Introduction to Chemical Convergence for Energy & Environment
Chapter 9. Supercapacitors
Spring Semester, 2012
Kookheon Char
Batteries
(Chapt. 7) Fuel Cells (Chapt. 8)
Supercapacitors (Chapt. 9)
Electrochemical Energy Storages
Background on Conventional Capacitors
Schematic of Essential Components Fundamental Equations
d C = ε
rε
0A
2
2 1 CV E =
ESR P V
4
2 max
=
C: Capacitance
εr : Dielectric Constant of Medium (Electrolyte)
ε0: Dielectric Constant of Vacuum A: Surface Area
d: Electrode Distance E: Energy
V: Voltage P: Power
ESR: Equivalent Series Resistance
Capacitance proportional to electrode
surface area Energy proportional to capacitance
Maximum power limited by internal
resistances (ESR) of a capacitorNegative
Electrode Positive
Electrode
Applied Voltage d
Electric Field
+−
+ −
−
+−
+−
+−
+−
+ +− −
+−
+ +− −
+−
+Store Energy as Electric Potential between Two Electrodes and a Dielectric Layer
Comparison of Capacitor Technologies: Electrostatic Capacitor
Electrostatic Capacitors
Materials
- Electrodes: metals
- Dielectric materials: metal films, ceramic, glass, mica
Capacitance - pF ~ μF
- capacitance is constant
Voltage
V E
εA Ed dz Qd
A Edz Q
V = ∫
0d= ∫
0dε = =
d E = V d
+ Dielectric -
Layer
ε
rA: area
dt dV(t) dt C
dq(t) I(t) = =
where E: Electric Field, Q: Charge
V C = Q
Current
where q=CV, C: constant (capacitance)
nm) 1000
(d ≈
Electrolytic Capacitors
V E
Materials
- Anode: Aluminum (or Tantalum) - Dielectric: Aluminum Oxide
- Cathode: Electrolyte & Aluminum
High Capacitance - μF ~ mF
- High capacitance arises from high
dielectric constant and extremely small, uniform thickness of metallicoxide (d: 10 ~ 100 nm)
- Capacitance of electrolyte is not a constant (i.e., electric double layer)
+
Dielectric-
(aluminum oxide)
d ∆ d
Aluminum
ε
Potential (V) Profile in the Diffuse Layer Electrolyte
Comparison of Capacitor Technologies: Electrolytic Capacitor
χ
=
−κ
κ
Ks 0 s
) e T 4 / ZeV tanh(
) T 4 / ZeV
tanh(
21
0 2 2 0
T V V
e Z n
K 2
κ
= ⋅
,
Electrochemical Capacitors (Supercapacitors)
Materials
- Electrodes: Activated carbon (porous) - Dielectric: Electric double layer
- Separator: Electric barrier (ex. glass paper) - Electrolyte: Sulfuric acid
Ultrahigh capacitance - ~ F
- Capacitance is directly proportional to the surface areas of plates.
(Surface area: 500 to 2500 m
2/g )- Charge separation distance (d): < 10 Å
+
+ -
- - - - - -
- - -
- - + + +
+ + +
+ + + + +
- - - - - - - -
- - + - + +
+ + + + + + +
Separator Electrode
(Current Collector)
Activated Carbon
Electrolyte
+ + + + + + + + + - - - - - - -
- -
+ + - - - + - - +
- - - - -
+ + +
+
Charged Discharged
Electrolyte
Comparison of Capacitor Technologies: Electrochemical Capacitor
Part I. Basics of Supercapacitors
What are Supercapacitors?
