공동생활주택(Co-housing)관련 법제개선방안 연구

(1)

Җسࢥഞલగ&RKRXVLQJ Қ۳ߩંёࢷߒঊৌҴ

이 준 호

(2)

(3)

! " #$%&"$ '

)(*!

(4)

! %"#$ &)#*+'( ,-.0%/

012 %3 54

86(7 29 :;< >=' 01? 57 #$+'(

CB@(A 29 01D @E@ 54

F'G JIH L K2 M? 57

,-.0%/ NPO 2Q RA S7 0KTU

57 VRA &)W R,X Y +' Z

% % [ [1 1

,-.0%/ \ &]

,-.0%/ \

%/ :; R

! %" ^ I_ MaP` bPO

F'G %"#$2 dc

(5)

,-.0%/ &]g h i F'G (

2Q MaP` b< jk2 )l?7 Hj( &]>K2

2mno fe2 54

( jkpo ! D>K2 qr )l? 2s

fet Dt' ,-.0%/ &]2 >Kc

,-.0%/ 6 [8 D

6[ D

w#vyuxh {z%xQ }|+' :;< >= ,-.0

%/ ~>2 @E@ V(7 V ,- .0%/ ~>X V+' AZ

8 D

~ (7 6{ ,-.0

%/2 01?+ Y C7 w %"jk

i+' ,-.0%/2 01c

,-.0%/ ~> &] A

,-.0%/ &] VRA A

,-.0%/27 &]X V+' AP7 C7

%/V I &]+' AX+'

,-.0%/g %" v H 2 `2

?n P7 Jl %/V I %/&]H }

(6)

X w( >K &]2` tA L

&t wV( wu+'( ,-.0%/X 01 P7 C %"jkI ,,%/ R,u+' ,-.0

%/X 01P7 CA V &] A2 Z ,-.0%/ ~> &] AX b< VRA \y

F'G %/&]+'( %/V &] +' &]A

X TAP7 C7 V KH *jKg ?w

:;< ! MaK2 ¢¡c

`£ %/V I &] 8X MPO ,-.0%/X ¥¤

P7 #*+' M§¦¦+' jP7 ,-.0,z27

`¨ ©JX L < V( 01ª 54

,-.0%/ ,« &)

N¬ VH jk -

,-.0%/2 w7 :;< M< MaKg

,-.0%/ jk :7 :! wjk u+'(

01K2 X 54 ,«%x :;

R < ,-.0%/ ,«g v®

R 54A ¯P h L 57 MI °<

,«%x'( ªH `2 %c

(7)

±²³j 01

,-.0%/H N¬ %/h {N´ µ ¶

· M< jg ±²V I ±²³j 01X §PO I¸

¹ º» 5` 2 M< 01K2 %c

,-.0%/H wjk -

,-.0%/2 wwjkH -?n A S7 01c +'¼ w R º w%{H ½ ¾

:;< T¿wÀHQ ÁÂª 54

` `M ÀH

,,%/ N¬ VRjÃ &)X b< ÄÀK 57 `Å

R,

j %/jk %"N¬ VR &)X b< ,-.0

%/ RA #* RT

(8)

#

$) !

! (

(9)

!

*#

+ & # $ %#

,

(10)

+#%# !

#

%

(11)

! #''*(&)"%*!&($ #"%*!&($ +*,.&- %*!&($ /-&0. %*!&($ ("1 !( %*!%.

(12)

Æ

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

"$

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 :

R \ ( Ç

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

R ° 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

R ° Èb999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

R \ ,-.0%/ 6[8 D

9999999999999999999999999 ;

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

%"h ,-.0%/ &] 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

,-.0%/ \ 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 <=

R ° 6[D999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 =

& 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 =

% D 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 =<

¾ º 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 >;

R ° 86 D9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

Y 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

ÉÊË 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

`E 6 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

(13)

R ° ,-.0%/ N¬ % ÌW¶99999999999999999999999999999999 ;

,-.0%/ ~> &]A N¬ ÌW 999999999999999999999999 ;

,-.0%/ ,« N¬ ÌW 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 >

R ° ,-.0%/ N¬ VR &)99999999999999999999999999999999999999999 =

,-.0%/ ~> &]A N¬ &) 9999999999999999 =

,-.0%/ ,«#$ &) 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 <

,-.0%/ 0KQ b< &) #* 999999999999999999999999999999 >

R < \ º Ç

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

Í Î

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

(14)

R °

R \ ( Ç

6 %/jkg RÁÏ u´h Ð¯n( PÑ ?

¸ T` wu´h RK\ ¹b`Q L+'

PÑ : Ò %/jkg ±ÓH N¬c+'¼ RI_

`- X 3Ñ » Ô2 j +' %/X ,«P

"@ z+' wX P7 C7 ÖÕ2 ¯×PÑ ?n

:;< RI_ ºj ¾·Ñ X 3Ñ : S< 6{·

%" M< ØB %" g `Y+'

TMt' -P: Ù Ú` 2 M< {ÛPÑ

aPO ª Ô2 -T %"ww+'( ww

u+' %/jk2 01» 57 I_A MÃPO ª Ô2 : 2ÜÑ Ý< jk ßÞH T` i Ma ( %/

jk 2mnwÑ ?7à 2á< %/jk X

%7 :;< ¾ ßâ?n F'G %" åäã'( %3

57 %/~>2,-.0%/2 ª 5:

,-.0%/ 2æ çè ëêéì ,zX Óy<

%",z+' ,-x íÆX Ê¬PO %vz ¾§?îïh .0

RQ ºP"@ ,-x 0-X ZðP7 F'G >= %/X ñ

<: `£7 uç+' %/X ¾~P %".0X bP"@

ô«< ,-.0%/ &]j7 (õftT( poP7 ,-x%/jk

X ¾&P7 2å( 1< jà 2 j7 (õftT pojk(

,-.0%/27 ©JX 1Pw ö ,-x%/2 1nQ 1P

( j< [12: ,-.0%/H ,-x%/ &] -K O7 NW

Ý< 2 Á.ª 5+@ ,-.0%/g po :;

< &]+' j P` Y(7 ÷ÈbPÑ 1? 57 ,-

(15)

<

S7 E ¾~ %/X øMPO j `z j< ±

( %"Q 1P7 #$2 CB@ %" .0#

$2 Ù 57à h %" v· F'G

( FùÑ @Eú %"21 .0#$2 ,-.0%/2

ª 5:

Jâ j7û %"òÞ´üX Á©P( x [1+

'( ,,øM%/ ,« M ,«#$ :; l%/

,« M ,«#$ :; ýþÿ2 0K ÏĀµ

%"Ã w ā %"ww x´ jÃ %/øM T\

Ă &) %"i &) ~wNB 0K poX ,©P ă: û %"òÞ´ü(7 ,-.0%/ &]X

2 T+' ©JPO wjkX poPĄ:7 [1g Úw

Jâ CB@ %" ! %" MaP` b

< %"ww %"i &) jk2 Ćąo Ô+' ć»

5: 2á< jkg ,-.0%/ A M< p og Ĉéw CB@( 29 %" åäã'( \P 5 7,-.0%/ M< 01H RA i R,X Kª 57

jku+'( 9Q o: Ù 5:

S< Jl V(7 VD( fjw fjMIX

+' < wĉ S7 jÃĉ Hj(,-.0%/X 0 1P7 VA Tl? 5: ¸ V Þª 57

,-.0%/ ~>H &]X VRA+' ¥¤Z+'¼ jh

w#vyux jkpo M< V `X R,P 5: Ù

.0%/ ¹ &]·X ¥Ċ+' ©J<:7 ċ( ,-.0%/2

7 ©J+' §PO 1P`' <:

6î§ û %"òÞ´ü 6î§ = <A

M© VD7 ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV 2:

(16)

R °

=

5: 28A w#vyux(7 D RjH TlX §P O w %/0K +' VRA `(

,-.0%/ 01H RAQ TAP 5:^< ( 2á<

j < %"jk h w#vyux x2 w

jkpo ØB F'G %" Ēø+'( M© D

ª 57,-.0%/ M< VRA L < T`

ª 5:

2IH ēg :;< ! VRA &) d2

2mnw 57 ,-.0%/ M< VR &)#*2 Y

#2 ª 5: x+'7 ĕĔ Jl %/ N¬ V

x´ [(,-.0%/ &]2 vBÝX 57 VRA i M< C)?n ª Ô2: ãT V &] A

2 E¸P: Ù A Ú+@ jkpo2@ {z01 \`

ċ( V ` K ! &)2 L P: ª Ô2 : ĖĔ ,-.0%/ RA V ` KX bPO 6[

( %" åäã ØB j < ,,%/,«j k MaP ,-.0%/ ,«X 0Kª 5A ė %/V %/ N< V·X PO F'G ,,%/~>

+'( ,-.0%/ ,« 0K MPO <: 2Q

bPO ,-.0%/ ,«#$ &)X b< P %/

&) ,-.0%/ 0KQ bPO Á.» 57 R·X

<:

2IH ēg #X }|+' PO F'G JIH

L K2 M? 57 ,-.0%/ NPO 2Q RA

< M© D Ö'( (õftT ĘAT JX b< w

`Y D Tl < (õftTD R=;ę (õftT %/

0K w N< D Tl :< (õftTD Rę 5:

(17)

S7 0KTU 57 VRA &)W R,X Y

+' <:

R\(7 ,-.0%/ \ H Zð 6[8( 29

01? 57 ,-.0%/ ~>H D MPO )l

PO jBPAė <: ,-.0%/g VB+' Ý<

¶2`:7 ! åäãQ VRA+' wP

`KX P7à }WX Ěn ª ¶2` ,-.0

%/ \ M< L ª Ô+' ěu:

( ,-.0%/ &]H Zð Ĝ?n ª %" &]

M( ĝĞ %/åäã '( \P` Tğ< ĠnPC þh %/ MPO <: CB@(7 w#vyux X }|+' 29 ġg ,-.0%/ D·2 ²?n 5+

2 : Ģ( ~H Y 5n(7 Ĉ% Ĥģ Ïĥ CB@

h -< X `+' PO ,-.0%/2 0K?

: 2á< 6· ,-.0%/ \ g CBÑA ġg T

WX Ħ Ô+' ěu?n tA' tPO <:

CB@ :;< D M(7 )l Q §PO zħ PÑ DQ ¾&P Y (7 ¸ Dt' VRA ċ

X Ĝ< ¹ĨX PAė <: )l ºH 29 ġg

,-.0%/ N< D·2 29 CB@( \PO G?

57 Ô+' ?7à Y (7 Ãî óĩ D'(

«Ī< MaP7 fe Đī2 %?7 DQ }|

+' V ċ ¹ĨH PO VRA TWX AĬP

`' <: fĭ 6[ &tD· 5n( VRA+' w2

(18)

R ° Èb

:

L < ¹H RAÁÏ \Į » 57 ¶· MPO ¹

º#* X ª 5Aė <:

R\(7 YĪ+' ,-.0%/ VRA &)#* M<

h ¹ĨX P7à ËÑ w # įpn( Q o lPAė <:

ĕ İĔ #g Jl %/ N¬ V x´ [(,-.0

%/ &]2 vBÝX 57 VRA i M< Q l

<: ãT V &] A2 E¸P: Ù A Ú+@ jk po2@ {z01 \` ċ( V ` K

! &)2 L P: ª Ô2: ,-.0%/ &]X V &

]+' AP7 C7 RAG *jKH wıK2 Ć»

5w VRA G2 Ĳ 57 KH 1R<K+' PO

RAG K2 }| `+' ěu?7 ,-.0%/ Á Ï r» 5:7 WX Zð Ĝ<:

Ě İĔ #g ,-.0%/ RA V ` KX bP O 6[( %" åäã ØB j < ,,

%/,«jk MaP ,-.0%/ ,«X 0K

ª 5Aė %/V %/ N< V·X PO F'G , ,%/~>+'( ,-.0%/ ,« 0K MPO <

: 2Q bPO ,-.0%/ ,«#$ &)X b< P % / &) ,-.0%/ 0KQ bPO Á.» 57

R·X <: Äĳ+' %/ N¬ V· [12 H" u Ĵ< 6´ü ĵ< %/,«jk( w Ķ>ÁÏ

ċ %/,«jk+' i?n 5:7 W ķ*PO F 'G %/~>+'( ,-.0%/X MI+' P7 %/,«jk

ĸá:ø Þ< VRA &)#* ĐĹX <:

(19)

>

( ,-.0%/ ~>ĺ Ĉé Jl øM%/ ,«J_

%/,«ċ 2mnĻ ª Ô2 ÄR 5n( Á .» 57 %/ V N´ ÌW X p+' Z +'¼ ,-.0%/2 °PÑ Jl VRA' ļ» 57 #*

X <:

S< ,-.0%/X ,«3"@ vÁ+' %< &·z Á .PÑ ?7 ¾~N´ ¹Ìº#* N¬ wz 2N´j

ÌW2 ,-.0%/ 0K 5n( } < ÌW2 » 5 : 2á< ÌW·g VRA Ľ *( ºª 57 #*A

5w JÄ 5n( ¸vz vÁ ³+' 2mnĻ ª

¶+' ěu: ( 2á< ÌW· M(7 VRA 1

N< ĩ :7 VRA wª 57 #*H jk w

u MPO ª 5Aė <: : ÌW fKI VRA

º :7 jk º2 : Àľ C ġ`

x VRA &):7 "T #K RT Y (7

Ð E¸ª Ô+' ěu:

2IH ē2 ( \PÑ F'G %/~>+

'(,-.0%/ M< 6[ 8 D Q §PO \

RAG ĐīX P ,-.0%/ ,« ċH

ċ( Á.» 57 VRA ÌWX AĬPO 2 M< VR

&)#* AĬX Y Èb' <:

(20)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

;

R \ ,-.0%/ 6[8 D

%"h ,-.0%/ &]

%" &]

,-.0%/ &]g %/27 \¾ &] ıKX Ĳ 5

` ¸ĭ %" &]H Ŀg N¬KX wÑ :⁼ %

" N< &]g uĴ< \¾ 9ĺ Ĉé

9'( &]X ¥ZP7 Ô+' Ĩª 5: ,-.0%/

&]7 1nI ©J(A @E@ 5ŀ2 %/ &

] ,-.027 &] ¾ ¥Z?n 5:

ěuª 5` uĴ< \¾ 9'( %/2 w7

&] : ¥Ċ ıK2 p?n 57%" &]2 ,-.

0%/ &]H ´» 5:7 WX łŁª 5: ( C)

+'7 \¾ 9 %/ &]ĺ Ĉé %" &]X

= %/V R Rę P %/2æ µM K2 \`z çè %"

.0X ª 57 ' ±²Ń Ï S7 Ø ıwQ ñP

uç%/H ,-%/+' ¹<:' íjP 5` %/ &]7

\¾ &]X ÏR' P 5: Ù 5: <ń %/H N¬X w7 %

" &](A :4 ĵ%( ÓP 5ŀ2 \¾ &]X L+' ÏR P 5:

%"`YV (7 %" V jQ íjP 5w ö` j< V

9Q P` nŅw %"`YV R %"ņ M< íj(7

ŃB bŇ+'ĥ ňn@ ŉP *j %"i ( z:G

%".0X ª ņBQ Ĳ7:' íjP 5` \¾ i 28

i X ¥ZP7 Ô+' ěuª 57 ĩ" %"`YV í j?n 5: Ĩª 5: <ń 6[ )l 2Kâ ór%"` 9Ŋ

¾Q b< %"w jk ¹Ĩ &)#* ÏÁÏ ; (A 2h ēg 9Q ÓP 5:

(21)

ĝĞ7 Ô2 } P: 6[ )l(7 :4H ē2 %"

&] MPO ÓP 5:^:

%" P7 &]g ŃB "ŋ'( %/H 9' ( %"Q ĐĚ ¥Z<: ŃB %/H N¬< %"ņg

z:G .02 < TÓH (Ãþ < %/ "%ª

57 ņBQ 9<: O`( z:G .02 P: P7

Ôg uĴĭ ÃQ ×ª 57 "ŋ 2I 9Q Ĳ7: Ò v

â b³+'ĥ *Ï P ·2 ó¾< ŉ

< .0X ª 57 jA ŃB,z2 ?n 5n <:

7 Ô 2: S< ĵò ńTÓ ÖQ · IPAh Ï`TÓ

(Ãþ `Y+' Ĳp 5n <: ØŌ W( wú

û %/V ór%"`X T< Ôg V+' ŃB

%/ M< ņBQ óÅ' ©< Ô27 W( Ë:

: I` )l P ór%"` &]g Bz :G .0X bP` b< ó¾< %".0 `C2 ª 5+

V &]g B6{2 ŉP ĝ` ōg .0X P` bPO L

< ó¾< %"`CX 9P %/V R= -V Tl¦

R: " 6;\N2 Ój ,< `X ñ<: `

¨Pă+@^> %"`YV2 Rj 2s7 %"`YV R:

ēg V Tl¦ R ( 6î§\N2 Ój ,< `

X ñ<: ª 5: ( CB@( %" %"`

H N¬PO(7 ÄIPÑ %"`YV (%"7 V &

] `Y `X R,P ór%"` x [1X í jZ+'¼ ±²V %/V H N¬ V( %"h N¬ ¶

MPO &] `X R,P7 `H ŎX èPÑ ?:

Ù 5:^;

: 2Kâ ór%"` 9Ŋ ¾Q b< %"w jk ¹Ĩ &)#* Ï

ÁÏ ;

> 2Kâ Ģ (

; : Jl %"`YV g V x´h :ŏÑ jíjX Ě 5w

(22)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

<ń+' ,-.0%/H N¬PO(7 %"`YV H Tl¦

íjg ŐC } < Ĝ ¾'( ?n ª ¶2 Ù

5: Ò %"`YV Tl¦ R P j Ój ,

P7 ór%"`7 ãT Kt ó¾ %" 1 At # & Ï1ő\Ä L ÓÃ `

*ÏKŉK X Ĝ< %/ K i `2 ¥Z

?n <: 2á< `·g w( ór< `+'

R,?7 ¶2 ª 5: ØŌà ,-.0%/ C7

I`< ór%"` ¾·2 %/H7 ŐC :ŏÑ Ĝ» Œ Ú: ª Ô2: %"H LÓÃ `g , -.0%/H %/( ġg 2 œ 5+ i ` S

< -< I_( `X ÓjP7 Ôg E¸Pw öX Ô2:

( ,-.0%/ A H N¬ jkpo(7%" M

< `Y V `H `X Ĝ< [1+' ?n po?n

ª Ô+' .ĵ: fĭ ww ċ( jk+'

G?7 ,-.0%/ C7 %".0X ~P7 %/,z+

'( `2 ā?w ö vŔ +' G ŕuTÓH ē g +' G» KA 5X 5: 27 Jl wTÓ X ,-.0%/+' GPÑ ? Á.» 5: Ù 57à

wTÓH %/g Ŗĭ TÓ ±² 2 5+

w?7 ÖÕH TÓ01 #$(A 2 œ 5:

ö: Ò %" MPO T+' V &]X jPw ö %"`YV R( %"ņ MPO 6{g N´ V¦ D' jP7 ŗ Ń B bŇ+'ĥ ňn@ ŉP *j %"i ( z:G %

".0X ª ņBQ Ĳ7:7 íj+' ÎVI `Yņ [1H +' %

"ņX íjP 5: 2á< Ŏíj+' PO %/H N¬ ĐŘ V·g

%"`YV I ŎíjX ª Ô2 N¬ jkpo S< 2 Ŏíj

ÞPAė po?n ª Ô2:

(23)

2á< 2~' %"`YV I ór%"`H ,-.0%/

%/`H N¬KX ª 2Q VRA+' &)<:7

w' ĩª Ô2 Ĉé ,-.0%/ ±²H G M< Ŏ `+' %"`YV I ór%"`X ĜPO ª Ô 2: RA &)¶ M(7 Jl %"`YV R: R¶

(7 6î§\N2 6{2 ŉP ĝ` ōg .0X P`

bPO L < ó¾< %" N< w©'( ór%"`X

Ój ,PAė íjP 5: Ĉg ,-.0%/2 0K?

2 M< tA `2 VRA ċ( ĩP 5w ög I _2` T`I7 ćQ 3X 5w s7 ór

%"` Ój , 2mnĳ 7 ,-.0%/ M< `

A 2 ¥Z?n ,©?n ª Ô2:

%

%"`YV R

R:ór%"` Ój 6î§\Ng 6{2 ŉP ĝ

` ōg .0X P` bPO L < ó¾< %" N< w©

'( ór%"`X Ój,PO <:

R¶ 6î§\N2 ór%"`X Ój,PĜ 7 C7 9B N´ }řlj`N \H ³< s %"jk|

b |Q "Ś <: , ór%"`X PĜ7

CA S< ē:

ór%"`7 %" 1At # & %/ Ó ÃK i ¾ M§¦¦+' jP7 ¶2 ¥Z?n

P R O± Ø jK2 ~w?n

<:

%"`YV Tl¦ R

Rór%"` [1 V R: 6î§\N2 Ój ,P7 ór%"`7 :4 ĵ ę ¶2 ¥Z?n <:

(24)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

,-.0%/ &]

Y %R2( MI ,-.0%/ 2!ŗ śPCe

27 %/ &]g ¸ %/2 P7 ŗ ( :! &]

j :ŏÑ @E@` wŜP7 1n S< §?n 1

? 5w7 ö: Ù 5: Jâ ,$+' x %/jk

i+'( (õftT( po? 57 ,-x%/jk(

jP 57 :4H ēg &]2 \ 2 Ù 5:

Ò (õftT(7 ,-.0%/ AX b< ,-x%/jk

X poP( ,-x%/ MPO çè ëêéì ,zX Óy

< %",z+' ,-x íÆX Ê¬PO %vz ¾§?îïh .0

RQ ºP"@ ,-x 0-X ZðP7 F'G >= %/+'

jP 5: (õftT(7 I`< ,-x%/ &] M PO &]X KP7 ¾ ( ÓP 57à 2Q jBP

:4H ē:

,-x%/g ŝĈŝ Şs.0 Ö¨ Åû. "%P7

ş· fe f?7 %/2: "%v·2 Zð Š7 ë êéì ,z2 %/ [ 5n( "%v 01 :;P Ñ 01? ,z 01#$ )/2 P: ëêéì ,zg

A$ X §PO ÓP 57 [1X Lv jBPO 1< [12:

Kt ó¾ %"

1At # &

Ï1ő \Ä L ÓÃ `

< *ÏK ŉK X Ĝ< %/ K i `

(25)

<

: ,zH f,z+' 01» 5: : ,z+'(7

"%v }| w%{ ¾š 01 ,zîŝ l 01H

"%vh w%{2 Zð Š7 š 01 ,zśŢţ Ťť

+' 01» 5+ f,zg B·X b< ,-%#

·X b< ğĉÄ ÖQ b< ŦÄ :;< %R' \

P: ª 5: S< Zð ĝ( ŧÑ » 57 ½X

Ö#P` bPO "%v·2 Zð ã7 ,-xíÆA 57à ŝ Ĉ> Şs.0 Ö¨ Åû. O± įÑ ©íÆ X 01PO íÆX Ê¬<: P7 `z -* j< øMŨ'

"%ª 5Aė øM>%/01A P:

I`< (õftT( 1P 57 ,-.0%/ &]g :;

PÑ ¹» 57 57,-.0%/ fK MaPO jkp o ó» 57 ¾·'( KPO :¾ G 5n(

K2 ũnĳ 5:7 W2 CĜ: Øá@ w#vyux

< ÄI YĪ ,-.0%/ &]A27 WX Û*<:

RAG K :7 jkpo ó C)» 5 :7 Wg Ū¹ĭ Ĝ» 5X Ô2:

2h ŊB ,-.0%/ NPO : :;< H I_X 1ª 5Aė 6[ )l(7 :4H ē2 ,-.0%/ N

< x ÓX P 5:

;:ûM ÉÊË( ŋ4 Tğ Ô+' ÉÊË ±² ū Ŭŭ

2n µŮ $Ã I Q 2ůH Zð ³PO

.0 ª 57 %">=Q ķ*< Ô+'ĥ TğPO 2s É ÊËh þŰÉX }|+' Õ? ;>>û űëŲåh ųŴ

96 ¾&?( śPCe 1n 1?: ś PCeg ±²Ń b% ATâ.2 Ĉŵ Ø * "%P 57

ş ÅWX Ŷ ,-x G- P@'( Jâ ÉÊËQ Ãŷ<

~ wH 96 Y w( śPCe M< N|2 M?

