1905~1907년 驛屯土 내 一進會 관련 분쟁의 성격 - S-Space

. 1905 1907

, .

, ,

.

.

.

, .

209 7

. 1905

‘

*

185

’ 1906

‘ ’

.

.

, ‘ ’

. ,

,

.

‘ ’ .

‘ ’, ‘ ’

. 1906 ‘

’ ‘ ’

. ,

, ,

.

, , , , ,

1.

, .¹⁾

,

1) ,

, . 1908

, , ‘ ’ (

, 1979뺷 뺸 , 108-109 ).

‘ ’

‘ ’ .

.

. 1898

.

. 1899

. 1900 1903

1903

5,899,865 , 5,173,163 87.6%

.²⁾

, .

,³⁾ ,⁴⁾

5) .

, ,

.

. ,

‘ ’⁶⁾

.

2) , 1996 뺷 뺸 18, 230-232 .

3) , 1996 1894~1910 ;

, 1997 :

.

4) , 1992 뺷 뺸 18; , 1997

;

, 2004 뺷 뺸 20.

5) , 1979 뺷 뺸 ; , 1989

:

; , 1995 뺷

뺸 ; , 1997 뺷 뺸 ; ,

2002뺷 뺸 ; , 2003뺷

뺸 .

6) , 2000 뺷 : 뺸 , 187, 288 .

? ?

, .

. 1905~1907

뺷 뺸 뺷 뺸, 뺷 뺸

뺷

뺸

, ,

. 1905 3

.

뺷 뺸 뺷 뺸, 뺷 뺸

.

뺷 뺸

,

뺷 뺸

.

뺷 뺸

,

뺷 뺸

,

뺷 뺸

.

,

뺷 뺸

,

.

뺷 뺸

,

뺷 뺸

. .

뺷 뺸

7) . 뺷

뺸( 21891),뺷 뺸( 21049) ,

뺷 뺸( 17874) .

뺷 뺸 뺷 뺸,뺷 뺸

.

뺷 뺸

.

뺷 뺸

. 1 ,

뺷 뺸

.

뺷

뺸

뺷 뺸

.

뺷 뺸

뺷 뺸

뺷 뺸 뺷

뺸 뺷 뺸

, .

뺷 뺸 뺷 뺸

뺷 뺸

.

2.

206

. 206 3 209

, , 1 . 1

. 1

.

. .

1 ,

.

( ),

( ), 1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907

5 3 1 9 1 1 2 1 4 5 4 4

2 2

1 1

, ,

1 1 3 5 3 11 6 3 9

, 1 2 3 2 25 6 33 1 1

1 1 1 1 2

( , , )

1 1 1 1 1 1

5 6 3 14 1 3 1 5 7 36 10 53 10 4 1 15

( ), ( ),

1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907 1905 1906 1907

4 1 1 6 1 1 2 9 9 3 21 2 2 1 5 54

1 2 1 4 3 7 10 16

1 3 4 4 4 1 2 3 12

19153 12 15

19152 9 21

19149 13 9

19155 8 28

19147 14 2

19163 17 4,10

19157 8 25

19160 11 38

19161 8 45

19154 12 16

19151 8 21

19150 17 9,10

19156 8 28

19148 25 3

19158 10 26

19159 10 36,37

19162 8 45

, ,

4 4 8 3 7 10 4 2 2 8 3 3 50

, 1 16 2 19 4 1 5 2 2 63

1 1 1 3 1 5 9

( ,

, )

1 1 1 5

10 26 3 39 6 18 2 26 18 23 8 49 2 2 4 8 209

뺷 뺸 뺷 뺸G

209 , 7 .

, ,

.

‘ ’ ,

.

. ‘

’ . ‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’

‘ ’ .

‘ ’ ,

.

, .

1905 59 , 1906 118 , 1907 32 1905 , 1906 .

1905 1906 ,

. 1905 .

‘ ’

.

. 1906 1 , ( )

( )

. ,

.⁸⁾ 1907

8) 뺷 뺸 24 246-247 .

.

, , , ,

, , , 53 1906

, .

, ,

.⁹⁾

,

. , ,

.

. , , 1905

,

. ,

.

?

, ,¹⁰⁾

11)

9) , , 186 .

.

. 1909 ,

, , , , ,

( , 1911 뺷 뺸 7 ).

128,868 7.1%, 307,800 13.9%

( , , 207-216 ).

.

10) , , 187 .

11) , 1988 뺷 :

.¹²⁾

. 1906 3 ,

50 300

, ,

.¹³⁾

, .

.

. .

‘ ,

,

’ .¹⁴⁾

,

, .

‘ ’

.

. , .

뺸 , 437 .

12)

,

( , 1999 :

뺷 뺸G172 , 49-52 ),

‘ ’ (

, 1990 ‘ ’(1904~1906)

, 52 ).

13) 뺷 뺸( 19148) 19 .

14) 뺷 뺸( 19147) 11 ; 뺷 뺸( 19148) 20 .