Also known as ultracapacitor or electrochemical capacitor
Very high capacitance (even ~ 1000 F)
- Molecularely thin dielectrics
- High surface area & nanostructured electrodes
High power density
Virtually unlimited number of charge-discharge cycles
No toxic substances as in conventional batteries
Electrode with electrolyte Electrode with electrolyte Separator
Current Collector Current Collector
Cross-Section of a Typical Supercapacitor
Ragone Plot of Energy Systems
• Activated carbon electrode
• Current collectors (positive and negative)
• Micro-porous separator
• Spiral-wound or prismatic
• Aqueous or non-aqueous electrolytes
Super- capacitor
M. Winter et al., Chem. Rev. (2004)
Batteries vs Supercapacitors
EDLC (Electrical Double Layer Capacitor) research is largely focused on increasing their energy performance and widening the temperature limits into the range where batteries cannot operate
Properties
Batteries Supercapacitors
Storage Mechanism Chemical Physical
Power Limitation Reaction kinetics &
mass transport Separator ionic conductivity
Energy Limitation Electrode mass Electrode surface area
Output Voltage Constant value Sloping value
(State-of-Charge (SOC) known precisely) Charge Rate Reaction kinetics &
mass transport Very high, same as discharge rate Cycle Life Limitations Physical stability &
chemical reversibility
No Limitation by electrochemical kinetics (not swollen in active material)
Life Limitation Thermodynamic stability No Limitation
Solvent Limitation Decomposition of electrolyte at high voltage or high temperature
No limitation of solvents
with high power performance at low temperatures (down to – 40 °C)
Li-Ion Batteries vs Supercapacitors
R. Miller et al., ECS Interface (2008)
* Time for discharge and charge of usable total energy stored in devices
** Power capability of battery for short duration partial discharge at 90% efficiency Characteristics State-of-the-Art
Li-ion Batteries Supercapacitors
*Charge Time ~ 3-5 min ~ 1 sec
*Discharge Time ~ 3-5 min ~ 1 sec
Cycle Life < 5,000 @ 1C rate > 500,000
Specific Energy (Wh/kg) 70 - 100 5
Specific Power
(kW/kg) **0.5 - 1 5 - 10
Cycle Efficiency (%) < 50% to > 90% < 75 to > 95%
Cost/Wh $ 1 - 2/Wh $10 - 20/Wh
Cost/kW $75 - 150/kW $25 - 50/kW
Taxonomy of Supercapacitors
Supercapacitors
Pseudo- Capacitors
ElectrochemicalDouble Layer Capacitors
Hybrid Capacitors
Carbon Nanotubes Activated
Carbons Conducting
Polymers Metal Oxides
Asymmetric
Hybrids Battery-Type Hybrids Composite
Hybrids
Carbon Aerogels
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
AC CNT
MPC C60 CAG NRC
PANI/AC
PEDT/AC PIThi
PFDT
PPy/AC MPFPT
DAAQ PAn/CNT
P3MT PEDT
PAn
RuO2/PAPPA
RuO2(sol-gel) RuO2(ED) RuO2(sol-gel) RuO2/AC RuO2/AC RuO2(ESD) RuO2/CB
RuO2/CNT RuO2/AC RuO2/CXG RuO2/MPC RuO2/AC
NiO SnO2 / Fe3O4 MnOx
NiO/RuO2
MnO2
NiO
Ti/RuOx/Co3O4
MnO2
Ir0.3Mn0.7O2
MnO2
Sp eci fi c Ca pa ci ta nce / F g
-1Carbons Polymers Metal Oxides RuO
2MPC: meso-porous carbon CAG: carbon aerogel NRC: nitrogen-rich carbon
PFPT: poly(fluorophenylthiophene) P3MT: poly(3-methylthiophene) PIThi: poly(isothianaphthene)
CXG: carbon xerogel CB: carbon black
PAn: polyaniline
( Literatures 2002~2006 )
ED: electrochemical deposition ESD: electrostatic spray deposition
Proposed Materials for Supercapacitors
Pseudo Capacitors
EDLCs
Part II. Electrochemical Double Layer Capacitors
V
-V
+Q
m-Q
m+Electrode Electrode
Electrolyte
+ + + + + - -
- - -
- - - - - +
+ + + +
Overview of Electrochemical Double Layer Capacitors (EDLCs)
There is no transfer of charge, non-Faradaic
Two carbon-based electrodes, aqueous or organic electrolyte
Electrode is made from porous nanostructures– activated carbon, nanotubes, aerogels
Schematic of ELDC
C
+C
-R
elR
+rxR
-rx1 1 1
C
t= C + C
+ −
+ +
=
+V C Q
mC Q V
− m−
=
−: Store the charge electrostatically using the reversible adsorption of ions of electrolyte onto active materials
Simplified Electric Circuit
Models for Double Layer Structure
Stern Model
Helmholtz Model Gouy-Chapman Model
– No Debye layer (ρ = 0) – Voltage jump at interface
(“dipole layer”)
– Constant differential capacitance
– Finite Debye length (“double layer”) – Parabolic differential
capacitance
– Linear voltage adjacent to electrode
– Parabolic differential capacitance with “wings”
– IHP : Inner Helmholtz Layer – OHP : Outer Helmholtz Layer
Conway BE., “Electrochemical Supercapacitors – Scientific Fundamentals and Technological Applications”, Kluwer Academic/Plenum (1999).
