Elementary Pre-service Teachers’ Conceptions on Mass and Problems of Teaching Mass
Sunggi Kwon
∗Department of Science Education, Daegu National University of Education, Daegu 42411, Korea (Received 8 July 2015 : revised 4 August 2015 : accepted 20 August 2015)
The purpose of this study is to examine the profiles of understanding the concept of mass by student teachers. The elementary science curriculum does not require that the concept of mass be taught, but rather requires that of weight to be taught. However, how to teach the concept of weight without a valid and credible understanding of mass is a question that many elementary student teachers have. Only when teaching related courses can elementary pre-service teachers could be expected to learn the scientific units of mass and weight. The subjects for this study were 79 student teachers with a science major selected from a University of Education in a local city. Questionnaires on the concept of mass were developed so as to match those for the concept of weight in previous research. After the pre-service teachers’ choices and written responses had been analyzed, we are able to get some profiles for the concept of mass and to discuss the problems associated with teaching the concept of mass combined with units of measuring weight in the elementary textbooks. We will suggest ways to develop new effective tips for teaching the concept of mass to elementary students and pre-service teachers.
PACS numbers: 01.40.jc, 01.40.-d
Keywords: Mass conception, Teaching, Weight, Association
w
Õ ×6 ] K ¡w ] ¡t K 8 ý ù m ÇS ë s 4 G È º Ñ ÷ ù m ÇS ë s 4 G È8 ý U y ¢ U ê s m
-
! H) ç M
∗@
/½¨§¹¢¤@/<Ƨ õ<Ƨ¹¢¤õ, @/½¨ 42411
(2015¸ 7Z4 8{9 ~ÃÎ6§, 2015¸£ 8Z4 4{9 ú&ñ:r~ÃÎ6£§, 2015¸ 84 20{Z 9 >FSX&ñ)
:
r½¨Hí1px<Ƨ õ<Ƨ¹¢¤õ&ñ_ Áº>Fl éß"é¶\"f µ1ÏÒqt½+É Ãº eH ||9¾Ó >h¥Æ\ @/ôÇ <Æ_þv 9 כ
¹$í_ ëH]j ]jl\¦0AôÇ כ ܼÐ, \Vq§[þt_ |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ\ @/ôÇ sK úïr¸ü< |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ t¸ _
9כ¹$í`¦ ¹1ÔФ. t~½Ó_ ôÇ >h §¹¢¤@/<Ƨ <ÆÒqt[þt 79"î`¦@/©Ü¼Ð |9|¾Ó\ @/ôÇ >h¥Æ`¦¸
¦ |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ØÔ}9 9כ¹$í x9 |9|¾Ó >h¥ tƸ ~½Óîß`¦¸ %i. ÕªQ |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ØÔ }9
9כ¹ eH 6£xsú² 52% &ñ¸Ð |9|¾Ó >h¥`Ʀ ØÔ}9 9כ¹ \O (48%)ü< q5pw > ¸÷&%3
. "f |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ¸{9 Ö¼\ @/K"f¸ ðøÍ$õí ìøÍ@/_ _|s ØØ > @/wn½+É Ãº e`¦כ s
9, í1px<Ƨ §õ"f\ ||9¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦¸{9 H כÉrÁº> éß"é¶`¦#Q§>> ëß[þtú e. "f í1px
<ÆÒqt[þt\> |9|¾Ó >h¥`ƦsKr~´ ú eHú\O t¸ ~½Óîß`¦¹1ÔÐH {9s 8¹¡¤ 9כ¹½+É כ s.
