <" @A@c ÚÚÚ()* k s; C D%E FI/3=v(©È89cvÑ8> 4 qÎ ()* +,4 xN ~ D O/"/3 !56'Ó]&()* @ c ¹5A6 ô: @A@7 ÷G¢QR; ']&()*e$G¢QR;'A()* ø>4X+,BCDX<Æ/3X \ 56 Xx\ A\ $%&O ; ôx<$ 7 tQ&<%E <Æ/3 Y Zä >" ¹5A6 '<= _û8?\¬« PQRª«()*+,s"/< ¡%] &()*"56\¬«k+,s;CD%E< "UÇÈ;+v<Æ/3Y$_û8? ©¥¬"567]&()*+,<$o cPQR()*4¼£;'($/"¿; ê<Æ/34/Óø7}Q½D/3 ; ]4 <= @A@" $G¢QR~; ô:<$ §\Y Óc c564/L<ãL"-. @A@7;ô:/Ó÷G¢QR ÓccF(56 ^vefg \@A@7564X¸Y<"-..

(23) . 4QF@ cµ-.c<ä;. II. 설비병설. øy8?78>\1Ü4H< DÓ; }x<Æ/3 <}~ 8?i g4 F. 1. 병설 형태. 7m<¡J<Æ/3 æ+, @A@7()*;ô·<vF("567J K ^v ^v7 +,<" ()*}R Wó4q@A@4X+,FI/3ì. ¹5A6eqr<=@A@"fg;FN) 56K84MN< ä56K8¯4N) NFI/3ZN)MN4QF(/Ó 7}|;+<$D/3 가. 물리적 병설. @A@Èô4>7m4ó ;+,\@A@7Fa}R4(A()* +,BCD"}JBCD%E<$D/3 마. PBLC 제공에 대한 법률적 기틀. ¦xMNc56 ^v7NOK8, i; @A@7 í<= N) MN<" \( 56"@A@4XÇÈ,i;ô<$nN <=N)7HN,i;+,<XO/3¦x MN4°hvwxyz%"Yuæ{±/3. ¹5A64Q568c56O3P ; 'F Ø³ É¬x¯ 8c 56e. /. @A@4FN \s/3G¢C. i{GsGlG jGz. ê4QF("4 n

(24) Ø. vsvGwG l. ³;}I/3. wGi sGj u{w. . ¹5A6\ÅF}"'o()*"6 나. 원격병설. @ c¹5A64Q3P;vÑ56O 3P4¬7<=Ø³BCD/34@ c56 'o()* d qr 3P4 Q O 3P4 ¹5A64Q3P;¬7<Æ/3. . {G wz{uG tkmG. 1O3P. 1Úè 4 F ³W$ Dv ÏÐ4. vsvGjTG lG. 56 ^vefg<v<=56K8¯ 4ýP¦;r<=ÇÈN)N<$ ; 'F fg<" -./3 MMN4 Qvwxyz%"YuR{±/3. ¹5A64F(;+,F|/< ¡%. /. vsvGwG vsvGl. c 56 õ| q d |}ãC b% vG zGjG. 564XD/34£$SCx ³C|Z|}|}ãCó)>;F. jGz. g<vF56e@A@iÇÈ</356. vsvGwG l. "ì'o#½³;FG¢C>ä -};Ê<}"@A@4 QF(";íJBCD/3. wGi sGj u{w. i{GsGlG. . {G wz{uG tkmG.

(25) . 103.

(26)

(27) . 다. 가상병설. >B_`´%-4MNB}c9¥Sõ4. @A@" o N) 567 q G 1Ü<%E •. <"-.\(N)N4564X'ã< "-./3 Z -.4 QF @ c 56 K84 ¦ xMN;+,B=|,iD"_``x\ ¦xMN;<%E<Æ/3Y}H_`4 "MMN{7xMN;$<FCD"ª MMN_`@A@¬«8>]} 7Çfx\H}vÏÐ4>4X+,W "PQR()*4+WvÏÐ/37MN _`564(Ð+<"ªF("56 }¨H¸ ÇÈ<vÏÐ/3ZN )MN-Ì©4(MMNc()*+,|f ¤4(@A@4X¶Wv%<Æ/3. n~;°\1ÜB}"8?K<%E <ÆZK4°h)>úDc74 ÙÜ/3 8?7 ^K8 L ,9Sõ4 S) n4N<"_`N)MN7cjk )>4°¡³F}}~²³}R4¼\MN< "8?7¬<"4Që</3 vf )>4 Q<= 56" d N)MN4 CÙW"Ê³)>úD<[\A4564 ) >;f8?7¬FIB/3. 4. 영국의 설비병설 현황 AA× Ê; F( @A@ 9<" N) MN\"¦xMNMMN7MN 7}7 $<WË/3 ·¸ ÜK N)MN. 2. 설비병설에 대한 법률적 기틀 56 O3P4(" È D; _` 567 ¶jk£ vf³ã d qr ()* @A@4X +,<%EØ³<$D/3¹5A6+,4DH¦ xMN{MMNÇÈ</"@ J< 4vÑ56O3P4N)MN{qrO8 ;(7<Æ/3¦xMN4qg]ê+, v|}óã/É¬x¯84QF("56 e@A@ig³4Fg³ \JO/3. 3. 설비병설 가격 및 비용의 보상. ã ¦x MN _` ßß1Û 14 Ò