Ÿ{Ĩ X §< AT0 Ź` µ´h AT Dę :

(26)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

=

5+ CB@ w(A śPCe >= %"uwQ

KP 5: śPCeg ÊX,-xQ P 2ůz N´ >

KH ³X źP7 : Ż ,-x G-+' ÁÏPă: śPC e } < fe+'(7 %{2 ÍOP7 Hj ĐŘ

2ů·2 ÍOPAė uwQ Ó´ ,-TÓ 21 šM

%{ < ~wNB Ã´« ,- R0- ®w 2 57à 2á< HjX §PO ,-.0H ĂB2żT Ķ>X

2mÑ :

Jâ CB@(7,-.0%/27 ©J 28 ~< Ž X w 5+( :! ©JX 1P7 C 5: Ò Yĳ

¹X -P( j< ±2@ fe( 2Q w(

,-.0%/27 ©J 28 1nQ 1P7 C ġ2 5 7à 2ŋž ,-.0%/ 28 1?7 1n· M<

L ª Ô2: 2á< I_g Jâ'(7 Ĉ ,-.0%/ S7

śPCe27 ©J2 V+'@ jk+' < wbQ w

5w ö` 2A Ù 5: ( %/jk+' S7

+' Á.?7,-.0%/ ~>2 Á.» Ê: °

< 1nQ 1PÑ c+'¼ 1n §2 2mnww ö 57

2~'A .ĵ» 5: :4 A© [1g ,-.0%/ &]

H N¬PO 6[ )l(,-.0%/H Yĳ+' ~<

KĪH feX w 5+( ¹ 2' PO :ŏÑ © J?7 ~&]X Ó< [12:

,-.0%/H ~ &]

,~%"

%{· .0,z Q Zð 1P7 %"~>+' ,~%" S 7,~%/27 1n 5: ,~%/g µ` Å (( T ğ &]+' ,-%/H ŊB %",z Q Ę2 Ĉŵ ş

(27)

·H ,~P7 %"~>2: óĩ 6[(A %"Ã12 g (õ

Õ MATQ }|+' %"Ã1 °ÛH .0 ĳX 2` b

< #*+'( dû^X MI+' Õ? 57 pµ2`A P: ,

~%"?%/5 3 g V+' j &]2 Ĉéw I¸ĭ

Ĥģ Ïĥ 1 &]+' 1 MI2@ 2 1n@ ſP 7 #$2 ®ƀ I2P: +' µ` Å ~ 6(

Tğ?n 96h YX "Ś Oá 6' Õ Ô+' ĵ @

@ fK :ŏÑ Ï&?: ,~%" Ż Ľ g "%{ z %"h N¬ nƁ ÔX ,~ZX ÏR' <: ØÔ X çè+' ¾~P"@ 1P`7 R 2~' ÃÀ ľ ÃÞB2` 2: ( ,~%" `Y g R

Àľ [w7 ÞB ª 5: ,~%"( ,~

P7 MIg C)+' ,z+' §g ƂÄ 8 ,z Ò "Ä ő $¸ \Ä ,zX ,~P7à 2 "%{·g ,~Q §

%"Ã1X °ÛP( ƃ Ð Ƅ ù ŉ< %"i X P Ñ : ((7 Ĉŏŗ2å@ 1ƅ+' .´Q ~wP7 MƆ.·

2@ Ā«2 \2 ¯*j< Åû.·X }|+' #2@

%/X ,~P7 .0#$2 29 ƇB ƈĻ5: CB@ T %"

Ã12 g (õH AņX }|+' dû^ M*%"' Õ?

57 pµ' (õ¾ƉþƊ:ã §-ŕ2@ ƋnPCþC% 2

ĐĚ 2 È% ¥Z:

,-ƌ

,-ƌE 3#g ;>ûM Å þŰÉ( yŐŞ2@ jƍ

\ĮX b< %",z( Tğ &]+' ƂÄH ƎŢÄ \

Ä z2ő+' K &,z( .0P "Ä2@ $¸

,zX ,~<: Øá@ çè nĜG ş· ,-x . 0X § vè.0X wP 2Q b< ÏĆ2 %/ [ I%

P 5:7 W( :¾ I2< &]2 ª 5: S< %",z

:7TÓ &]2 Ð Ë 2 6[(7 %' u` øT

"ŋ' 1:

(28)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

:

I`< ŗh ēg ,-.0%/ &]H ~&]g Äĳ+'

&]jè2 )l? 2 ! jkpoH RA²2 2mno

C Ĉé f< %" M< L K2 R`? 2Q ¾ P` b< jkpoH RAGX P7 Hj( 2· jkH RA

PO >K &]2 ª 5: ( &]H jk RA

,£PÑ ?7 I_(7 &]·2 ſB+' S7 x´+'

>K?w ƏP &]>K 2 ?Ɛ jkH RA PO

AĬ &]·2 Ù 5: ( ~< KĪX w(A

t ¾ £âPÑ ?7à 2á< ,-.0%/ &]>K

( 27 feg ,-.0%/2 h i F'G

( 2Q MaP` b< jk2 )l?7 Hj( &]>K2 2m nƑ` 2 ª 5: :4(7 2á< +' j

%/wjkH Ă'Øƒ N< Dh 2 ( >K ,-.0

%/ &] NPO Ó<:

w%/

w%/5% 3 g çè .02 nĜG ş·\Į

ŞƓ Ɣśƕ}çv Ñ L < Ũ@ .0w (ÃþQ

%/ ºÞ< Ô+' 2·2 w jķPO .0ª 5Aė

Ɩ7 %"~>2: ( (Ãþ,zH .0 Q ,~P`7 P

@ ,-ƌH ÊƗw' %{ MIÈb : ³¾P vèw

X ÏR' <:7 ċ( :¾ I2P:

Ĭŋ@ ±²AT,z¾ ÊXâ. "WĐĎ'( ,~%" KG

ŐýƘ ±²AT,z¾ AT,zâźƙĥ =

>A

(29)

>

,-.0%/H j wĂ'Øƒ

jw Ă'Øƒ D

CB@( @E@ 57 ,-.0%/ \ Ěãáo feg

}řj S7 w#vyux < %/,«jk i+' 2mn o:7 W2 Óª 5: Ò ,-.0%/ j%A ,

«2 Ĉƚw7 0K?n 5w öw JÄ+' %/ú ¾ h w %/jk Àľ M*+'( RT» 5:7 f eX ,-.0%/2 Ĳ 5` 2 M(7 s ġg j k Ï& 2mnĳ Ô+' ÖI: 2á< w( ,-.0%

/H ór.0`g Ŀg N¬KX Ĳ 5: Ù 5+ }ř j S7 w#vyux(7 ór.0`X ŪĘTƛ` b<

w ċ wu+' ,-.0%/X 01PÑ ?7 CQ

ÖIª 5Ñ :

2á< ċX Ĝ<: ,-.0%/ `g Jl ór.0`

X ĜPO ,-.0%/ `X 01Z+'¼ ƜMIv·

Ñ ór.0`X ÅHª 57 .0 ÀHQ Á.TU 5A ė po?n ª Ô2: Ò ww u+'( ,-.0%

/X 01P7 C7 ,-.0%/ `2@ po[1X Jl

ór.0` įƝ( poª Ô2 Ĉé Ø `X IP 7 +' GPO Äĳ+' ,-.0%/X 01< `MÀH Q ŪĘª 5X Ô2: :4 A© [1g I`< ŗh ēg j

w Ă'Øƒ D MPO 6[ )l( ¾&P 57

DQ Ó< [12:

ŃÇ {z < %/,«A D 5+@ VRA ċ(7 j S7

w#vyux PO V¦ S7 D ĩ"PO wP7 >= ġ: Ù

5: 2 M(7 R\ R° ,-.0%/ M< D¹Ĩ( Ó<:

(30)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

;

jw Ă'Øƒ D

Ččw Ş ĩª 57 j %"w Ă'Øƒg

r¾ƞ Ïµv®w Čnč%/&Ɵĉ 2 5+ wvx

( &t+' poP 57 Şs%/ Ś%` ĉ 2 5:

ØŌà r¾ƞ Ïµv®wg 2ľF' rƠPw ¾ ƞ2 n ÄR w3X 57 ®ơg rª Œ Ú: S< Č nč%/&Ɵĉg %/&ƟX b< R `2 Æ< Ş