PACS numbers: 01.40.jc, 01.40.-d
Keywords: |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ, |9|¾Ó ú\O, Áº> Fl, ©
∗E-mail: [email protected]
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
I. " e  ] Ø
1. ìÅ8ý ýmÇ~¿VRË õmÍÒ×XìÄ
í1px<Ƨ úïr_ <ÆÒqt[þt`¦ @/©Ü¼Ð l:r õ<Æ >h¥Æ
\
@/ôÇ ¸\¦µ1ßj˵ܼÐ+ õ<Æ&h >h¥Æ o\¦Ä»¸
H½¨H¸Öµ1Ï > '÷&#QM®oܼ 9, Ótüo_ ¸>h¥Æ
½
¨\¦ &ñoôÇ ½¨H Óüt %o ò%i ׿\"f \P, l, j˵, yn
C >h¥Æ`¦ Ùþd >h¥ÆÜ¼Ð ×þ # ׿1px ÆÒ<qt[þt\>"f
© > µ1Ï|÷&H¸>h¥Æ[þt_ ìrí\¦Ð#ÅÒ%3 [1]. s õ<Æ >h¥Æ ½¨[þtrÉõ<Ƨ¹¢¤&õñ_ >hµ1Ïs õ
<Ƨõ"f >hµÏ 11px\ ìøÍ%ò÷&#Q í׿1pxÆ<§ &³©\"f z
´|9&h o\¦ {9ܼ~´ sכ 9, <ÆÒqt[þt_ õ<Æ&h >h
¥Æ
Aá¤Ü¼Ð o H {9`¦l@/½+É כ s. ÕªQ õ<Ƨ õ
"f\¦ >hµ1Ï H õ&ñ\H õ<Æ >h¥Æ_ &ñ ÷rëß m
õ<Æ >h¥Æ_ >h ~½Ód 1pxÄBº 4¤¸úôÇ ëH]j[þts \O )
eܼ 9, §õ"f |99[þt¸ ªôÇ #Q9¹¡§`¦ °ú¦ e
. s õ<Ƨõ"f_ >hµ1Ï õ&`ñ¦½¨ # í1px<Ƨ õ
<Ƨõ"f_ >hµ1Ï\ z´]jÐ ÃÐ#ôÇ §H |99 ^]j,
§¹¢¤õ&ñ_ ?/6 xs 0A> úïr, |99 § hË>_ ?/ÂÒ,
<Æ_þv ?/6 x ¨$½í, èF &ñ 1xp"\f ëH]j\¦¦ e6£§`¦
¹
1Ô?/%3 [2].
:r½¨_ 1xll¸ s ëH]jü<'aº÷&#Q Òqtz¤. ½¨
^
&hܼР´ú , 2009¸ >h&ñ §¹¢¤õ&ñ\ í1px
<Ƨ 4<Ƹ_ Áº> éß"é¶`¦ >hµ1Ͻ+É M: Õª s\¸ ]jl
)
a ëH]j (Áº> é"ßé¶\ |9|¾ÓsH>h¥Æ`¦í<ÊK"f t¸ K
ôÇH ëH]j) ìøÍ4¤K"f ]jl÷&%3 [3]. s õ
&
ñ`¦[j > [O"î lHQ§#t>ëß í1pxÆ<§ õ<Ƨ 6
xt¸"f\HÁº> >h¥Æëß ]jr÷&#Q e¦, |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦
¸{9K ôÇHכ¹½¨[þt¸ y© > ]jla &)hs e. Õª
!
3ܼÐ+ í1pxÆ<§ §[þts |9|¾ÓsH 6 x#Q\¦þjèôÇ Ü
¼Ð sK > ÷&#Q {9©&hܼР|9|¾Óõ Áº>\¦ D¥1lx
H ëH]j\¦K½+É Ãº e¦ l@/½+É Ãº e [4,5]. |9|¾Ó õ
Áº>\¦"fÐ D¥1lx H ëH]jHÕª ¿º t >h¥Æ`¦½¨ Z>
# sK K|¨cú el M:ëH\ Bĺ ׿כ¹ [6,7].
Õ
ªQ ׿1px<Ƨ @/<Ƨ úïr\"f |9|¾Ó`¦ØÔ}9 M:
H¾»_ >h¥Æ >h ~½Ód`¦ 9, jµsË 6 x #
5Åq÷&H Óüt^_ (5Åq¸-jµ Õ˪AáÔ_ f lÖ¦lH) :
£¤$íܼР$ |9|¾Ó`¦ ¸{9 ¦ ׿\ Áº> ׿§4\ _
ôÇ כ e`¦t¸ 9, ||9¾Óõ Áº>_ éß0At¸ ½¨Z>
½
+É Ãº e. Óüto >h¥Æ_ éß0AH ²DG]j ³ðïr SI éß0A>
\
¦ØÔl 0A #, l:réß0A (U´s, rçß, |9|¾Ó 1px)õ Ä»
¸ éß0A (j˵, 5Åq¸, îr1lx\-t 1px)\¦½¨Z> HX<, l
:r éß0A îß\ |9|¾Ó_ éß0A kg, g`¦ 6 x¸2¤ Ùþ¡ [3].
Table 1. Subjects of preservice teachers.