(28) º nm A n¡ nm ; )¢<=1æ£4(MN`WËÚ£4( nÊ©/3ìN)MN{qr<=ßß1Û1 1¥4@ c@A@¤MN)£d CF56K84:<"_`56¤M 9ÊÎ%:7m<%E<Æ/3MMN _`4"ßß1Û1!£4(MNnÊ© !£4("MNÒ/0 23. III. 가입자망 세분화 대가산정. N)MN{qr<=úD<")>c8?. 7:# É&4 °h Q7 ¥³ -Ì\. @A@% <%E <$D4 Q 8. @ ¼v4 $< -Ìc -.. c@¹

(29) n . A456¦7?§6¹4É7}-ÌË/37. 4(³<%E<$D/3@ g{e@¹. 1ª( x\ @ K Q7¥³-Ìc. 8;\/Ó{±cg;}Ë/3. @ 1ÚÚÚÛR4 4(+v. &âx¯8?7N)MN;O><( úD<" )>c N)MN; ><" 8? <%E<Æ/3 N)MN,i4<ä8?C 104. A456¦7?-.Ë/3 Y |\" A456¦ -. X)> ;ÙÜ<7:#_ûx\, ÔW"S4(_+x7ÙÜ<vÏÐ¡.

(30) . "¿/3 X)>c¯¨¡4<Os)>. #Q7¥³-½4Q56+½{4Q. ;ÙÜ<vÏÐ4_ûS4(¯¨¡õ|. @ ¿;,Ä<Æ¼vQ7¥³. v?c X)>\7;b³<<<}. -½4QF(%vÔ<Æ/34Q¾Fq. ;vÏÐ/3~ X)>\7. ¿; CÀ<= 9Û è4 Q7¥³-. ; b³B _` \1 _û n:u~ §¨¡. Ì4 Q :S; ÄÅ<Æ 14 7. X)><r%Iv<vÏÐ/3u~§¨¡. ;b³<Æ/3. ÜK]&Èöô3ÙÜ/"£%7}$ D/3 ¦§6¹4-Ì_+x7ÙÜ -Ìv"<}~F("¾¾4Q F( 7; ¥³F LI <" H< D$ ·9x\¥³<"%l7m<vÏÐ /3u~§¨¡@ c4QF}Rx íe"qÎJ¥7;b³<v-Ì \_ûS4(_+x7ÙÜjk7 ;b³<"A456¦-Ì;8><"N. @ c¼vQ7¥³4DH/Ó7}C |4(j<Æ/3 •. Q7¥³ QM©mnm ª mn n YP. C\ •. É¬xQ7¥³M© mn n ZP. C\ • ¼vQ7¥³. 1. Oftel의 Oftel의 대가산정 방법 초안. x¡$J<Æ/3<}~}R´J¥jk7. @ ¼vQ7¥³-½4(")E@ . b³c568\Ø³<}"§¼. -½4QFl~;Ä<"8?7D/< . v4"567J¥Q7x><W(}xí. ¡% ÇÈB _` ¼v Q74(" N)MNä. \ ¯F úD<" )> í" Q74 ÙÜB. y 4Q)>cÙÜ<}<. CD%E<Æ/3. ç/3. YZ[\@ AA×4QQ7¥³M©c /Ó\ÈBCD/3 • 7b³cA456¦7?4-Ì;x> •. }xíô<}$jk74:¾ J¥7;x><}~}xí4 )>í³a&BCD"_`74 ÙÜ. • 5 {±7:#É&+,. 4°¡úD<")>%A456¦7?4 @A@ • N)MN4FúD<")>c@A@7. </C@A@756K84N)MN <"_`nNe±c)>c¾@A@7 £|<"x4°¡ ZQ7¥³M©{qr<=@ cßßß Û ! Ð( úi<Æ/0!23 =v4(" 7:. Q7¥³QM©cßßßÛ!4,ÄÐ (4(+WËÉ¬xQ7¥³M©;C\ <v]+\(«><XO/37:#É &ä {qrOM©c@ 7 :# É& ¼v Q7¥³4 x>WË/3 u~ §¨¡y äN)MN4°hQ 7 ¥³ -Ì; +<$ D/3 Ð(4 äf¬ @ GÈ£c/Ó{±/3 567 +½O Q7¥³ -½4(" 7:# ³vxQ74O¡s) . 678 9:;<=>?@A?BCDE FGHIJ?KALMN6OOOPQR=ST&U>VW W211X034Y4Z[34W\2WZ]2134W3]3 W21^_/`

