Ⅵ. THE ‘GOVERNME NT-CAN’T-DO-IT’ SY
NDROME OF PUBLIC FINANCE.
Presenters: S. J. Kim H .W. Park S . k. kim
1. Political views
It objects to the encroachment by the state on the freedom of the individual.
2. Economy views
It objects to the over-expansion of an inefficient public sector to burdening the future generations with debt, to igniting inflation, or to heading for an unsustainable burden of public debt.
CRITIQUE ON THE FULL EMPLOY
MENT SCHEME
FULL EMPLOYMENT SCHEME F OR THE OBJECTIONS FORM
Approval on the freedom of the individual
In India we are surrounded by devastating poverty with nearly one third of the population living in sub-human conditions.
Private sector is necessarily more effect than the public sector
It makes the mistake of assuming that the public and the private sector are necessarily in competition in all situations.
FINANCIAL INVESTMENT BY THE PUBLIC PROCUREMENT PROCESS
FINANCIAL DEFICITS FOR THE OPPOSITION CLAIMS
Half of Indian children
Suffer from under-nourishment 20 per cent of rural children
INFLATION BY HIGHER WAGE
The stipulated minimum legal wage would ‘self select’ the poor precisely because it is lower than the normally paid w ages.
The scheme would have little direct impact on the working of the rest of labour market because it creates in effect se gmented labour market.
Poor people would have a stronger bargaining position.
It will help them to fight unfair discrimination, give them dignity
This is precisely one of the objectives of this full em-
ployment scheme.
작은 정부가 가장 현명 하다는 주류 경제학자들의 주장
정책적 반대
1. 정치적 성격
2. 경제적 성격
완전 고용 계획에 대한 반대 형태
1. 인도의 특수한 배경
2. 민간 부문이 공공부문에 비해 효율적
공공부문 대 민간부문에 관한 이분 법적 논쟁
1.
민간 부문 기업
기업경영변화 보유지분의 매각 소유권 변경2.
공공 부문 기업
노동자 참여계획소유권과 사용권 결합
민영화에 관한 기본적 논점
공공부문 및 민간부문의 작동을 규제하는 능력
알 권리
책임과 의무의 명시
적자재정에 대한 반대 주장
농촌 어린이의 인도 어린이의 농촌 어린이의 인도 어린이의
완전 고용계획의 목표
노동시장 압박 인플레이션 유발