Grades Gender
Total
Male Female
3rd grade 16 36 52
4thgrade 7 20 27
Ages 22.4 21.7 27
Table 2. Questionnaires for mass concepts.
Subcategories Items of questions No. of items Words being associated to mass 1
Mass Units of mass 4
concept Measuring mass 7
Meaning of mass 9
◦ Which is more difficult to teach 11 Teaching mass or weight
mass ◦ Is it needed to teach mass? 12
◦ Teaching methods to teach mass 13 concept
Õ
ªQ &³F õ<Ƨõ"f §6 x t¸"fH Áº>ü< |9
|
¾Ó_ éß0A\¦ ½¨ìr "f¸ &³z´&hܼР¿º >h¥Æ_ éß0A
\
¦ D¥6 x H&³F ©`S!¦Õª@/Ð Ä»t ¦ e.
s
ëH]j\¦ K l 0A # í1px<Ƨ ÆÒ<qt[þtÉr |9
|
¾Ó\ @/ # l:r&hܼР#Q" d`¦ ¦ eܼ 9, #Q"
>
h¥Æ`¦ 8 #Q90> H \¦ ¸½+É 9כ¹$ís ]jl÷&%3
. ÕªQ í1px<ÆÒqt_ âĺH |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦Cĺt¸ ·ú§
¤l M:ëH\ ÆÒ©&h õ<Æ >h¥Æ`¦ ¸ H ~½ÓZOs
¸ ¸½¨_ {©$ís ëHj] |¨c ú e¦ ¸ õ_
ø@¸t _ëHÛ¼XOl\, §¹¢¤@/<Ƨ\ F<Æ ×æ \V q
§[þt`¦ {9 ½¨@/Ü©¼Ð # |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ_ sK ü
< |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ t¸ ~Óî½ß`¦¸ %i.
2. ìÅ Ò×» õmÍ <gX¢XìÈ
1) |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ¸ l 0AôÇ ëH½Ó`¦ í1px<Ƨ õ<Æ õ
§¹¢¤õ&ñ_ Áº> >h¥Æ ¸ ëH½Óõ "fÐ @/6£x÷&¸2¤
Ã
ÐÒo&hܼР>hµ1Ï # í1pxÆ<§ \Vq§[þt\> z´r
% i.
2) í1px<Ƨ \Vq§[þt |_9|¾Ó >h¥Æ\ @/ôÇ ¸ õ\¦ ìr$3 # |9|¾Ó >h¥`ƦÁº> >h¥õÆ <Êa ØÔ}9 M: _
t¸©_ ëH]j&h`¦ 7H_ôÇ.
:r ½¨H ||9¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ í1px<Ƨ\"f t¸ H ©S! s
\OܼټÐ, |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ\ @/ôÇ f]X&h ¸H ½+É Ãº
Table 3. Frameworks for classifying of understanding mass questionnaires.
Levels of understanding Criteria Scores
Complete Understanding (CU) ◦ correct answer to a simple and an written question 3-4 points In-Complete Understanding (IU) ◦ correct choice only in a simple question 1-2 points
◦ correct either only in simple choice or in an written question
Non-Understanding (NU) ◦ not correct neither in simple choice nor in an written question 0 point
◦ not answered
Table 4. Distribution of associated words and its ranks.
Words / Weight unique (spring, balancing) Gravity invariant kg Moon absolute Mass Mass Volume
group scale conservation
Frequencies 28 26 18 15 12 10 8 7 7 7 6
of words
percent 35% 33% 23% 19% 15% 13% 10% 9% 9% 9% 8%
(n = 79)
Ranks 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 8 8 11
\O
%3ܼ 9, |9|Óõ¾'aº)a"ßéé¶Ü¼Ð Áº> é"ßé¶õ'aº
#
|9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦t¸ ¿º >h¥Æ_ sK\¦q§ H
~
½ÓZO`¦¹1Ô¤. ¢¸ôÇ ½¨ @/©_ ]jôÇ&h ³ð|9\ ôÇ&ñ÷&
#
Q e¦, :r½¨_ õ\¦ÐÒÃo&h úïr\"f K$3½+É Ãº µ
1Ú\ \O%3.