d dV
C
ddQ ε
rε
0=
=
−
= kT
eV exp Z
] i [ ] i [
s 0 i
D H
d
C
1 C
1 C
1 = +
]0i
[ : bulk ion concentration Zi : charge of ions
Vs : potential in solution
V I
∆V
1
E. Frackowiak et al., Carbon (2001)
where Ι : current
(dV/dt) : potential scan rate C : double layer capacitance
Typical Charge/Discharge Voltammogram
1 - ideal capacitor
2 - capacitor with resistivity
3 - capacitor with carbon material 4 - influence of redox reactions
∆V - voltage delay Ic - capacitive current
dt C dV
I = ×
Sign of current is immediately reversed upon the reversal of potential sweep
Current is independent of potential (i.e., purely electrostatic)
Cyclic Voltammogram 1
* Capacitive Current: current (or current density) flowing through an electrochemical cell (It only causes accumulation (or removal) of electrical charges (not chemical reaction) on the electrode and in the electrolyte solution near the electrode)
V I
∆V
Typical Charge/Discharge Voltammogram
E. Frackowiak et al., Carbon (2001)
R I = V
2
, A
R = ρ l Cyclic Voltammogram 2
1 - ideal capacitor
2 - capacitor with resistivity
3 - capacitor with carbon material 4 - influence of redox reactions
∆V - voltage delay Ic - capacitive current
: resistance,
ρ
: resistivityR
Resistivity is an inherent property of material
Unit of resistivity is ohm-meter
V I
∆V
1 - ideal capacitor
2 - capacitor with resistivity
3 - capacitor with carbon material (EDLCs) 4 - influence of redox reactions
∆V - voltage delay Ic - capacitive current
Typical Charge/Discharge Voltammogram
E. Frackowiak et al., Carbon (2001)
3
Cyclic Voltammogram 3
• Special oxidation of carbon for increasing the surface functionality (through chemical treatment, electrochemical polarization)
• Formation of carbon/conducting polymers
composites by electropolymerization of a suitable monomer (aniline or pyrrole)
• Insertion of electroactive particles of transition metals oxides such RuO2, TiO2, Cr2O3, MnO2, Co2O3 into the carbon materials
Enhancement of specific capacitance for cabon materials by:
V I
∆V
Cyclic Voltammogram 4
Typical Charge/Discharge Voltammogram 4
E. Frackowiak et al., Carbon (2001)
1 - ideal capacitor
2 - capacitor with resistivity
3 - capacitor with carbon material 4 - influence of redox reactions (pseudocapacitor)
∆V - voltage delay Ic - capacitive current
* Voltage Delay (∆V): time interval at the start of a discharge during which the working voltage of a cell is below its steady value
: scan rate (dV/dt)
: surface concentration of reactant
C
1s
I
pcRT s VnF
C K
RT VnF
C K RT
nF
I q ⋅
− +
= −
21 1
1 1 1
)}
/ (
exp {
) /
( exp
RT s nF I
pc= q ⋅
4
1
q
1 : amount of charge to form a monolayerStrategy for High Energy Density
2
2 ) 1
( E CV
Energy =
Capacitance (C) Voltage (V)
• Surface area & pore size control
• Internal & external resistance ↓
• Wettability ↑
• Introduce of hetero-atoms
• Electrode density ↑
• Asymmetric cell (Hybrid capacitor)
• Electrochemical activation
• Electrolyte
- Aqueous : 1.2 V - Organic : over 2.5 V
• Purification and additives
• Protective coating of the electrode
• Asymmetric cell (Hybrid capacitor)
Porous Carbon Materials
Carbons
Category Representative Materials
Porous Carbons
Activated Carbons
steam-activated carbons alkali-activated carbons
Template Carbons Carbon Aerogel, Xeogels
LiF-Activated Carbons
Nanocarbons
CNTs(single-walled & multi-walled)
C60s
Carbon Nanohorns
* Graphenes (most recently)
Activated Carbon
Electrode Material (Activated Carbon I)
Large surface area (500 ~ 2500 m
2/g)
Optimized pore structure
Low resistance
Electrochemically stable
・Rechargeable at high temperature
・Wettable with solvents
Activated Carbon
Conducting Agents
+
BinderAdsorped ions (anions, cations)
Solvents
Micro pores (< 2 nm) Meso pores (2 ~ 50 nm) Macro pores
( > 50 nm)
Activation
CO
2CO
Gas Activation Activation by Reagents
Alkaline metal (KOH)
Zinc chloride, Phosphate, etc.
