*
1)
.
. 1 ‘ ’
1.
2.
3.
. 1.
2. ‘ '
3.
. 1 ‘
’
1. 1 ‘ ’
2. 1 ‘ ’
3. 1 ‘ ’
V.
* /
: 2013. 4. 27 / : 2013. 5. 30 / : 2013. 6. 4
I.
1) 1
.
, ‘ ’ ‘ ’
‘ ’
.
,
( ‘ ’) . ,
. , ‘ ’2)
. 3)
,
. ,
,
.
‘ ( )’
. ,
‘
1) 11110 , 2011. 12. 2. , 2012. 3. 15. .
2) 1 ‘ ’ ,
‘ ’ .
3) 1 ‘ ’ ,
‘ ’ .
’ ,
.
1
‘ ’
. ‘ ’
. , ,
. ,
,
1 ‘ ’ ‘ ’
.
,
1 ‘ ’
, ,
.
II. 1 ‘ ’
22 2 . , · ·
. 1
, ‘ ’
.4)
1 ( ) 8 (
) ,
, .5)
,
‘ ’
, ‘ ’6)
1
.
( )
4) , , , 2007, 2~3 ; , ( 8
) , , 2012, 29 .
5) . The Constitution of the United States of America,
Article I [The Legislative Branch] Section 8. [Scope of Legislative Power] The Congress shall have power... To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries;...
6) ‘ ( )’
. , ( 2 - ) , , 2012, 20 . ,
‘ ’ .
, ‘ ’
,
.
, , , 2007, 87~101
.
,
. ,
= + =
.
,
“ ”
, “ ”
.7)
1
, ‘ ’
, ...
,
.8) 1
,
, .9)
,
.10) ,
7) , , 4 .
8) , ( 2 - ) , , 2012, 4~5 .
9) , , 18~20 .
10) , , 29~30 .
, 1
‘ ’
.
. ,
, ,11) ‘
' .
...
,12)
.13)
2 . ,
( ) ,
( )
. , ,
, ( )
, .14)
11) , , 2 .
12) , 14 .
13) , 13 .
14) Goldstein
. Essentially utilitarian, these principles aim to promote culture and education by encouraging the production of the widest possible array of literary, musical and artistic works. Paul Goldstein, Copyright (Second Edition), Little, Brown and Company, 1996, I
, p.1:2.
, 1
. ,
.
, 1 ‘ ’ ‘
’ ‘ ’ , ‘ ’
.15) ,
( , ) .
1
. ,
.
.
, .16) ,
,
. ,
15) , (http://stdweb2.korean.go.kr/search/View.jsp) .
16)
( , , 15 ),
.
.17)
, -
( , )
,
.
, ‘
’ ,
. ,
. ,
,
.
‘ ’ .
.
( ) ,
17)
.
, 9 , 11 , 69 . , ‘ ’
4 5 , ( )
... · · ·
... , 9 ·
.
11 1 2 ·
· · ·
, 69
...
. ‘ ’ , 22
1
.
,
. "
” ,
( 9 ).
,
, · , , ·
· ,
.18)
.19)
18) 2004. 5. 27. 2003 1 .
2000. 4. 27. 98 16, 98 429( ) ; 2003. 12. 18.
2002 2 ; 2011. 2. 24. 2009 13·52·110( ) .
19) , ( 20 ) , , 2010, 117~119 ; ,
,
‘ ’
. ‘ ’
,20)
, .
.21)
( ) ‘ ( )’
, ,
. ,
, , , , .
( ) . (
) .22) ,
( )
.
(2010 ) , , 2011, 143~146 ; , ( 2 ) , , 2011,
205~207 ; , ( 8 ) , , 2008, 269~273 ; , ,
, 2004, 217~220
. ,
, ,
. ,
( 7 ) , , 2012, 242~243 .
20) , ‘ ’
, ‘ ’ .
21) , , , 2011, 182 .
22) , (http://stdweb2.korean.go.kr/search/View.jsp) .
, .23)
,24) .
.
.25)
.
,
, , ,
, ,
.26)
, , ,
.27)
23) , , , , 2008, 14 .
24) , ( 21), 182 .
25) , , 14 .
26) , , 145~146 .
27) , , 206~207 .
, , .28)
,
.29)
( ) ... · · ·
... , 11 1 2
· · ·
·
, ‘ ’ 4 2
. ,
,
. ,
,
. ,
.
, .
.
28) , , 219~220 .
29) , “ ”
. , ( 21),
183~186 .
,
.
.
,
. ,
.30)
, .
,31)
32)
.