II. ì Å U ê s0 n É
:r½¨\"fH§¹¢¤@/Æ<§\"f õ<ƧF ½¨ y©_\¦ Ã
ºy© "f ||9¾Ó\ 'aºa) >h¥Æõ |9|Ó >¾h¥Æ_ t¸ 9 כ
¹$í x9 ~½Óîß`¦ ¹1ÔH sכ%3. ĺo t~½ÓFg%ir_ ô
Ç >h §¹¢¤@/Æ<§_ <ÆÒqt[þt`¦ @/©Ü¼Ð >ü< 'aº
)
a ¿º >h <Æõ (3<ƸÉr A, BÆõ<\¦, 4<ƸÉr A<Æõ)\
"
f 8úx 79"î`¦½¨@/©Ü¼Ð &ñ %iܼ 9 z<ÆÒqtÐH
#
<ÆÒqts ´ú§¤ (Table 1).
|9
|¾Ó >h¥Æ |9ëHtHí1xp<Ƨ õ<Æ §6 xt¸"f ׿
\
"f Áº> Fl éß"é¶õ'aº÷&#Q Áº>\ @/ôÇ >h¥Æ`¦¸
ôÇ ½¨ [8]\"f 6 x)a|9ëHt_ Áº> ¸ ëH½Ó[þtõ
`¦sÀÒ¸2¤>hµ1Ï %i (Table 2). Áº> >h¥Æ\ @/ôÇ
¸6 x |9ëHtü< <Êa 6£x½ú²É M+:H 30ìr&ñ¸ èכ¹÷&%3
.
<ÆÒqt[þt_ é#ßQ © ìøÍ6£xõ ìr$3Ér#ßéQ © _ ì
r$3 ~½ÓZO [10,11]õ Óüto ¸>h¥Æ t¸ ¸_ ½¨ ~½ÓZO [1]õ Ä» > ½¨ @/©_ 6£x IJú»+þAõ ¸\¦0AÅÒÐ ì
r$3 %i. |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ ¸ õ ׿\"f &húo½+É Ãº e
H ëH½Ó[þt (4, 7, 9)Ér]h&XôÇ 6£x{ú²9 M: 1>h_ 6£x
² ú
1&hm ÂÒ# # þj¦ 4&ht ÂÒ# # G&h
%
i. s\¦½ÓܼРTable 3%! Ó3üto ¸>h¥Æ ½¨\"f
6 xÙþ¡~ 4éß> ìrÀÓd¦ [12]` ¦ 3éß>Ð »¡¤è # 3-4&h
É
r¢-aôÇ sK (CU)Ð, 1-2&hÉr Ô¦¢-aôÇ sK (IU)Ð, 0&hÉr¸ú3lw)asK Áº6£x²ú (NU)\ K{© ¸2¤sK Ã
ºïr`¦ ìrÀÓ %i.
III. ì Å + s ÇÊ Ý
1. ùmÇSës 4GÈ;c 6X¢ º
|9
|¾ÓsH éß#Q\"f © ´§sú ©÷&H כ `¦ ¸ ô
Ç õH Table 4ü< °ú . Table 4\¦ Ð 10% s©s
©)a #ßéQH 8úx 7>hÐ z¤Ü¼ 9 Õª ׿\H\V©ôÇ
@
/Ð îÁº>ï\¦© ´ú§s ©%i. Õª 6£§\H î¦Ä»
<Êï, î$Ö¦ï, î׿§4ï, î t ·ú§Hï, î²úï, îkgï, îmï, î]X
@
/&hï, î|9|¾Ó Ð>rï_ íH"fÐ © %i.
§¹¢¤@/<Ƨ <ÆÒqt[þtÉr ||9¾Ós Óüt|9_ ¦Ä»ôÇ ªÜ¼Ð"f Ô
¦ 9, kg éß0A\¦6 xôÇH ©`¦ "f¸ Áº>
<
ÊÉr ׿§4, $Ö¦ 1xp_ ´ú`¦© H Üכ¼Ð z¤Ü¼ 9,
|9
|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦sK½+É M: Áº>Héß#Q\¦ > ©
H : £¤$í`¦ °ú¦ e%3. Áº>ü< ׿§4`¦ ©ôÇ ìøÍ6£x
`
¦ ½+Ëu, §¹¢¤@/<Ƨ ÆÒ<qt[þt_ 54% &ñ¸H |9|¾Ós
H 6 x#Q\ @/ # Áº> (׿§4)\¦ © %iܼ 9, |9|¾Óõ Á
º>\¦ ½¨Z> l ÐH _ q5pwôÇ כ ܼРD¥6 x H
כ
`¦ [O"î½É Ã+ º e. ôǼ# Áº>H ´ú\"f |9|¾Ó`¦
©Ùþ¡~ qÖ¦s 15%Hõ [8]ü< q§ , |9|¾Ó\"f Á
º>\¦© lH Bĺ ~1tëß, Áº>\"f |9|¾Ó`¦©
lH#Q§>¦ K$3)a.