(31) abc d)ef6OOOPgR = hi jk>J VWW211 X 034Y4Z[ WX3Wl1X3 X3 WZ]3]3W2134mlZ234W\2WZ]21^_ /`nA. 105.

(32)

(33) . >cvCO)>%WHD;CD/3 4@ cvÑ7:#Q)>4( :vÑ\s&O)>c+E/3. 가. 가입자망 대가 1vÑ¡. 56"%)äoØ7NO7:#. ¡üô\WHD>. ; 'F( ()* +,<" _` \1. 7ôe 'o#; fg G" ; ¥¹"/3. ¡4Q)>;C<XO/3<}. ¥Ùx\'o#JS7SJ4<. ~@ c567oØ7NQ7b³. >Kë£4<XO/3YZ[. 4DHvCO¡)>;. \¦x\"]G4(7:UL\¯:<v. QCD/$`<<Æ/3. Fº=nc}<4YNOq\¬«¯. ®56"7:#667'Fsy. :W"¡7O/3 ¡)>C-Ìc /Ó7} -Ì. ¨\Y¯;ÙÜBCD/3 °56"³vxQ74C)% *;QC D/3~ %C)4 Q ³_³ã7Î/< ¡%56"vÑ 7:#Q74C):ë±; /3 ZP. ²56"¹n ³ eº6§4Q) >%9jk&OQ7L}"³vxQ7 4±;/3. D/3 ¡)>;s&<=³vxQ74 »cúD)>;vi_{4°¡£í YÛ¥³¬¼;)>\Õ<"/3 ¡)>;av)>Õ»7: ¡aFÛ%)>;¯.< =aFÛ%)>\Õ<"/3. ´5 4Q74*µ ?. 56" Z ¡4 QF úD<" )>. )>cxoH</3 ? )>c9. ;7:³vQ74CFI. qrN) m

(34) Q74. /":S;7}$DË/3Y|\"¡. ý"xo</3. 7)E¾ÕWH77ß¡B}¡%=]ù. ¶ 56 Å,i Q)" £|,i4 °¡ ¬{BCD/3 ·¥ÙQ)d¥Ùq)"(\W ä ³vxQ74I/3 ¸P¦Q7c@A@Nx\%¤ BCDHI/3. _+x77D~¡4Q7 ;ß\B_`S4½HO³ã+,BCD /"/3ì³vxQ7")>4 <= ¥³WHI/":SË/3 <}~ @ g³84(" ³vx Q74 ¡ s&O )>; +E<%E <Æ/3 Y \"vÑ¡)>c:C7. 2. 세부 요소별 대가산정방안 @ c v4 vw M©; \ /Ó{ ±c-Ì;'FQ7¥³<%E<Æ/0æ23 . Fo]32plq23[/r stu._/`v

(35) $>_wx)y/z{|}

(36) {~^_a> z>~*^x)U=!>~* . a> t./kt.a &}. 106. WËvÏÐ4s&<=)>;CB_` ©\)>;¬{/"/3u~§¨¡7 c)>4v¼FI/"/3 @ Q7¥³4Q:Sc¾QX)> 4:¾$p7¾; 'F(:C¬c)>4(+E/" /34vÑ¡)>c:}}!x) >§¨¡"g;}Ë/3.