Steam
C+H2O→CO+H2 C+2H2O→CO2+2H2
Carbon dioxide
C+CO2→2CO
Oxygen
C+O2→CO2 2C+O2→2CO
4C+K2SO4→K2S+4CO
for high surface area
Pore
Electrode Material (Activated Carbon II)
Porous Carbon Materials (Graphene)
Chemically Modified Graphene (CMG) Particle Electrode Surface
Cyclic Voltammogram
Nearly Rctangular in Shape
Good charge propagation within the electrodes
Insensitive to varying voltage scan rates (short and equal diffusion path length of ions in electrolyte)
R. Ruoff et al., Nano Lett. (2008)
Measured conductivity of these CMG materials (∼ 2 × 10
2S/m) closely approaches that of pristine graphite
Synthesis process: suspension of graphene oxide (GO) sheets in water reduction using
hydrazine hydrate
During reduction, individual “graphene” sheets
agglomerate into particles of approx 15-25 μm in
diameter (surface area of CMG agglomerates: 705
m
2/g)
O. Barbieri et al., Carbon (2005).
micro pore
meso pore macro pore
d < 2 nm
2 < d < 50 nm d > 50 nm
活性炭の細孔と容量の限界
Gravimetric capacitance / F g-1
Specific surface area S
BET/ m
2g
-1 Capacitance vs Specific Surface Area
0 0 1000 2000 3000
20 40 60 80 100 120
Pore Distribution Control & Capacitance Limitations
High Surface Area NOT Necessarily Lead to High Capacitance over S
BET> 1700 ~ 2000 m
2g
-1Optimum
Surface Area
Pore Size & Pore Size Distribution
Sub-Micro
Pore (< 0.5 nm) Micro Pore
(0.5 ~ 2 nm) Meso Pore
(2 ~ 50 nm) Macro Pore (> 50 nm)
Pores with different size have different time constants
R
iand C
ican be treated as resistance and capacitance of pores with a certain pore size ; R
iC
iwhich gives the unit of time, RC = (V/I)(I∙t/V)= t (time)
Indicating how fast pores of a certain size can be accessed
A well balanced micro- or mesoporosity was needed to maximize capacitance
Transmission Line Equivalent Circuit Model
Hydrated IonH. Shi, Electrochim. Acta (1995)
E. Frackowiak et al., Electrochim. Acta (2005)
• Zones I & II : Electric Wire-in-Cylinder Capacitor in Solvent-Free Electrolyte
• Zone III : Electric Double-Cylinder Capacitor (EDCC)
• Zone IV : Planar Electric Double Layer Capacitor (EDLC)
Current Issues for Carbon Materials
Specific Capacitance as a Function of Pore Size
=
0 0
ln /
a b b A
C
ε
rε
−
=
d b b b A
C r
ln
/ ε ε
0Y. Gogotsi et al., Science (2006)
J. Huang et al., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. (2008)
a0 : effective size of unsolvated ion b: pore radius
d: distance of approach of ion to carbon surface
A, B: templated mesoporous carbons; C: activated mesoporous carbons; D, F: microporous CDCs ; E: microporous activated carbons
Partial or complete removal of the
solvation shell and increased confinement of ions leads to increased capacitance.