Table 5. Mass can be measured? (n = 79).
Group (grade) 3rd grade 4thgrade Total (n = 52) (n = 27) (percent) measured 34 (65%) 18 (67%) 52 (66%) not-measured 13 (25%) 7 (26%) 20 (25%) no answer 5 (10%) 2 (7%) 7 (9%)
Table 6. How mass can be measured?
Group (grade) 3rd grade 4thgrade Total (n = 52) (n = 27) (percent) Contrasting
15 (29%) 6 (22%) 21 (27%) weight (gravity)
Lever scale 6 (12%) 6 (22%) 12 (15%) Balanced scale 4 (8%) 5 (19%) 9 (11%) A weight of scale
2 (4%) 4 (15%) 6 (8%) others (omitted)
Partial sum. 27 (52%) 21 (78%) 48 (61%)
|9
|Ó_¾ &ñ_\¦ ¶nsH ëHÓ\½"f 62% (62"î)H Óüt^_ ¦ Ä
»ôÇ ªs¦ Õüt %i¦, QtH x9¸ Áº>ü< °ú
É
r ¸ú3lw)aÕüt`¦ Áº6£x²ú`¦ %i. @/^&hܼÐ
§¹¢¤@/<Ƨ <ÆÒqt[þtÉr |9|¾ÓÉr Óüt|9s ¦Ä» H$í|9Ér s
K Hכ ܼРz¤.
¢
¸ôÇ §¹¢¤@/<Ƨ <ÆÒqt[þt |s 9|¾ÓÉr 8£¤&ñ½+É Ãº e¦ 6
£
x²úôÇ qÖ¦s 66% s©s%t3ëß, Õª ìøÍ@/Ð |9|¾ÓÉr 8£¤
&
½ñ+É Ãº \OH 6£x²ú¸ 25% (20"î)Ð z¤.
Õ
ªQ |9|¾Ó`¦#Q" ~½ÓZOܼР8£¤&ñ½+É Ãº eHt\¦ ¶ns
H "fÕüt+þA ëH½Ó\"fHBĺ ªôÇ 6£xsú² ¸Ø¦÷&%3.
Õ
ª ׿\ Table 6\H ׿§4 (Áº>)ü< q§ôÇH 6£x²ús
© ´ú§s z¤¦, 6£§Ü¼ÐH ª¼1Ï $Ö¦`¦s6 xôÇ
À»]Xr $Ö¦`¦s6 x # |9|¾Ó`¦ 8£¤&½ñ+É Ãº eH 6
£
x²ús Õª +'\¦ s%3. ÕªQ |9|¾Ó_ 8£¤&ñ ~½ÓZOÉr B Ä
º ªôÇ 6£x²ús e%3l\ þjè 10% s©_ 6£x²ú ëß`¦ ì
r$3 %i¦, ^ 6£x²ú ׿\ 61%ëßs |9|¾Ó 8¤&£ñ ~½Ód`¦ Ä
»_ > 6£x²úôÇ כ ܼР%oÙþ¡.
|9
|¾Ó_ éß0A\¦ ¶nsH ëHÓ_½ õH |9|¾Ó_ éß0AÐ kgs g`¦³ðr y 1&`h¦ÂÒ# # G&h %iܼ 9,
½
+ËíßôÇ &hú 4&hs 9, Table 3_ lïr`¦ s6 x ÷& 3- 4&h`¦%3rÉ <ÆÒqt[þtßë¢-aôÇ sK (CU)Ð óøÍéß ¦, 1- 2&h`¦ %3Ér âĺH ÒìÂr&h sK (IU)Ð ìr$3 %i. |9
|
¾Ó_ éß0AÐ kg, g`¦6 x H ëH]jH ~1¦ l@/½+É Ãº e
#Q"f &ñ²úÖ¦s Z}`¦ כ s¦ l@/Ùþ¡Ü¼ Table 7`¦
Ð, |9|¾Ó_ éß0A\¦¢-ay sKôÇ âĺH 47%s%3¦, Â
Òìr&hܼРsKôÇ âĺH 28%\ ¦ tÙþ¡tëß, d¦2; s K
Áº6£x²ú_ âĺ¸ 25%Ð z¤. ²DG |9|¾Ó_ éß
Table 7. Levels of Understanding of the SI unit of mass.