ĩP` JÄ+' nŅ: ØB Şs%/ Ś%` ĉ g ór%"`9Ŋ ¾7 jk © Ój?w öĈ ĉ MI po[1 ( ór%"`9Ŋ ¾h NK2 :

ØB Ƣƣ: Ččw Ş7 "% 9'( %/:7

Ũ w (Ãþ H N¬ Ƥ ĳ R %"w }

< 2: ØŌà 2á< %"w wg ÀľK< ub ńƥX

Ʀ` b Ƨ Ã1 jA ſB ÄI po2 nĜG Ä j2: Ò Ččw H¾ÊX2 P Ş "%,z2

Õâ?n 5n íĐ (ÃþQ R,P` nĜG Ô2: S< Č čw Ş %"R7 R`2 Zð ?n ª Ô2:

( Ččw Ş ór%"` 9ŊX ¾P jíĐ

2I Q `+' < %"(Ãþi `ÅTÓ Ũ w

R,X b(7 %/&Ɵ 2 Ú7 ŞQ MI+' < Čč

> ØƨƌX Ĝª 5: Čč> Øƨƌg v+' %"IX p oP"@ %/& 2 Ú7 ŞQ MI+' %"` Ă

K w ,-+' .0ª 57 "%,zX R,P7 &]

2: 2Q § #zę(Ãþ uw[ oŨ¾ Óy Ş%"h

Ʃ< (ÃþQ R,ª 5+ %/NB,u( po} u w¾8´^ .0*j ńwh NBƌƪĥ.0w ę NB ĉH ´Q § w(ÃþQ āTU 5X Ô2: Č č> Øƨƌ KT j ¾ƞ`X źĬP` b Øƨƌ

%P7 ŞQ MI+' ,-ğĉ\X R,P7 #*A ?

n ª Ô2: Ččw Ş7 ¾íĐ Č>=' R`

(31)

I` )l( ÓP 57 ,-.0%/ D7 Čnč2

7 f< w I_ įpn( po?7 j wĂ'Øƒ

PO >K ,-.0%/ < >= M< Ó2 ª

5: I` )l D7 ft< w I_X ÏR' jkp o2 2mno Cà ,-.0%/ C7 \W2 ª

57 01 ċH ` ċ+' PO :;< MIH I_

Maª 57 %/~>2 Ù 5: ( I` )l

( ô«< D7 Čnč Þ< >= ,-.0%/2 >K

CQ Ó< Ô2 28 :! I_H MI M(A :;< >

= ,-.0%/2 >K» 5: 2á< jk RA TlH

GX §PO ,-.0%/g ¸ MIH I_ į7 &]>K2

2mnwÑ ? jkH RA VR' 2nw7 u´(7 ,- .0%/ &] S< V &]+' vBÝX 5Ñ : :4

(7 j jkH RA V `X >KPO Tl G?7

C 2 ! ,-.0%/ V &] MPO Ó<:

jw Ă'Øƒ V `

óĩ7 %/ N¬ VR } ¶ M(7 ¹V2 2mnw

"@ V RX PO V H wQ ĭ P7

2 ÆP` lj( ,-+' ČÕŃ S7 wfƫX

.Õª 5Aė wQ R,P Čĉ`¨ƙĥ `¨wX §

.ÕX RTU ór%"`9Ŋ %"w IX ` Mª 5X Ô2:

Ĭŋ@ 2Kâ ór%"` 9Ŋ ¾Q b< %"w jk

¹Ĩ &)#* ÏÁÏ ;>A;;

(32)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

VRA 2mnw 5:^< `Y2 Ŏ+' j p oª 57 wĂ'Øƒ jkpo ĩ"7 V S7 D

Ê¬?nw7à 2ÜÑ V `X >KPO jk2 po?7 C

jku+'( ,-.0%/ &]2 A» 5: 27

,-.0%/ V A2 )l 2s Ïx jkH RA ²

C Ĉé Ïx jkH RA Tl G 2s

¸ X ŊKP` b< u+'( ,-.0%/2 01c+'¼

V &] 2mno C ª 5: M© D'( J l %/ N¬ V( j wĂ'ØƒX Gª 5Aė V

ĩ"Q Ê¬P 57 VH Ø [1g :4 A©h ē+ 2 P( ÖTP 57 ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đo X b< ftV C7 V TlH jk poX bPO , -.0%/2 V+' A Ö ª 5:⁼

< =û %"`YV [12 %/V ( çèP øM%/V 2 {z øM%/ N< ftV H ,,%/ ftV +' ¹V?:

= ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV R R;ę(7

,-> Čnč%/X íjP 5:

%

%"`YV

R%/ ±Ó ,« 6 w#vyux7 %/2 x´

2 Àľ+' ±Ó ,«?Aė ŞP %/T\ %/

Õĉ2 ±ÏPÑ `ª 5Aė ~APO <:

RøM%/ ,« 6 w#vyux7 r¾ƞ^

%"w2 L < ´^X b< ,,øM%/X ,«PO <:

6 w#vyux7 {zøM%/ ,«2 0K» 5 Aė wPO <:

6 w#vyux7 `ĉ ³-Þ ÃBu x ,ƥ +' øM%/X ,«ª 5Aė wª 5:

(33)

R,-%/ NB 6 w#vyux7 6{2 ĝ` ōg

%".0X bª 5Aė ƧP Àľ ,-%/ NBx´

Q ²PO <:

R<%"i jÃ 6 w#vyux7 %"i X j ÃP Şs%/X &ƟPO %{ Ƥ ĳ2 &)» 5Aė w

PO <:

R=%"Ã 6 w#vyux7 %"Ã Ć2 H:P O %".0X bP` nĜG r¾ƞÑ %"«OQ w«P O <:

R%"Æv w 6 w#vyux7 \Į¦v

%"Æv *ÏP ńB< %".0X bª 5Aė wPO

<:

{

{zøM%/ N< ftV

R< 6 w 6 w#vyux7 :4 ĵ ę X

bPO %/AT`®V ! %/AT`®2P %/AT`®2

<: v®X C)+' wP µfDR<V w#

µfDR<V D' jP7 ŗ µQ Ûª 5:

{zøM%/ ,« M

{zøM%/ &Ɵ ƫĳ R

`ĉ ³-Þ ÃBux {zøM%/ ,«

ÍO ~A

< %/øMNBĉ ŝK

ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV

R jÃ´ü è jÃ wj T\Ƭd\g

òÞ´üX ĜPO jÃ´üX èP 2Q %{Ñ (+'

§< s %{ÓQ P 2I %{Ñ ,şP %{

ƭX ·g s 2Q ƮPO ÷T\ ftvyT\ Aw S7

ftvyAw2P TAw <:Ñ jÃwjX ƍd

(34)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

PO <: jÃ´ü [1X ª L 5X 7 ēg °

Q "Ś wjX ƍdPO P? M§¦¦+' jP7 9

< ¶X P7 C7 %{ M< (§ %{Ó % {,ş ƭd °Q "yw Ĉéª 5:

R¶ ! jÃ´ü7 :4 ĵ ę ¶X ¥ZPO <

: : R>ęĥ R<ęƚw ¶g L < C è<:

jÃĉ Ŝ jÃ by

jÃĉ Tl #$ ÖjT`

jÃĉ TlÖjv

< 1 S7 1ª wŃņņB µ(

= ĉÃ âŊ N< ¶

NÏ§ÊXČnčjÃ N< ´ü : Čnč%/ ¿w K&)

> ,-> Čnč%/ Óy´ü nƯ2 0- ,z

; Čnč øM%/ ,« NB

w21´üjÃ`TÓ´ü,-21TÓ Óy´ü

i Ï N< ´ü

6 ´ü 21 N< V RR:ę ! AT Ƭ´üTÓ Óy N< ´ü

6 ´ü 21 N< V R=R¶ ĵ ę ¶

N< ´ü

< Ø Œ jÃĉ TlX bPO L < ¶+'( M§¦¦

+' jP7 ¶

G2P .ħH

\

\Į ¦v %"Æv w N< V

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

%"Ævæ :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 şX ñ<:

=µ 2I ş

@ \ĮwV RR¶ ¸P7 \Į

: Ø Œ M§¦¦+' jP7 ş

(35)

<

%"Æv1 %/2æ :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 %/

X ñ<:

%"ÆvÑ øMª +' ±ÓP7 {zøM%/ N<

ftV RRę {z±ÓøM%/

@ %"ÆvÑ øMª +' &< {zøM%/ N<

ftV RRę {z±ÓøM%/ S7 ēg Rę

{zŐøM%/

: ,,%/ ftV RRę ,,øM%/+'(

H @ P7 %/

%"Æv "%P7 %/+'( R= %/&Ã1X w

3Ĉ &< %/

R= %"w´ü è 6î§\Ng %"Æv M< %

"w´üX èPO %"`YV R= èP7 %"ò Þ´ü ¥Z?Aė PO <:

R¶ %"Æv M< %"w´ü7 :4 ĵ ę ¶2

¥Z?n <:

%"Æv M< %"w´ü ©h po#

%"Æv1 %/ ±Ó ,« N< ¶

%"Æv1 %/&Ã1 w N< ¶

< Ø Œ %"Æv %"*jX bPO 6î§\N2 L P : jP7 ¶

R TA %"w´ü è ftT\÷T\ftvy T\Aw S7 ftvyAw2P TAw <:7 R=

%"Æv M< %"w´ü %"Æv M< TA

%"w´üX èPO %"`YV R èP7 T A %"òÞ´ü ¥Z?Aė PO <:

%"Æv M< TA %"w´ü7 R=R¶ ĵ ę

¶H Nª w#vyux K .0 %"Ä= X ĜPO %"Æv %"*j L < ¶2 ¥Z?n <: R%"Æv1 %/ Ƣ±Ó 6 w#vyux <6w

%/,V ! <6w%/, S7 w#,`ĉV R<;

(36)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

=

%/ĉX +' Óè w#,2P w#, <

: ,,%/ ftV RRę ,,øM%/ } M§¦

¦+' jP7 øM%/X ±ÓP7 C¹ 2I Èb

( M§¦¦+' jP7 Ãľ 2IX %"Æv1 %/+' ±ÓPO

<:

%/V R ĉ´üƱņv R¶ %"Æv1 %/

2 ±Ó?7 ĉ MPO %/V R ĉ´üX Ʊ

PĜ :4 ĵ ę ¶X PO P 2Q ŪĘPw ƏP7

C N¬ (ï ƲX wTP7 L < yQ ª 5:

%"Æv1 %/ Ƣ±Ó Ãľ O

R; ! ńTÓ Óy` ŪĘ O

R%"Æv1 %/ øMĉv w 6î§\Ng øMĉ v %"Æv1 %/X ±ÓP7 C R; ńTÓ Óy`

X ŪĘP7 TÓ ÓyÃ1X %/AT`®+' Ƴv wª

5:

R%"Æv1 %/ øM ± RRęĥ :ƚ w %"Æv1 %/ ø vĪ)j#V øM ± N

< ¶g M§¦¦+' j<:

øMĉv7 ¸ øM%/ "% } ø2 "ƴ2@ Ø

Œ j< #V+' %"Æv1 %/X øM3g C7 øM

´ÆX R S7 wP"@ øM´Æ ƵƍX "°ª 5: R=%/&Ã1 w 6 w#vyux7 :4 ĵ ę

nư P@ ¸P7 v %"Æv 0- ÞPAė %/

øM1 %/X ¥Z<:X &P` bPO L < Ã1 wX

ƍdP7 C7 &Ã1X wª 5:

%"Æv

%"Æv µM+' 57 µM%

Rę S7 Rę şÑ øMª +' %/X &P

v P7 øM

wMIv vĪ L < ¶g M§¦¦+' j<:

(37)

< Jl %/ N¬ VH ,-.0%/ &]

}řj S7 w#vyux < ,-.0%/ ,« ċ

( ĝĞ Jl V(7 :¾ ¥Ċ2`7 Pw ,-.

0%/ ,«2 L < MIv·Ñ 2Q ,«ª 57 jkX po ª 5Aė V ĩ"Q Ê¬ ƶ 5: Ù 5: fĭ %"

`YV [12 %/V ( çèPO ¹V? \¾ 9'(

%/ &]( w KĪ %" &]2

V+' Ac+'¼ \¾ 9 28 Èbƚw 1» 57

%/VR ƲºK2 R: ¹Ĩª 5: : O`( Ĝ

ª ¶g j wX b< V ĩ" Ê¬2 >K?nĻ 54

A ¯P ,-.0%/27 &]X V'¼ ļPO 2Q

V ĩ"Q w7 &]+' vBÝAė P7w M(

L P: V+' w2 < MI2 <: ¸ĭ

Ø MI S< V+' &]X >KP 5n ª Ô+' :

Jl %/ N¬ VR(7 `£ \¾ 9'(%/ &]

2 }|+' byP 5+ %"'( w7 : M 9 Q w7 %/ &]X Ĉ ŹĈ` Ʒ·: ª 5: Jl

V(,-.0%/ &] \ ƚG KĪ+'( V'(

ĩ"Q w 57 &]g,-> Čnč%/2 ª 5:

R%"Æv1 %/&Ã1X w3g øM Ƣ R=R¶

Rę øM2 &Ã1X w3Ĉ %"Æv1 %/+' &<

C7=û Èb( M§¦¦+' jP7 `z -* ¸ %/

X %"Æv S7 %"Æv µM+' 57 µM%Ñ øMPO

<:

(38)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

:

Ò ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV R

j R;ę( ,-> Čnč%/2æ ç"Ş ¾û ¾Ƹ

\ Čnč Æ´^ woX bPO `£ '¸ ƹî R

ę %/ X 01< ,-.0> %/X ñ<: jP

57à 2á< &]g ,-.0%/ &] \ ƺ: ª

(7 ÖIª Ú+ 2 jA V &]+' ,-.0%/

&]2 V+' A?: Ù 7 ÚX Ô+' ěu:

( Jl %/ N¬ V(,-.0%/ &]X nƼ< >=h

fe+'( V &] ªw M( ŐC } PÑ ?n

ª Ô+' : Jl %/ N¬ V( %/ N< V

%

%/V

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

%/2æ µMƽƾ K2 \`z çè %".0X ª

57 ' ±²Ń Ï S7 Ø ıwQ ñ P 2Q uç%/H ,-%/+' ¹<:

%/2æ %/ 8 ±²ŃH Ø ıw'( %"TÓ'

21< TÓ X ñP Ø Èbh òï7 M§¦¦+' j

<:

,-%/2æ ±²Ń ƿA´u2@ Ø Œ ÓÃ

Ï S7 Q ,-+' 1P7 ĵ µM P@ ±²Ń *

( ĵĵ çè %".0X ª 57 ' %/X ñP

Ø òïh Èb7 M§¦¦+' j<:

(39)

>

µM¹> ,-%/2æ ,-%/ %/ [ ,z

Q µMt' ¹PO .02 < ' P? Ø ¹ ,z

MPO ¹¾~Q ª Ú7 %/+'( M§¦¦+' j P7 ±Ó` ` ÞPÑ ±Ó %/X ñ<:

6{%/2æ %/AT`®V ! %/AT`®2P %/

AT`®2 <:+'ĥ v®X w3Ĉ ±Ó?"@ &Ɵ?7

%/+'( %" 1A' Š27 2P %"Ï12

<:2 ęǀ S7 µM¸ >=Rǁ9ĥ 2P %/ AņjÃ

´üV RRę ! AņX R8< ATw2 Ĉŵ ǂ

S7 wgę S7 µM¸ %"Ï12 Rǁ9ĥ 2P

%/X ñ<: 2P 6{%/íĐ <:X ñ<: 2 C

%"Ï1 Õj#Vg 6î§¦+' j<:

6{%/2æ Rę 6{%/H 6 w#vyux <

6w%/,V ! <6w%/,2P <6w%/,

<: S7 w#,`ĉV R<; %/ĉX

+' Óè w#,2P w#, <: ±ÓP7 %/

{zøM%/ N< ftV RRę ! {z±Óø M%/ ,,%/ ftV ! ,,øM%/+'( R=ę

,,/w R ĉ´ü ƱX 3Ĉ ±ÓPO øM P7 %/ } %"Ï12>=Rǁ9ĥ 2P %/X ñ<:

< {%/2æ 6{%/X R8< %/X ñ<:

< AT> .0%/2æ µM 9 6{%/íĐ ¸P7

%/+'( M§¦¦+' jP7 %/X ñ<: G2P .ħH

,

,-%/NBV

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

,-%/2æ :4 ĵ %/ TÓX ñ<: 2 C

Ñ ¹;?7 BTÓg R8<:

%/V RRę ! ,-%/

@ ±²V R ! ±²ǃQ 3Ĉ %/ 8 TÓH % /X - ±²Ń' ±²P7 ±²Ń

(40)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

;

: %/V RRę ! MTÓ ēg R<ę

! BTÓ

ƢNBMI ,-%/2æ =µM 2I ,-%/ } ¸ ,-

%/X Ï+' NBP7 vQ Ě vy º`Q Ƣ+'

KPO P7 j< Ƣ H?7 ,-%/X ñP

Ø Èb7 M§¦¦+' j<:

,-%/uwæ %/V RRę ! %/uwQ ñ<:

< ßÞ%/uwæ ¹;X +' < ,-%/H øM%/2 Zð

57 ,-%/uwQ ñ<: G2P .ħH

,

,,%/ ftV

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

,,%/2æ R<R¶ ĵ ę íj v S7 R<R¶

! ,,%/ĉv 6 S7 w#vyux âj2@ %/

AT`®V ! %/AT`®2P %/AT`®2 <:X

w3Ĉ 2 V S7 :! V ±Ó Ő S7 øPO

,«P7 :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 %/X ñ<:

øM S7 øM< s ¹;ÏiX ª +' ,«P7 %/

V RRę ! %/+'( M§¦¦+' jP7 %/

2P ,,øM%/2 <:

@ ¹;X +' ,«P7 %/+'( %/V RRę

! 6{%/íĐ 2P %/2P ,,¹;%/2 <:

,,±ÓøM%/2æ R< ! ,,%/ĉv

±ÓPO ,«P7 ,,øM%/X ñ<:

,,ŐøM%/2æ R< ! ,,%/ĉv

±ÓPw ĈéP ŐŐ +' ƞPO ,«P7 ,,øM%/

X ñ<:

,,%/wæ ,,%/ ,«X bPO ,,%/2 Ïx%/

}¹ = 2I2 ? RR¶ wj TP7 wQ

(41)

<

ñ<: 2 C Rę ĵ t %/Ãľg Ïu íj Èb(

M§¦¦+' j<:

G2P .ħH

±

uç%/Iuç%/ >=Q ĲǄ jnƯ2ŕ ,-.0j w

Ĉ-ƙĥ ŞwTÓŞw%/g R8<:X ¥Z<:J

uç%/

@ :}%/@ :4 ±X ĐĚ ĲǄ %/X ñ<:

Ɔ. S7 \ Oá ş2 \`z "%ª 57

' ?n 57 Ô

çè %" >=Q Ĳpw Ĉé< Ôĵ Ät' ǅÄg Óy ª 5+@ TÓg ÓyPw Ĉé< ÔX ñ<: 2P

ē:

2 Rǁ9ĥ 2P2 ^ ^ 2P Ô

: :%/@ :4 ±X ĐĚ ĲǄ %/+'( ,-%/

¸Pw ĈéP7 ÔX ñ<:

%/+' Š7 ^wP^g R8<: & ^ 2P Ô

: ^ Ï S7 Q L'ì ' PO %\+'

1P @ǆw ¹X %/ 8 1A' Š7 C7 ¸

^X %/ ^( R8<:

& - %/+' Š27 ŗƪÓ %\ g R8

<: 2P ē: Þ´ Rǁ9ĥ 2P Ô

;µM 2P "%ª 5X Ô

,NǇǈ

,-%/I,-%/ >=Q ĲǄ jnƯ2ŕ ,-.0j w

Ĉ-ƙĥ ŞwTÓŞw%/g R8<: %/V T l¦ RR¶ ! ǉ> %/X ¥Z<:J : 2@

@( ^Q Õjª ^ ÏQ L'ì ' PO %\

+' 1P7 C7 L'ì ¹X ^( R8P :(

^Q Õjª ^ Ï S7 Q L'ì ' PO %

(42)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

<

\+' 1P @ǆw ¹X %/ 8 1A' Š7 C7

¸ ^X %/ ^( R8P ĥ ƚw íj(

^Q Õjª wP^X %/ ^( R8<:

Ĉłå@ %/+' Š7 ^ =& ^ 2I %/

@ è%/@ %/+' Š7 & - ŗƪ& 2I -X wP

%\+' ºP7 C7 ĵĵ -+' Y: Þ´ Rǁ 9ĥQ ÅHP ^ <& ^ 2P %/

: :µM%/@ %/+' Š7 & - ŗƪ Þ´ Rǁ9ĥ

2P2 ^ <& ^ 2P %/& 2I -X wP%\

+' ºP7 C7 ĵĵ -+' Y:

`Ɠ@ Ɔî S7 ,\ Ɔ. S7 òĉ X bPO Š 7 Ô+'(& - ,-TÓ 21 µM Ïx =ƈ ƙå 2I Ô îŝ`YV R:R¶ ! Ɔ.w%/X

¥Z<: {

{zøM%/ N< ftV

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

{zøM%/2æ øM +' R,P7 %/IwQ øP O ±Ó %/ Ĥ×þǊ M§¦¦+' jP7 %/2P

%/2 <:X ¥Z<: 2P ē:J+'( øMĉv R=

ė< %/X ñP {z±ÓøM%/H {zŐøM

%/+' ¹<:

{z±ÓøM%/2æ :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 {z øM%/X ñ<:

øMĉv øMQ +' ±ÓPO øMP7 %/

@ %/V R; ė< %/±Óĉv ēg V R

ĉ´üƱX 3Ĉ ±Ó< %/ } 1 ƚw

¹;?w ĈéPO øMP7 %/

{zŐøM%/2æ øMĉv ŐŐ +' ¾~ņX ƞ PO øMP7 {zøM%/X ñ<:

(43)

<

< `ĉ>øM%/2æ `ĉ>øMĉv >û 2I øMª

+' ƞPO øMP7 {zøM%/X ñ<:

= ,,øM%/2æ >øMĉv >û 2I øMª

+' ƞPO øMP7 {zøM%/X ñ<:

u`øM%/2æ >øMĉv <û 2I øMª +

' ƞPO øMP7 {zøM%/X ñ<:

G2P .ħH Č

ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV R j

BĐĎď2æ ±²Ń Şs ǋR S7 `I X bPO

² &² S7 M)X P7 lbQ ñ<:

Şs ¯Ɵ Čnč%/2æ \`z çè %".0X ª 57

' Čnč%/+'( :4 ĵ %/X ñ<:

Ǎǌ2å 1 Čnč%/

@ ±²Ń2 ¢¡?"@ ǎÄ?n ǐǏ Ø Œ *Ï

CĜ 57 Čnč%/

: ±²Ń ` ºZ ÄT, S7 Şs' <

ºZ +' Ǒ" ¯×< Čnč%/

T\ Ƭ ÷T vy d\2P T\ Ƭ d

\2 <:2 "% S7 1 OQ < œĥ û 2I

ĈƢA "%Pw ĈéP"@ 1Pw ĈéP7 Čnč%/

: jÃ`TÓ2æ A' IA PA Ĥ ƹ jTÓX

ñ<:

> ,-21TÓ2æ %{2 ,-+' 1P7 ÊXN ,-ğĉ

\ Ø Œ M§¦¦+' jP7 TÓX ñ<:

; ,-> Čnč%/2æ ç"Ş ¾û ¾Ƹ\ Čnč Æ

´^ woX bPO `£ '¸ ƹî Rę %/

X 01< ,-.0> %/X ñ<:

(44)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

<

Jl %/V (7 \ `Y %/ &](ĥ p

>= %/&]ƚw Ãî ÷ÈbPÑ%/ M< &]X íj P 57à %/H %/ ØB ,-%/ &]X % / ¥Ċ 1+' íjP 5+ 6{%/2@ AT

> .0%/ &]H ē2 p jk L K V

&]+' \PÑ %/&]·A íjP 5: ( ,-.