... · ·
...( )
, , , ,
,
30) 2004. 5. 27. 2003 1 .
31)
· (
2 1 ),
( 1997. 11. 25. 97 2227 , 1999. 11. 26. 98 46259
).
32) 10 2
.
‘ ’ .33)
.
34) , 27
1
.35) , ·
36) 15 1. (a) “ ”
.37)
. ,38)
33) 2000. 4. 27. 98 16, 98 429( ) .
34) ( , Universal Declaration of Human Rights) 1948 12 10
58 50
. 217A(III) . 360
, .
. (http://ko.wikipedia.org)
“ ” .
35) . Article 27 Everyone has the right freely to participate in the cultural life of the community, to enjoy the arts and to share in scientific advancement and its benefits.
36) · (International Covenant on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights, ICESCR) 1966 12 16
. A . 2011 7 160
. , , ,
. (http://ko.wikipedia.org) “ ·
” .
37) . Article 15 The States Parties to the present Covenant recognize the right of everyone: (a) To take part in cultural life;
38) , ( 18 ) , , 2007, 425 .
.
‘ ’
.39) , · ·
·
19 5 19 2 3
.40)
.
, ,41)
“ ” “ ”
.42) ,
.
6 1 2 ‘ ’
, , ...
39) ‘ ’ ,
( 11690 , 2013. 3. 23. , 2013. 3. 23.
) “
” ,
. 25 1 10 .
40) 2003. 12. 18. 2002 2 .
41) 10 .
42) , ( 22), 309 .
...
, .43)
‘ ’44)
( ) ,
( ) ,
.45)
( ,
) .
. 1
‘ ’
22 2 ( · ·
) ,
,
. ,
43) 2004. 5. 27. 2003 1 .
44) , (http://stdweb2.korean.go.kr/search/View.jsp) ‘
( )’ .
.
45) ,
29 ,
,
. , 29
, , 2012 ( 68 ) .
104 22 2
“ .”
,
,
.46)
1 .
‘ ’
.
47)
· · · , ,
· , · · · · ·
, ·
, ( ),
, · · · · ,
.48)
‘ ’ .
49) 50) ‘ ’
46) 2011. 2. 24. 2009 13·52·110( ) . 2002. 4. 25. 2001
200 .
47) 2 1 .
48) 4 1 .
49) “ ” 18 .
, , ,
, , ,
, , (
), , , , , ( ), , , ,
( ) .51)
,
.
· ·
·
,52) 23 35 2 , 101 3
101 5
· · ·
53) “ · · · ”
, .
, ‘ ’ ‘ ,
, ’54)
.
,55)
, , , ,
, · ,
, , ,
, , . 18
· ·
2 .
50)
. 11313 , 2012. 2. 17. , 2012. 8. 18. .
51) 2 1 1 .
52) 28 .
53) 35 3.
54) , , 205 .
,56) .
, 1 2009 57)
, ‘ ’
, ‘ ’
. , ‘ ’
‘ ’ ,
‘ ’
. , ‘ ’
, 58)
2 .
" ”
· · · · ·
,
· , · , · ·
, , ,
· · · (
)· · · · , ,
55) , , 3 .
56) , , 6 .
57) 9625 , 2009. 4. 22. , 2009. 7. 23. .
,
· .
58)
. 11167 , 2012. 1. 17.
, 2012. 4. 18. .
· · · · ·
· · ,
,
, , ,
· · ( ,
2 2 · ·
),
.59) ‘ ’
, " "
· · · · ( )
.60)
‘ ’ ‘
’ .
.
.
2009 ‘ ’
. ‘ ’
- .
‘
’ ,61)
.62)
59) 2 1 ~ .
60) 2 1 2 .
61) , , 5 .
62) , , 31 .
, ( ) .
, ( )
,63)
, ,
.64)
65)
. (
, )
.
, ,
.66)
63) ,
.
.
· ·
. 2004. 5. 27. 2003 1, 2004 4( ) .
64)
. ,
.
. 2004. 5. 27. 2003 1, 2004 4
( ) .
65) “ ”
. 2000. 4. 27. 98 16, 98 429( )
2004. 5. 27. 2003 1, 2004 4( ) .
66) 3 ( ,
, ) ‘ ’ ,
.
/ / (http://www.mcst.go.kr/web/introCourt/
, ‘
’ . ,
,67) ‘
’ .
.
‘ ’
, ‘ ’
.68) ,
.
21
. 2 ,
,
. , 2 ( ‘
’; prosumer)69)
introOrgan/mainConts.jsp) .
67) 1 .
68) ,
, 40 , 459~486 .