Group
Levels of Understanding
Total Non Under- Partial Under- Complete Un-
standing standing derstanding 3rd grade 16 (31%) 15 (29%) 21 (40%) 52 4th grade 4 (15%) 7 (26%) 16 (60%) 27 Total (%) 20 (25%) 22 (28%) 37 (47%) 79
Table 8. Is needed to teach mass? (n = 79).
Group (grade) 3rd grade 4th grade Total (n = 52) (n = 27) (percent) Yes 34 (65%) 7 (26%) 41 (52%) No 18 (35%) 20 (74%) 38 (48%)
Table 9. Which is difficult to teach mass or weight? (n
= 79)
Group (grade) 3rd grade 4th grade Total (n = 52) (n = 27) (percent) Mass 44 (85%) 22 (81%) 66 (84%) Weight 7 (13%) 4 (15%) 11 (14%)
Same 1 (2%) 0 (0%) 1 (1%)
No answer 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 1 (1%)
0
A 6 xÉr@/|ÄÌ 50% &ñ¸ëß `¦ØÔ> 6 xÙþ¡Ü¼ 9, Õª s Ä
»\¦Áº> éß0AÐ 6 x÷&~ :r (t)s kg׿õ °ú Éréß 0
A[þtõ D¥1lx HX<"f ¹1Ô`¦Ãº e.
2. ùmÇSës 4GÈ8ý Uy¢;c 6X¢ ýmÇ~¿VRËÊÝ Uês0nÉ º
|9
|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ØÔ}9 כ9¹\¦ ¸ %i8m Table 8%
!
3 @/|ÄÌ §¹¢¤@/Æ<§ <ÆÒqt ׿ì]XøÍs |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ØÔ}9
9
כ¹ e"f¸ ìøÍ@/Ð |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ØÔ}9 9כ¹\O
Hõ¸ Qt ]XìøÍ`¦t Hª`©¦Ð%i. Õª
Q 4<Ƹ ÐH 3<Ƹ |é9ß\"f |9|Ó >¾h¥Æ`¦ØÔ5g
ôÇH 9כ¹\¦ 65% &ñ¸ 6£x ú²%iH כÉr |9|¾Ó >h
¥Æ
s Áº> éß"é¶`¦ t¸½+É M: sK HX< 9ú&hs¦ Òq
tyôǦ K$3|¨cú e.
¢
¸ í1px<ÆÒqt[þt\p ||9¾Óõ Áº> >h¥ ׯ æ\"f #QÖ¼ >h
¥Æ
s 8 #Q9Ö¦\¦ |9ëHÙþ¡`¦M:, §¹¢¤@/Æ<§ <ÆÒqt[þt_ 84% 66"îs |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ 8 #Q9Ö¦ כ s¦ 6£x²úôÇ ì
øÍ, ìøÍ@/Ð Áº> #Q9Ö¦ sכH 6£x²úÉr 14%\ Ô¦ õ
%i. :£¤ 3y <Ƹ |9éßr 4É <Ƹ Ð ||9¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦t
¸½+É 9כ¹ 8 e¦ 6£x²ú %i6£§\¸ õ<ƧF ½¨ x9
t¸ZO y©_\¦ úy© "f Áº> Fl éß"é¶`¦<Æ_þvôÇ
f
Êê%iHX<¸ |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦Bĺ #Q90> %i. Óüt:r |9
|
¾Ó >h¥Æ ÷rëß m Áº> >h¥Æ¸¢-a > sKôÇ כ Ér
m [8]. s õHí1pxÆ<§\"f õ<Æ`¦ØÔ5g
½
+É \Vq§[þts |9|¾Ó >h¥`Ʀ sK t¸ H {9
`
¦#Q90>ôǦ \V©½+É Ãº e.