(37) . oØ7N¡d¬7«?. C<%E<Æ/3YZä¬7«?4FúD. "vÑ]&E4(7x¯;È ô<" 7:4 F úD<" \( @A@ È4F567CÊ<XO/3~ m n ÊW} "/ @A@\¬« PQR () * s$ 56\¬« ]&()* +,s" _` \1+,4°h)>(7x\úD <vÏÐ/3A m n;Ê<v\@ g³<X¿4°¡Ð+©Èc/õpõ <v"<Æ/3 oØ7N ¡ )>C-Ìc /Ó ø7}-ÌD/3 s&<=³vxQ74ýWL>Û C;"-Ì N)4av)>Õ<"-ÌÀ _`@A@7)>;¬<=¡7N <$()*+,</7;/h@A@ì "564X]<"_`Fa¡_ +x7ã4QÐ+7DÓ oØ7N¡eqr<=@ ¼v: S;s&<=³vxQ74Á$ >; C<%E <" -½; +<Æ/3 YZä 56"Â_`L>ÛC9½Fa)>;CF. <")>cN)4C<%E<Æ/3 ¹n ³ eº6§ ¹§dº6§4(%oØ_è7} Å7äfÆ/34QF56"oØ7N ¡_è7}\L>ÛC]4ÙÇ _`Ã)>ã;s; CÎvÏÐ4av )>&<"s&<=C<"ã/fa </$ }x<Æ/3 <}~ @ c N)4 ¹§ dº6§)>;Q_`©\)>;ã s;CD/"£;`<<=jk)>;¹ ³vxQ74<=C<%E<Æ/3 4QFgb\"/Óø7}C D/3 vÑ³vxQ74 «?ÇÈN)>4 C<"-ÌÀ-ÌcFa7:1 Ü8?_4°h)>ã]ÇÈ @ cø7}-Ì©4(oØ7N¡ e7}|H¹§dº6§jk)> ;³vxQ74ý%E<=C<%E< Æ/3. [P. I<vÏÐ4~7:7L>ÛC ]4F }<Ã=L>ÛC4Fa<"p7¾). sy¨\Y¯. C<}H<XW$gK<OsC7l. @ c5677:#7j7<"sy. 7m</"£;HÙQ<Æ/3 Z|H56"øµ-Ì¯av). ¨\Y¯Ê#79;´%. >Õ4)>CM<Æ}~=v(%=. ¿;+<Æ/3<}~/h8?c56. ]ù56e@A@8@A@e@A@8] ^4°h7ãÐ+7+vWË$4QF gb;Ä}H<@ coØ7N¡4 Q)>;s&\³vxQ74. Í\<}$)>4ÙÜBCD/" sy¨\Y¯4°h)>¬{4l~;Ä< Æ/3Y|\("~sy¨\Y¯4° ¡)>;@A@7}l<XW"_`561Ü) >c >§}X W}~ ÙQ\ 7j7g{ @A@ 4X(¬«ã3s}§%O/"gä". . 7XXql "=>z

(38) $P)^ gP nA. XO/56"sy¨\Y¯;Ê<} ;vÏÐ/3 107.

(39)

(40) . 4QF@ c¨\Y¯Ê)>{¨\Y ¯41>)>op*;³vxQ74 ý%E<Æ/3 !CÈ @ ¼v -½4(" CÈ)> % C)>\³vxQ7\:WHD ;\J<Æ/3ì5677:#É& 4Q³_CÈ)>³ã7Î/< ¡% :vÑC)>4WHD;¡ "¿;ÄÅ<Æ/3<}~456¿; s§=CÈPa)>;@A@4X¬{<v \<Æ/3"ìCÈHÈ;Ï@A@ 8S)£<}$3P564X CÈ<";É+<"|¯;+,/3 æ>9 56"7:#;É& èiL4 /564ÙÇW"_`Ê )>;¬{FI /$ GS<Æ/3 4 Q @ :S% 56 ¿49/":S;ÄÅ<Æ/3<}~> ? @A@ Ê )>; ø <" ª4 ÙQ<= 564X Ù^W" _`4" 567Ê )>;¬<%E<Æ/3 Z Ê )>4 QF @ c )>úD M¯ ¬M©4°ËÊ )>;úDý" >?@A@4X)>úDM¯D/$ J/3w/Ó{±³ CD/3. R*µôx)> @ ¼v -½4" *µ ôx)>4 QF ³vxQ74)> ;C/"56+½xo/$J< =9qrN) ¹m