.

,

, .

, ,

, , .

3. 1905 ‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’

. 1905

‘ ’ .

,

, .

. ,

. .

, , , -

. ,

. , , , , ,

, , , , , , ,

, , 8

. .

.

, .¹⁵⁾

,¹⁶⁾

, .

.

1905 4 1906 1 6

.

, ,

, ,¹⁷⁾ ,^{18) 19)}

. 1906 2 3

. 1905

, ‘ ’

.²⁰⁾ ,

, ,

‘ ’ .

.

‘ ’

.

15) (1996), (뺷 뺸 18), 238 .

16) , 1983 뺷 뺸 9,

, 306 .

17) 뺷 뺸( 19153) 7 .

18) 뺷 뺸( 19154) 8 .

19) 뺷 뺸( 19153) 9 .

20) 뺷 뺸( 19153) 8 .

. ,

. ,

, .²¹⁾

. 1905 2 ,

. 1904

. ‘

’ .²²⁾

.

.²³⁾

. 1905 8 , ‘

’ .²⁴⁾

.

. ,

.

25)

. 1905 9 , ,

21) 뺷 뺸( 19155) 6 .

22) 뺷 뺸( 19147) 10 .

23) 뺷 뺸( 19143) 60, 61, 62 .

24) 뺷 뺸( 19160) 6 ; 뺷 뺸( 19159) 6 .

25) 뺷 뺸( 19159) 6 .

,

.²⁶⁾

, , ,

. ‘ , ,

’ . ‘ ’ ‘ ’

, ‘ ’

. ‘ ’, ‘ ’, ‘ ’ ,

. ‘ ’

, ‘ ’ . 1905

5 ,

‘

’ .²⁷⁾

‘ ’

.

.

. , ,

. ,

,

.²⁸⁾

, 1904

1905 .

26) 뺷 뺸( 19160) 6 .

27) 뺷 뺸( 19159) 6 .

28) 뺷 뺸( 19157) 6 .

12 5 2

‘

’ .

( 19148) 19

10

.

( 19148) 19

( )

, 20

?

( 19159) 8

‘ ’

? .

3

. ‘ ’ ‘ ’

. 1904 8

‘ ’ , ‘ ’ .

.

, .

‘ ’ ‘ ’ , ‘ ’

?

‘ ’

. ,

‘ ’ . 19

뺷 뺸

,

‘ ’ . 1898

.

,

,

. .

‘ ’, ‘ ’

,

. ,

,

, .

‘ ’ ,

. ‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’, ‘ ’

.

, ‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’ .

, ‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘

’ . ‘ ’

‘ ’ ‘ ’ .

‘ ’, ‘ ’

.

‘ ’, ‘ ’

. .

‘ ’ .

,

’ . ‘ ’, ‘ ’, ‘ ’ ‘ ’ .

.²⁹⁾ ‘ ’, ‘ ’

‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’ ‘ ’ .³⁰⁾

4. 1906 ‘ ’

‘ ’

,

‘ ’ . ‘

’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’ .

‘ ’ .

.³¹⁾

. 1906 5

‘ ’ .

.

.

,

.³²⁾

29) 뺷 뺸( 19160) 7 .

30) 뺷 뺸( 19160) 8 .

31) 뺷 뺸( 19160) 11 .

32) 뺷 뺸( 19159) 7, 8, 9, 10 .

.

‘ ’

. 1906 2 , , , , ,

.³³⁾ 3 8 6 28

.

. ‘

’ , ‘ ’

,³⁴⁾ ‘ ’

.³⁵⁾ ‘ ( )

’, ‘ ’,³⁶⁾ ‘ ’³⁷⁾

.

, .

. , .³⁸⁾

.

, , ,

, .

‘ ’

? .

33)뺷 뺸( 19143) 76, 77 ;뺷 뺸( 19149) 12 ;뺷

뺸( 19150) 12, 13 .

34) 뺷 뺸( 19150) 12, 13 .

35) 뺷 뺸( 19150) 12, 13, 14 .

36) 뺷 뺸( 19150) 12 .

37) 뺷 뺸( 19150) 13, 15 .

38) 뺷 뺸( 19155) 6 .

. ‘ ’ ,

‘ ’ ‘ ’

.

?

. ,

. .

‘

’ .³⁹⁾

. 1905 3 , ,

.⁴⁰⁾ 4 , , .⁴¹⁾

, ,

, .⁴²⁾

,

. ,⁴³⁾

.

‘ , ( ?)

’ .⁴⁴⁾

39) 뺷 뺸 1904 11 21 , ;뺷 뺸 1904 11 22 ,

.

40) 뺷 뺸( 19150) 10 .

41) 뺷 뺸( 19143) 61 .

42) 뺷 뺸( 19143) 61 .

43) 1905 1 6 ,

(뺷 뺸 26 232 ).