"f í1px<Ƨ \Vq§_ 80% s©s <ÆÒqt[þts #Q
90> H |9|Ó >¾h¥Æ`¦ØÔu¸2¤õ<Æõ §¹¢¤õ&ñs
§õ"f\ |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦íÊr<v ú\O ?/6 x\ @/ôÇ ÂÒ {
ܼР6 x# ÂÒ&ñ&h õ\¦ צú¸ e. s ëH ]
j\¦K½+É Ãº eH |9|¾Ó >h¥_Æ t¸ HÓî~½ßs,
|9
|¾Ós Óüt^_ ¦Ä»ôÇ :£¤$ís 9,'a$í_ ß¼l\¦ ±p כ e
`
¦ sKrvHכ s. 7£¤ ||9¾Ós ß¼, a$'ís &"f &ñ t
1px5Åq îr1xl©I\¦Õª@/Ð Ä»t 9H|í$9s |9|¾Ó
\
qYV # ß¼l M:ëH\ ¦Ä»<Ê`¦t¸K ôÇ. s
½¨ [8]\"fH í1px<Ƨ\"f Áº> éß"é¶_ t¸ ~½Óîß`¦
7H_½+É M:HÁº>ü< |9|¾ÓsH>h¥Æ_ _p Bĺ Ø
Ô 9, éß0A, "é¶ 1px`¦"îSX> ½¨ìr ¸2¤t¸ H~½Ó î
ß`¦ ]jîß %i. |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ í1px<ÆÒt[qþt\> Bĺ /' Ä
º"f¸ ´òõ&hܼР²ú½+É Ãº eH~½Óîß`¦¹1ÔH {9s r
/åL ¦ r~ÃÎ`¦Ãº e.
IV. + s Ç Â ] Ø õ m Í Ä Ò × ì Å
:r½¨\"fHt~½Ó_ §¹¤¢@/<Ƨ\ FÆ ×<æ 3<Ƹ õ
4<Ƹ <ÆÒqt`¦½¨ @/©Ü¼Ð # |9|¾Ó >h¥Æõ t¸
~
½ÓZO\ @/ôÇ ¸ õ\¦ ìr$3 # 6£§õ °ú Érr&h
`
¦%3%3.
|9
|¾ÓsH 6 x#Q\"f Áº> ׿§4`¦ ©ôÇ qÖ¦Ér 50%\¦Å%3l M:ëH\ |9|¾Ó`¦ Áº>ü< _ Ä»ôÇ כ ܼ
Ð D¥1lx H&³©s F³÷&&%3. ëß Áº>\"f |9|¾Ó`¦
© Hq֦Р|9|¾Ó\"f Áº> (׿§4)\¦© Hכ s
s` Z}¤H&hÉr ||9¾Ós Áº>ü< x9]X > 'a÷&
"f¸ ½¨ìr÷&#Q sK|¨c כ9¹$ís e6§`£¦ r ¦ e
. ¢¸ôÇ õ<Ƨ¹¢¤õ&ñ\"fHÁº>ü< |9|Ó_¾ éß0A\¦½¨ ì
r "f¸ &³z´&hܼРÁº> éß0Aü< |9|¾Ó éß0A\¦ D¥6 x
H &³F ©`S!¦ &ñ ¦ e. |9|¾Ó_ éß0AH SI éß 0
A>\"f lïrܼР&ñôÇ kg, g`¦6 xK HX<, s\¦
`
¦ØÔ> sKôÇ qÖ¦Ér§¹¢¤@/<ÆÒqt_ 47%\ Ô¦õôÇ כ Ü
¼Ð z¤. Áº>_ éß0AÐ N`¦6 x H `כ¦ "é¶gË: Ü
¼Ð ¦, kg, gÉr |9|¾Ó_ éß0AÐë ß6 x½+É כ `¦t¸½+É
9
כ¹$ís e. Áº>ü< |9|¾Ó_a'>HÁº>H |9|¾Ó\ ׿
§
45Åq¸ (g = 9.8 m/s2)\¦ YLÇ Ãô ºu\ K{© ټР|9
|
¾Ó_ °úכÐ @/|ÄÌ 10C &ñ¸a)H כ¸ ìøÍ×¼r sKr
&
½+É כ s.
|9
|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ØÔ}9 9כ¹ e/\O_ qÖ¦s q5pw Ùþ
¡tëß, í1px<Ƨ\"f Áº> >h¥Æ ÐH |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦#Q
90>½+É כ s¦ \V©ôÇ qÖ¦s 84%`¦ Å%3H õ
H &³f\ HÁº H í1xp<Ƨ §[þt\> ¸ôÇ õ [8]ü<¸ {9u÷& 9, í1pxÆ<§ §õ"f §6 x t¸"f\
|9
|Ó >¾h¥Æ`¦F&hG&hܼР¸{ 9Hכ Ér Áº> éß"é¶_ ú
\O
`¦8¹¡¤Q§#>> ëß[þt0px$ís Z}. Õª!3\¸ f¸ Á
º> éß"é¶\"f |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ¸{9 Ö¼\ @/K"f¸ ðøÍ
$í
õ ìøÍ@/_ _|s ØØ > @/wn ¦ e.