0%/27 &]X V+' AP7 C7 %/V I &

]+' AP7 ÔX+' ª 5: : s¨ª [1 2w % ª Wg %/V I &]g %/ ¾~>= T Ó` N< `+' jQ P"@ tA jk H

%/V R Rę%/ Ręuç%/ Rę,-%/ R<ę%/ R=ę

6{%/ R:ę{%/ R>ęøM%/ R;ęwøM ¹;%/ R;ęµM

¹> ,-%/ RęAT> .0%/ Rę¿w°Æ> ǒi %/ Rę

±āǒ> %/ Rę\ %/X íjP 5:

\

\Į ¦v %"Æv w N< V

R j 2 V( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

%"Æv1 %/2æ :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 %/X

ñ<:

%"ÆvÑ øMª +' ±ÓP7 {zøM%/ N<

ftV RRę {z±ÓøM%/

@ %"ÆvÑ øMª +' &< {zøM%/ N<

ftV RRę {z±ÓøM%/ S7 ēg Rę

{zŐøM%/

: ,,%/ ftV RRę ,,øM%/+'(

H @ P7 %/

%"Æv "%P7 %/+'( R= %/&Ã1X w

3Ĉ &< %/

(45)

<<

L ( FùÑ >K %/&]2 íj:7 W2:^: Ò

,-.0%/g %" v H 2 `2 ?n

ª Ô2 Jl %/V I %/&]H } X w(

>K &]2` 2 M< tA L ª Ô+' ě

u:^> ,-%/NBV H ,,%/ ftV ØB {zøM

%/ N< ftV g j %/,«jk NPO } < V

`X R,P7 V2 Ù 5: ,-.0%/ &]X A

ǓX 2Q j %/,«jk N< u+' 01P7

C7 2á< V ,-.0%/ &]X APO 01P7

#*A P: Ù 5: : 2á< C7 v~'G >=

h po%x' >K?7 feX w7 ,-.0%/ C j

%/,«jk ÞP7 >=' ,-.0%/2 01: P 7 R<W2 £âPÑ » Ô2: ČnčÊX %"i &) B ĐĎď đoX b< ftV H \Į ¦v %"Æv w

N< V g ft< +' Rj Tl?7 V( %" S7

%/H N¬ ¶X íj< V'( 2á< X ŊKP7à L < u+' ,-.0%/X 01P7 ÔA ª Ô2: 2

C7 ¸ V ÞPAė ,-.0%/X jPO V

I jíj+' Aª 5X Ô2: fĭ ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV (7 29 2á< #$+

' VI ,-.0%/2 01 VD ª 5:^;

: Ģ ĵ%( `¨P 5ŀ2 %/V (7 uç%/ ,-%/ Ŏ

%/` ! %/X jZH -T µM¹> ,-%/ AT> .0%

/ ¿w°Æ> ǒi %/ jk F'G ~> %/ MPO p

j#$+' íjP 5:

> ,-.0%/ &] A N¬(7 R\( ,-.0%/ N< VR

&)#*X ª PAė <:

; ČnčÊX %"i &) BĐĎď đoX b< ftV R R;ę(

7,-> Čnč%/X íjP 5:

(46)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

<=

,-.0%/ \

ĠnPCþ \

ĠnPCþ7 >=I ,-x%/H " -< &] ¾Q Ĳ

W2 2W2 ª 5 2á< ĠnPCþ MPO 6[ ) l(7 :4H ē2 ÓP 5:

ĠnPCþ7 : ş·2 ƂÄ ēg ó¾< çè ,z X R8< ǅÄ2@ %# "ÄH ēg ,zX ,~ª 57 %/

2: CB@ ĠnPCþ7 ¯H û Ïĥ `ĉ

{z( dû^X MI+' «?` TğPă: CB@

(7 «Z ¾>%/ M< A Pă

j7 %"*jKH ŉKX P( ¾>%/ ,« 0 KQ bPO AT>.0%/H %/ &]X APă:

Q b< ¾>%/g j( jk+' \ĜP 5w ǔ g w ǉ>= Ʃŕ?n5n Á.P7 *Ï ŉK 2 RW+' w? 5: 2á< ċ( ĠnPCþ7 >= A

T ,-+' 1P7 ,z2 .ą@¸ 1 2 Ǖnw

Zð "%P` %" ŉKH *ÏK2 ĈĻ ¾>%

/ M*2 » 5:

jk ,-.0%/ K,«H7 T`+' Ģ(7 fe2

5: Ù 5: S< j S7 w#vyux < jkpo2

Ĉé {z`ĉ2@ PO po?:7 fe2 57

ów)Ĥ-ǖ ,«v NW( Y Tén´^X b< ĠnPCþ A 0K

#* %/ Rņ Rę == ;A;<

(47)

<

Ô+' : {z`ĉ2@ PO po?7 C

7 L+' ,-.0%/ :! :7 %v· h

\ Ǘ Þ?Aė K ,«:7 feX ĲÑ

:

I` )l ŏ M< w+'( po WX

Áƭª 5+ ww ( Şû^X MI+' <

C:7 \ ƆĉH N¬PO ǘg^X MI+' <

Q MI+' < C ġǙ: Ù 5: 2á< ĠnPCþ

\g %/ h 01#$ M< :ĵ KX R,Pă + uĴ< Q MI+' < %/,«#$X ǚn(( :

:;< H w' jk poX ƢTU 57 -`'(

`Pă: Ù 5:

%/ \

%/g ĠnPCþ %/01#$X w ċ( 0 1< >= ,-.0%/2 ěu: (õftT %/ 0 K w N< D 2P D <: R jíj(

7 Rę( %/ MPO %/2æ R ÆvQ

MI+' %"N¬ R %x ,«?7 øM%/ X

ñ<: íjP 5:D R Rę ØB D(7

R Ævh %" N¬ R %x MPO :4H ē 2 íjPă:

ów) Ĥ-ǖ Ģ Ǜ ;A;<

(

(õftT %/ 0K w N< D

R j 2 D( 1P7 1n Žg :4H ē:

(48)

R ° ,-.0%/ \H &]

<:

ĠnPCþ %" v· H %"2 ā >= ,- .0%/2 <: %/g ,-.0%/ ww

KĪ2 ā >= ćª 5: Ò ĠnPC7 ¸ %/

v· vÁ Þy PO >K» 57 wšĭ {z vľ KĪ2 āP: <: %/g `Y+' w w %x %"Æ´^X MI+' poP7 %"wjk u

%/2æ R ÆvQ MI+' %"N¬ R

%x ,«?7 øM%/ X ñ<:

R Ævæ :4 ĵ nư P@ ¸P7 vQ ñ

<:

`ĉ ŝKV RRę ēg V Tl¦ R

! Æ´^

@ \Į ¦v %"Æv w N< V RRę

%"Æv

: ,,%/ ftV RRę ,,%/ } 6 (õft T (õ%/AT, S7 <6w%/, ¾~< øM%

/ "%v

Ƣ%/ µMK+'( :! D S7 íŎ+' jP7 ŗ

,,2 ¾~P7 øM%/ %ª vĪ2 57 v Ê *j %".0X bP` b( °< wX 3X L

5: j?n (õftT\2P T\2 <:2

tA' jP7 ` ¸P7 dû ŗ Ø Œ T\2 ftĭ jP7 v

%"N¬ R %xæ %/V {zøM%/ N<

ftV AT %"i jÃV íj %"N¬

ĉX TlP7 {V R ! ÃBV ,ƥV

Óè G N< V R< ǃ ,ƥV ³-

Þ `YV R>= Óè ³-Þ `ĉ ŝKV R> `ĉ }¾`ĉ`YV R !

}¾`ĉ±Óĉ -Õĉ øMĉ <Z X ñ<:

공동생활주택(Co-housing)관련 법제개선방안 연구

Җسࢥഞલగ &RKRXVLQJ Қ۳ߩંёࢷߒঊৌҴ

 



   

   

   ! " #$%&"$ '

)(*!

    

  

   

% % [ [1 1



` `M ÀH

 

       

  

 

Æ 

"$ 

R  \ ( Ç

R  \ ,-.0%/   6[8 D

R < \ º Ç

Í  Î

R  \ ( Ç

 

 

R  \ ,-.0%/   6[8 D

 

 %"h ,-.0%/ &]

 ,-.0%/ \

Җسࢥഞલగ&RKRXVLQJ Қ۳ߩંёࢷߒঊৌҴ

! " #$%&"$ '

)(*!

Æ

"$

R \ ( Ç

R \ ,-.0%/ 6[8 D

Í Î

R \ ( Ç

R \ ,-.0%/ 6[8 D

%"h ,-.0%/ &]

,-.0%/ \