(41) »¹Q 74ý%E<Æ/356"4QF ³vx Q74 ý} H/ 7:#³vxQ77§Ì¹N) 4I/$GS<Æ/3 4@ c567*µôx)>;y´7: N)'Fã]s;CDX<Æ/3 è|}q)eQ 6 4(" @ |}q )dQ¹Q74Q}§¨ N)MNQ7\ Q}4 QF gÍ} + Ë/3 6 ¿ CÀ g{ ¹³vQ74I/"¿/C Æ/3_`7:\³vQ74jkx >FI<"ªí}RxíQ74ÙÜ<v H/"Ð+7úD<Æ/34|}q)¬ {"}Rx)>í4GÍ<Æ56"}R xí4qÎjk)>;ÙÜ<"¿; ÄÅ<Æ/3 Z ]8³; p½<= @ c jk |} )>;7:#fi³vQ74ý%E< Æ/3 e ÙQ\ N)MN4 °h K8Q" N)MNQ7\¬{<Æ/3. èi4564XÙ^W$@A@ ()* ><Ò > 56 () *>/Ê )567¬/3 èi4564XÙ^W$@A@. 나. 병설대가 1Sõ> . ()* ><Ò > 56 (). 56"Sõ>eQ . *><}"_`Ê )@A@7¬. 4Sõ>eQQ%³Ë. /3. ä@ cQ³vQ74. ®@A@i4>79<Æ/>| @A@7N)¬/3 108. ý%E<Æ/3ÏÐ+"K8P¦p7¾ `]ù¬_`4s&<=³vQ74.

(42) . Q_`©\)>¬{W"Ð+£D. 58?4X1Õ4Fa<")>;ø8?. /3<}~)E¾ÒP¦¡B}¡%. 4X¬Ö/3<}~1íÛ%4"5\. 7"DvÏÐ4Sõ>¬{<}. ¬«% C<} H ä×} Ø)> 1Õ; ø. S4ÎÏOY;|/"56¿4°¡. 8?4X (7x\ ¬ý" -./8?. Sõ > ÐC<%E <Æ/3 YZä 56. aØ)>1Õæ¼(7¬3468?. A()*+,;FL¬x\ }W"ö. 7(7n:_`8?5"8?64X. *{@A@4X¬{W"ö*9¥<%E<Æ/3. o (7¬ 1Õæ¼; / ¬{<" -. /3. ,i3)> mn N)MN,i34°h)>{qr<=Å 7O8c)>C-ÌË/356"d¥ cK-.;¶<Æ"ª-Ìc`,i 34°h )>;µ n:<"@A@4X ] *¬{<$µ4n:@A@"í4:G <" @A@4X / )>; ¬{<" -./3 4QF@ c-.J¾<$56)> C ¤4(" |><}~ S¼v4 n:<" @A@"ú@A@7FaSõ4N)MN;<v ]4",i3)]*;¬FI<"Ð+£. ]ê8> ]Ù8>4QF 4(" ²´ùvÔÎ}~/C@A@564 X ]ê8> }l<vã/" ]ê; ]v8 \¬«¤j,ÔsvM<$D/3<}~9+ \" ]ê; ¤j ,Ôsv7 l7m<[\ @ c@A@56 Ä|]ê8>v|;°Ú%E <Æ/3 Nôx4°h)>. +vWË/3ì56"ÇÈ,i;N)M. 56"N)MN4°¡úD<}%E. N4°hCÈ,i\b³<X<"|¯%Ñ$. FI<vÏÐ456"¾8?N). D/3ì/h-ÌcN)MN;B@A@%¤<. <=C>BCD",i;3FI/3@A@. =Fa)>;%¤@A@C\äÒ"-ÌD. cF(GHn3P4°7D. }~"%¤W"@A@Ó4°¡)>e. 4úÊ<")>c@A@¬<=I. ¡n/"Ð+£D/3 Z Ð+£; Fg<v F @ c d¥ -.{|8-.;K<ÆWSn:SÔc> CD%E<"-.;K<Æ/3. /3 <}~ ÇÈC| \ N; ôx _`"567¬<%E<Æ/3 다. 초기대가. @ +-Ìc`1Û9½c567%. @ cAA×Q7¥³-½4F¥³O. N)MN@A@%¤<=%OC\,i3. afi³vQ7ßßßÛ1¬«x><%. )>;äÒHn:@A@4X¬{<$1Û. E<ÆßßÛ]}Wx\x><%. 4" % N)MN @A@7 §Ì 9+\ n:. E<Æ/3ßßÛ]}"¼vQ7x><. @A@4X)>;<$@A@7(7¬¬. $ßßÛ 4¼vQ7¥³-½;<=. c4n:<"@A@4X¬{<"-./3. \1Q7¥³B%³/3@ cßßÛ. %H²³K84QF(567%¤N. Q7¥³4"4¹5Û7;x><". )MNÈ@A@7yÆ"ªF45øy. ;Íx\<$D/3ÜÄ1Ý{ÜÄÝ"Q7¥. @A@~N)MN;È;_`F4"567. ³-½;x><=¥³O¼vAA×Q7/0R23 109.