(1906 2 , )

( 19148) 19

(1906 3 , )

( 19148) 19

(1906 3 , ) 50

300

( 19148) 19

(1906 3 , )

( 19150) 12, 13, 14, 15

. .

‘

‘ ’ , ‘ ’

’ .⁴⁵⁾

‘ ’ ‘ ’ .

, , .

, ‘ ’ .⁴⁶⁾

4 ‘ ’

44) 뺷 뺸 1906 5 18 , .

45) 뺷 뺸( 19159) 6 .

46) Edward Palmer Thompson James C. Scott

. E. P. Thompson, 1971 “The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century”, Past and Present 50(February 1971), Customs in Common-Studies in Traditional Popular Culture-, 1990 The New

Press:New York; , , 2004뺷 :

뺸 .

’ .

. ,

,

‘ ’

, ‘ ’

‘ ’ .

‘ ’ . ‘ ’

.

‘ ’

. ,

‘ ’ ‘ ’ ,

.

. ,

. ,

. ,

. ‘ ’

. ,

, .

. ,

.

, ,

,

‘ ’

(1906 2 , )

, ,

, ( 19148) 19

(1906 2 , )

(

) , , ( 19148) 19

(1906 3 ,

) ( 19150)

12

(1906 3 , )

( 19150) 12

(1906 4 , , )

4

( 19150) 12

(1906 5 , )

( 19143) 77 ,

( 19147) 11 ,

( 19148) 20

(1906 5 , )

4 5 17 (

19156) 7

(1907 3 , )

( 19150) 14,15

. .

.

, , , ‘ ’

. ,

.

. 4

. ,

,

( ) .( )

, ‘ ’ , , ‘ ’

. ,

‘ ’, ‘ ’ .

‘ ’, ‘ ’, ‘ ’ .

‘ ’, ‘ ’, ‘ ’ ‘ ’, ‘ ’

. , ‘ ’ ‘ ’

. ‘ ’

‘ ’ ‘ ’

. ‘

’

, . ‘ ’

‘ ’( ), ‘ ’ .

, .

‘ ’ ‘ ’

‘ ’

.

(1907 3 , )

10

‘ ’

.

( 19150) 14

(1907 3 , ) 10 2, 3

.

( 19150) 14

‘ ’ .

47) .

‘ ’

, ‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ ’

.

5.

.

.

, .

, .

,

47) , 1994 뺷 뺸 , 65-66 .

,

? ,

.

,

‘ ’

. ‘ ’ ‘ ’ ‘

’ ‘ ’ , ‘

’ ,

. ‘ ’

‘ ’ .

, ,

. ‘

’, ‘ ’

. .

.

‘ ’ ‘ ’

. ‘ ’ ,

, .

,

.

(2008. 4. 26), (2008. 5. 8), (2008. 6. 1) .

, .

, 1994

뺷 뺸

, 2000

뺷

뺸

, 1988

뺷

:

뺸

, 1997

.

, 1997

뺷 뺸

, 1992

뺷 뺸 18.

_______, 2004

뺷 뺸 20.

, 1983

뺷 뺸 9,

.

, 2002

뺷 뺸

, 1979

뺷 뺸

, 1989 :

.

, 1997 :

. , 1996 1894~1910

.

_______, 1996

뺷 뺸 18.

, 1990 ‘ ’(1904~1906)

, 1999 :

뺷 뺸

, , 2004

뺷

뺸

, 2003

뺷 뺸

, 1995

뺷 뺸

.

E. P. Thompson, 1971 “The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century”, Past and Present 50(February 1971), Customs in Common-Studies in Traditional Popular Culture-, 1990 The New Press: New York.

Abstract

Kim, Jong-Jun

The study is aimed to collect and list the contentious issues related to Ilchinhoe ( , pro-Japanese Association) among the materials of Kyung-ri-won ( , The Office of Accounts) possessed in Kyu-jang-gak ( , Storing Institution of documents and material), and contribute to developing the study of Ilchinhoe further.

The materials of Kyung-ri-won, which will be used for the study, were mainly the files of documents produced in the period from 1905 to 1907, which were composed of government’s official reports and instructions or orders, exchanged among officers of Kyung-ri-won, those of local administration and tax collectors and the petitions sent to Kyung-ri-won by the local residents.

For the study based on actual proof, a great deal of effort has been made to get all the materials of Ilchinhoe together, and on the other hand, from the view-point of the study, almost, the same great effort has been thrown to unveil the true historical nature of Ilchinhoe as much as possible. As the results of the study, firstly, the full story of the conflicts related to Ilchinhoe and its socio-economical phase was brought to the light. Secondly, some aspects of Ilchinhoe’s reform-oriented activities, its quibbles or sophistication for the civilization of Chosun society advocated by the member of Ilchinhoe and the local people’s protests against Ilchinhoe’s activities were closely examined and verified.

Keywords: Ilchinhoe ( ), The Office of Accounts ( ), Public Lands ( ), Tax Resistance, Civilization ( ), Local Society ( )