69) (prosumer) (producer) (consumer)
,
< 3 > .
, .
. “ (UCC; User Created Contents)"
.70) ,
. ‘ ’
, ,
. ‘ ’
23 22
, ,
.71)
-
“
” .72) ,
( ), ,
73) ( ),
70) · ·
· · · · ·
. 2 1 .
(UCC)
.
71) , , 3 22 23
.
72) , 2
, .
73) ,
.
( )
. ,
.
“
” . ,
,
. .74)
.75) , ,
( “ ”),76)
, .
. , ,
, 2012-3 , , 2012.
74)
( , co-evolution)
. , , , 2005, 341~345 .
75)
. 23 2 .
76) , ( 22), 309 .
.77)
,78) ,
79)
,
. 80)
. ,
,
.81)
“ ” ( “ ”
UCC ) 1
. , 1
12 UCC
28 ( )
,
77) .
. 2004. 5. 27. 2003
1, 2004 4( ) .
78) 2011 50 75
.
79) ,
(
) .
80) 23 ~ 38 .
81) 2011 fair use ( 35 3)
.
, ·
,
, UCC
,
· ,
,
,
,82)
.
V.
,
, ,
‘ ’ “
”
“ ” .
( , ) -
82) 2010. 2. 18. 2009 18800 .
. , ,
.
2013. 2. 25. 18 ‘ ’
19 ‘ (57 )’ ‘ (20 )’ 3
.83)
3 .
21 .
, ,
. .
.
‘
’
.84) .
83) , 2013. 2. 26. 3 .
84) ‘ ’
. , 2006 ,
, 2006, 93~94 .
, , , 2004
, (2010 ) , , 2011
, , , 2007
, ,
, 2007
, ( 20 ) , , 2010
, , , 2008
, , , 2012
, 2006 , , 2006
, 2011 ,
, 2012
, , , 2006
______, , , 2007
, ( 2 ) , , 2009
, ( 8 ) , , 2008
, ( 8 ) , , 2012
, ( 2 ) , , 2011
, ( 2 - ) , , 2012
, - - , , 2010
, 29 , , 2012 ( 68 )
, ( 2 - ) , , 2012
, , , 2005
, , , 1998
, , , 2007
, , , 2011
______, ( 7 ) , , 2012
, , , 2010
, ( 4 ) , , 2004
, ( 18 ) , , 2007
, 2011 ( ) , , 2011
Charles R. McManis, Intellectual Property and Unfair Competition (6th Edition), West, 2009
Margreth Barrett, Intellectual Property, Aspen Publishers, 2004
Melville B. Nimmer & David Nimmer, Nimmer on Copyright, Matthew Bender
& Company, 2006
Paul Goldstein, Copyright (Second Edition), Little, Brown and Company, 1996 Paul Goldstein, Copyright, Patent, Trademark and Related State Doctrines
(Revised Fourth Edition), Foundation Press, 1999
Rebert A. Gorman & Jane C. Ginsburg, Copyright (Sixth Edition), Foundation Press, 2002.
Roger E. Schechter, Unfair Trade Practices & Intellectual Property (2nd Edition), West Group, 1993
Roger E. Schechter & John R. Thomas, Intellectual Property The Law of Copyrights, Patents, and Trademarks, West Group, Thomson/West, 2003
< >
1 ‘ ’ ‘ ’
‘ ’
, ‘ ’
‘ ’
. ‘
’ .
‘ ’
. ,
,
.
, ,
, ‘ ’ “
”
“ ” .
( , ) -
.
:
A Study on the Meaning of ‘the Improvement and Development of Culture' under Article 1 of the Korea Copyright Act
Lee, Byoung-Kyu*85)
Article 1 of the Korea Copyright Act stipulates that the purpose of this Act is to protect the rights of authors and the rights neighboring on them and to promote fair use of works in order to contribute to the improvement and development of culture. Hence, the improvement and development of culture is the final goal of the Copyright Act and should be the essential standard of the interpretation and application of the law. However, most of Korean copyright scholars do not explain the meaning of it and they even assume that protection of the copyright and promotion of fair use themselves are deemed as it.
The meaning of the improvement and development of culture should be derived from the Constitution and there is a principle of the nation of culture as one of the basic constitutional principles. Pursuant to the principle of the nation of culture, the improvement and development of culture means maximization of the right of enjoyment from culture by the building of the ecology for the sustainable production and consumption of the works. This should be not only the legislative purpose of the Copyright Act but also the goal of culture policy.
* Associate Professor of Law, Myongji University College of Law/Attorney at Law