(43)

(44) .

(45) [( . T?. |~. ~. 3231m2. 66. gg. 6£. 232. 66. 6Q. O. Æ2Y32Çn"È. 66. O£. O. Æ2Y32?n"È. 66. QgF. O. Æ2Y32QOÉÊË. 66. £g. O. . 89/3²ùØ_+&{\¯FQx \Cþçc%Á}R4":PQR()* CÈ7&4//h71ª7:#©è Ð+"y´8?Cþ¤;éHK7 ]P. Mê)¡"¿÷%QøWË/ 0è23 YZ[\ `ä¡4(% ©èÐ+ Fg ^P. <$ JviL4FgBCD"-ÌcÜ. . 8©4(N)_`@A@7N). K_è7}\vÑ]&7:#;. ¬<$4¹56c/h@A@4. É&<= ú8? 7:#4 jB C. XÙÇÕ]<"_`48>_{ÛCd. D%E<"7SNx¡8O/0Ú23 `ä¡4(ßßÛ¬«(n%³¯7:#. 8>7m=¬4°¡7ã;sXO/3. ,9,>-½c7:#;ú8?4Xy-.

(46) [(. \©è)"õ&<(S_û. OOb OOb A? |~. ~$. ;,&BCD"-½¡BCD/3u~§. I. 6. gF. . ¨¡ú8?]&#;>BCDX¿4. B. 6. . 6. °¡YiCþ;|\-¸$b.c%}.

(47)

(48)

(49)

(50) . R4©O()*pR_QW"&{7 = u~§¨¡%Fi³ãíFõ4%.c%. IV. 결 론. ;;\JO/3. ÜK7:#É&³bc³ã&Q4°. 참고문헌. ¡£íî7<"¾#}~SÞße¾à¡ ¯()*4Q>áôÃ2ýv FC\WË/3²ù7S.c7:_ã<$ D7Sâc()*Aã}_ã<$D" vÑ]&;>7:#É&³bcã/ .c>JviL4PQR()*4j. ¡m2! VWW211 X 034Y4Z[ 73] ¢]Z2 034 Y4Z12\W21XZ2WX31lq2!££g}6} 6 ¡m2! VWW211 X 034Y4Z[ oXX1 mX WX3! £££}} F ¡m2! VWW211 X 034Y4Z[ 2\23] ¤Xq2 X3mXZ2¥3mXqX3V]2!£££}}. BCD"|¥-Ì¯/3Z8c`. ¡m2!XWXXl30l343]¦WZ22!6OO6}}. ä¡4%8<"77/$BCD/3. Q ¡m2! VWW211 X 034Y4Z[ ¥34W\2 W21 34. `ä¡" 1ÚÚßÛQ ä¬« Ôù î7 ¯ «8>¯ô4v¯<=/C8?7PQR. W3]3W21!6OOO}Q} ¡m2!VWW211X034Y4Z[¤X3Wl1X3X3WZ]3] 3W2134mlZ234W\2WZ]21!6OOO}g}. ()*+,<$D/3<}~Xx\âc7. ¡m2! 22q3X3 l342 WX34X3 gF} Xm Z2. :#;ã|<$D"8?7vÑ]&()*. W23W2 Xm 71Z 822WXqql3WX31 23] X. +,<Ò}ëx8?7|¥<=Q¬8 ?"CÈe*É*F\1'o#; ôxFI~<Æ/3\¯<=ú8?cY ÛåQN)7¥Hä"ÙCþcS4 (8?{æ_û\¯<=£í&O 110. . §k¨J©ªcN

(51) «¬{

(52) fP

(53) =® w¯°=

(54) ^±²³´µ¶5·!6OO}}6g} AH S¸$=¹º9uG«w»¬¼¬½ ;QOO¾B¿ À~ÁÂÃÄz±r¶Å.

(55) . Z2WZ]21XmZ2X\1X3Xmq2WZmW. g ³´µ¶5·!}6F}. 213411XW2323X32W02!6OOO}6}. £ u sÌ$»= Í& Aj_ÎH j»Ï} 6OO}}}. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111.

(56)