• High surface area and double layer of charge allows for much higher energy densities than conventional capacitors, with comparable power densities
• No chemical or structural change during charge storage up to 10
6cycles for supercaps compared with 10
3cycles for batteries
• Work in extreme temperature and very safe
• Nanostructured carbon materials are relatively cheap and fabrication techniques are well developed
Advantages:
• Cannot match energy densities of mid-level batteries Disadvantages:
Advantages & Disadvantages of EDLCs
Part III. Pseudocapacitors
Overview of Pseudocapacitors
• Charge transfer through surface Faradaic, redox
reactions• Similar to EDLCs, but electrodes are made from
metal-oxides or conducting polymers- Generally, lower power densities than EDLCs
- Cycle life can be limited by mechanical stress caused during the reduction-oxidation reactions - Negatively charged conducting polymer electrodes are not very efficient
- Best metal-oxide electrodes are very expensive and require aqueous electrolytes, implying lower voltage
• Advantages:
• Disadvantages
Current Voltage
Current Voltage
- Electrolyte ions diffuse into pores and undergo fast, reversible surface reactions
- Relationship between charge and potential gives rise to a pseudocapacitance
- Can achieve very high capacitances & energies
High surface area and fast Faradaic reactions allow for higher energy densities than EDLCs (Hydrous Ruthenium Oxide can achieve extraordinary capacitance)
+
-
Ru O O (IV) Ru OH
O (III) Ru OH
OH
(II)
chargedischarge
charge
discharge
Ru O O (IV) Ru OH
O (III) Ru OH
OH (II)
Redox of RuO 2
Stable Redox Reaction of RuO 2
V
Ca pa ci ta nc e
Part IV. Hybrid Capacitors
Hybrid Capacitors
Hypothetical Energy-Power Behavior
Technologies must be decoupled to effectively exploit the combination
Specific Energy
Specific Power
Technology 1 Combination of Tech 1 & 2 Technology 2
Symmetric
Double layer
+
- - - - - + + + + +
_
ele ct ro ly te
Q
Lower Limit Upper Limit
Potential / V
+ -
Q
Lower Limit
Upper Limit +
- Double layer
+ + + + ele ct ro ly te
_ +
Battery Electrode
Asymmetric
Potential / V
−
∞ +
= C
C
t1 1
1
Doubling capacitance of carbon electrode over symmetric device (battery)
(capacitor)
Design of Hybrid Capacitors & Advantages
Charging-Discharging Principle of a Hybrid Capacitor
“Pre-Doping” System:
Doping anode with Li-metal before charging-discharging
a cell
• Doubling capacitance of carbon electrode over symmetric device
• Higher operating voltage than symmetric device
• Voltage self-balance in series strings
• Very high specific energy and energy density demonstrated
• Response times of 2 to 100 seconds typical
Part V. Needs and Applications of Supercapacitors
Supercapacitor Technology Needs
Increase cell operating voltage to: > 4.0 V with RC < 1 s, high cycle life electrode/electrolyte system
Use lower cost design — exploit anomalous capacitance observed in asymmetric aqueous electrolyte ECs
Use electrolyte additive to reduce drying costs and control other impurities
• Lower Cost Cells
• Longer Life Cells
• Higher Cycle Efficiency Cells
Well-sealed cells always fail with package rupture (except valved caps)
Use electrolyte additive to prevent or control gas generation
Devise more effective ways for removing impurities
Carbon composite electrode may obviate current collector in asymmetrics
Higher conductivity electrolyte
Thinner, more open separator
Resistances need to be reduced everywhere
Many Potential Applications
Emergency Power Back-Up
Peak Power Load Leveling
& Energy Saving Line-Drop
Protection
HONDA “FCX Concept”
Startup and Acceleration
Ultra-capacitor assists the fuel cell stack to achieve crisp, responsive performance
Deceleration
Ultra-capacitor recovers the energy released during deceleration and stores it along with power from the fuel cell stack
Stopped
Auto idle stop system shuts off output from fuel cell stack to reduce fuel consumption. Electricity required to operate the other components is supplied by the ultra-capacitor
http://world.honda.com/FuelCell/FCX/overview/
Ultracapacitor Emergency Power Module for Wind Turbines
http://www.rell.com/resources/
With no moving parts, ultracapacitors provide a simple, solid state, highly reliable solution to buffer short-term mismatches between power available and power required.
Examples
Support Material 1: What is Capacitance?