"f í1pxÆÒ<qt[þts #Q90> H |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦ ~1> s K
r~´ ú eH Óî~½ß`¦¹1ÔÐH {9s 9כ¹<Ê`¦r~ÃÎ
`
¦Ãº e. 6 xº^Ão= $Ö¦`¦s6x #'a$í ||9¾Ó`¦¸&h Ü
¼Ð &ñ_ # ׿<ÆÒqt[tþ\> t¸ [13] , 3luÁº>
H ´ú\ |ÅÒ#Q 3lu|9|¾ÓsH ½¨^&h YV\¦ @/qr
&
Ð, Áº>ü< |9|¾Ó_ éß0AÐ kg, g`¦ D¥1lx t ·ú§>
|9
|¾Ó_ éß0Aëß ¸{9 ,'a$ >íh¥Æ`¦s6 xÇô'a$í |9
|
¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦t¸ H כ¸ 0px½+É כ s [8]. ÂÒx\¦
Óüt^ü< ||9¾Ó`¦ ½¨Z> 9H r¸ [14]¸ ÅÒ3lq½+É 9כ¹
etëß, :r½¨\"f s ~½Óîß[tþ_ ´òõ\¦SX H
כ
Ér½¨ #30A\¦#Á #Qèß. ëß Êê5Åq½¨[þt`¦ :x # Á
º>ü< |9|¾Ó_ >h¥Æ`¦ "fÐ ìr"î > ½¨Z> "f¸ |9
|¾
Ó >h¥Æ`¦ Øæìry sK ¸2¤ t¸½+É Ãº eH&³z´&hs
¦ ½¨^&h ~½Óî`ߦ¹1Ô^¦ `כ¦ ]jîßôÇ. í1px<ÆÒqts
\Vq§\> |9|¾Ó >h¥Æ`¦t¸½+É âĺ Érõ<Æ >h
¥Æ
[þt_ âĺ%!3 |9|¾Ó\ @/ôÇ ¸>h¥Æs Òqt±ú ú eܼ 9, |9|¾Ó\ @/ôÇ ¸>h¥Æ¸ FG4¤É ý+ º eH ~½Óî߸ 9כ¹
½
+É כ s.
P
c p 8 ý ò k >
s
7HëHÉr 2013¸¸ @/½¨§¹¢¤@/<Ƨ §?/ <ÆÕüt½¨q _
t"é¶`¦~ÃΤ_þvm.
REFERENCES
[1] J. Song, I. K. Kim, Y. M. Kim, S. G. Kwon and W.
G. Oh et al., Map of Students’ Physics Misconcep- tion (BooksHill, Seoul, 2004).
[2] D. Chae, I. Yang and S. Jung, JKASE 31, 1121 (2011).
[3] Ministry of Education, Science Teachers Guidebook for 4th grade (MiraeAn, Seoul, 2014).
[4] J. Park and Y. Jhun, JKASE 34, 295 (2014).
[5] KOFAC, in Workshop Manuals for Elementary Sci- ence Textbook (Seoul, Feb. 15-16, 2014).
[6] A. B. Arons, Teaching Introductory Physics (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1997).
[7] I. Galili and D. Kaplan, Sci. Educ. 80, 457 (1996).
[8] S. Kwon, JEE 31, 85 (2015).
[9] H. D. Young and R. A. Freedman, University Physics with Modern Physics, 10th ed. (BooksHill, Seoul, 2002), pp. 96-99.
[10] E. Youn and Y. Park, in Proc. of the 2015 Int. Con- fer. & the 67th General Meeting, edited by Y. M.
Kim (Busan, Feb. 5-7, 2015), p. 183.
[11] E. Youn and Y. Park, JKASE 33, 735 (2013).
[12] S. Kwon and J. Kim, JKASE 25, 476 (2007).
[13] J. Kim and W. Oh, Sae Mulli 54, 519 (2007).
[14] Z. Biener and C. Smeenk, Sci. & Educ. 13, 309 (2004).