• Capacitance (C): capability for charge storage per voltage (unit: farads) * Capacity: used in battery terminology to indicate the extent of Faradaic charge storage (coulombs or watt-hours)
Q = ε
rε
0V/d
where ε
ris the electrolyte dielectric constant, ε
0is the dielectric constant of the vacuum, V is the voltage, and d is the electrode distance
C/A = Q/V, C = ε
rε
oA / d where A is the surface area
2 Q 2
0
2 CV 1 C
Q 2 dq 1 C
q = =
∫
Capacitance (C) = Q/V
dW = (q / C)dq, W
charging(E)=
(Moving a small element of charge dq from one plate to the other against the potential difference V = q/C requires the work dW)
Support Material 2. Equivalent Series Resistance & P
max• Equivalent Series Resistance (ESR) : all physical devices (such as capacitors or inductors) constructed of materials with finite electrical resistance,
implying that physical components contain some resistance in addition to their other properties
Non-Ideal Capacitor with Series Resistor
) ESR (
I V V =
i−
•
) ESR (
I IV
P =
i−
2(this is a maximum when, ) dP / dI = 0 = V
i− 2 I ( ESR ) (where, V
i= initial potential)
) ESR (
4 / V I
V P
2 / V )
ESR ) (
ESR (
2 V V
) ESR (
I V V
) ESR (
2 / V I
2 i p
. max p
. max max
i i
i i
p . max
i p
. max
=
×
=
∴
=
−
=
−
=
=
∴
Support Material 3. Potential Sweep Methods
Linear Sweep Voltammetry (LSV)
Cyclic Voltammetry (CV)
: current at a working electrode is measured while the potential between the working electrode and a reference electrode is swept linearly in time
* Voltammetry
: An electrochemical measuring technique used for electrochemical analysis or for the determination of the kinetics and mechanism of electrode reactions.
: a linear-sweep voltammetry with the scan continued in the reverse direction at the end of the first scan, this cycle can be repeated a number of times.
: voltage cycle is defined by four parameters
the maximum and minimum voltages, the starting
voltage, and the initial direction of scan (to more + or
to more – voltage values).
Support Material 4. Physics of Double Layer
Diffuse layer of charge carriers at the interface
) exp(
] [ ]
[
0kT eV i Z
i
s
−
i=
Electrolytic Capacitor
The total charge per unit volume in the diffuse layer
e Z i x
Q
i∑
i= [ ] )
(
According to Poisson’s Equation,
) exp(
] [
00 2
2
kT eV Z Z
e i dx
V
d
i si i
s
−
− ⋅
= ε ε ∑
Boundary conditions
= 0
∞
= sx
V = 0
∞ x= s
dx
, dV
[i]: Bulk Ion concentration Zi: Charge of Ions
e: Charge of Electron
Vs: Potential in the Solution
ε : Electrolyte Dielectric Constant ε0: Dielectric Constant of the Vacuum
Potential (V) Profile in the Diffuse Layer
χ
=
−κ
κ
Ks 0 s
) e T 4 / ZeV tanh(
) T 4 / ZeV
tanh(
21
0 2 2 0
T V V
e Z n
K 2
κ
= ⋅
,
) ) 1 exp( ( )
exp(
) 1
(
11
1
RT
k VnF RT
C VnF nF k
I
net= − θ β −
−θ − − β
: transfer coefficient) /
exp(
1
) / exp(
1 1
1 1
RT VnF
C K
RT VnF
C K
= + θ
at Equilibrium Condition (Inet=0)
s RT RT VnF
nF RT
VnF C
K
C K dt
d ⋅
−
= + exp( / )
)}
/ (
exp
{
1 1 21
θ
1: scan rate
RT s VnF
C K
RT VnF
C K RT
nF q dt
q d
I ⋅
− +
= −
=
∴
21 1
1 1 1
1
{ exp ( / )}
) / (
θ exp
Peak Current of Pseudocapacitor
0
&
0
22
=
= dt
d dt
dI θ
RT s nF I
pc= q ⋅
4
1
Support Material 5. Peak Current of Pseudocapacitor
θ
β
1 1 1
= k / k
−K
dt s = dV θ
d q Idt
dQ = =
1 : amount of chargeto form a monolayer : surface coverage
q
1dt q d
I θ
=
1∴
Butler-Volmer equation By redox rxn at the surface
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
by eqn.(1) nF
I0
) 1
1(
1 θ
ν = Ck − rxn rate