www.koreanglaucoma.org
17
9ROXPH_1XPEHU
ৢߜܾࣳઊٻৌң֢ஷѿહઌടҋઊച
ഡפֳણ൝ઘਁ़ؘࣳीહௗݑݴӋܱനৡഡد֯ஷ Ԟഡ़ीહௗݑؘد৩ടކെથפֳણઅ़ीહௗݑܾ
ࣳއઊ१രٻӋઔؘҫࣼ੭ૂीӘࠒ़੭ણௗࣘ
ीઊدفࡘ࡚અीઘڝ़ीઊചഡפֳણ൝ઘઅઍୱહ
ௗݑܾࣼ੭ૂीࣷടؘٙԓѿણిઊ੭ؘࣼ੭
ૂीઊ५ೂഡઊ൲ਁؘࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी१രഢ़ઔކ
ࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઊऀӖહઊ߆ഢӄੌਁؘد१ࣼ੭
ૂी१രടؘҫઊඩڝԞڹߚઊ܅ӋࣥҀനࡆ़ઔدԓܟ
ܾ߳ऀӖઅѿ؟ऀઊઔدࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीࡂدؘࣼ੭
ૂीઊًࣷٻӋઔ੶ࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीدݳௗ
ѿѿ؟ഢڹ१രട٩ܿઊୱહઌௗݑࠒ੶ܾ֪Һڂؘӄ ലઊઔدടކࡻܿણԞҁઅӄӘӚ୵ઊചടҸކமԕ
ࠋٻӋઔؘد৩ഡઑࣛӴਁࣳࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઍୱ
़ीܾࣷടؘҫ٩ട֢અࣷઊٽ़ઔدؘҿӘڝઊࠋ
ٻӋઔ੶़ीઊചഡפֳણ൝ઘਁࣳࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी
ࣷടؘҫ़ीઘઅӄസӘࣷ٩ਁگݳࣷઊٽ़ઔ د५ૂܾഡࡂӋਁઅടךਁؘ߸ӵਁࣳਁӘട
َࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઅࡻૻઊךਁؘܾѿടਔ د
֯ஷԞഡפֳણ़ीܾࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीҿ
ીടӋ१രതਁઔৰ़ीઅऀӖനѿણޣસӋܱനৡഢ
ҫ़ी൲Ԟਁࠋࣥഢ़ઔؘસӘ़ी൲ৰؖી٩
१ҁઊӄӘഡ൲ࠋࣥഢ़ઔؘӋઊدࠒ़੭ણௗઅસ ധઊா࡚ട߆ഢӄੌࠒ़ѿ֢ௗҲއઊ੭پ੶ܾঅસ
ࠒघ५ڢઅഥ࠾ઊࠋࣥഢ़ઔ੶़ी൲़ѿ
ӄӘടҲٻࠒ़੭ણௗઅSODWHܾઽୱહઌࣼ੭൛ѿ
ઊݗৰࣳࠒ़੭ી٩ݴҿીടؘસധऀઅ࠸੶ܾઙੋ
ടҲټدؘҫઊدઊܟഡࣼ੭ऀ֮೩ѿࣥऀٻԞઌ़ी
Ԟਁؘࠒ़ѿ֢ௗҲࢉݼ੭ٻৰસ੶ܾઌഡഥ࠾ઊ
ࠋࣥഢ़ઔ੶़ी൲१ҁઊӄӘതਁگ܅֮೩ѿൌऀٻ
ࠒ़੭ઊৰڝࣳா࡚ഡઊٽ़ઔدؘҫ
ࠉڙ१ࣥҀടӋ൝ઘѿ़ी൲Ԟਁસҽڨ़ઔؘࣛ
ൠઌԓݼӋણԞહઌৰؖી٩ઌਁگ܅ࠒ़੭
ણௗࣘीҿીനৡഡد
ӯӘࣳહઌࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઅહࣔೞࡂ)LJXUH
ਁࣳਭҎઊDQWLPHWDEROLWHѿ࣏ੋٻԞઊਁؘߗ़ીஔ
़ીஔਁࣳઅפֳણҿޅઅ७ഡࣼ੭ऀࠉඕઊઔڹ೩ ٩ޅਐ੶ܾઌഡઊୱऀפֳણ३ࣥേӚפֳણҀޅઊ२ीઊ
൲ࠋࣥഡפֳણࣷऀפֳણLULGRFRUQHDOG\VWURSKLHVԓݼ Ӌઊઅפֳણ़ीઊ५ೂടਔڹી٩ܾӵഡٻৰઔৼ੶
֢ࣼ੭ૂीਁDQWLPHWDEROLWHѿ࣏ੋٻৰऀӖݬઊৈ
ࣳહઊ)LJXUHਁࣳਭҎઊًӵഡٻৼد
नࢤആҙ֣ղ /7(
ઍࠉહઌৢߜௗݑਭܩઊસௗݑਁࠉടৌؘ19*൝ઘਁ
ઔৰࣳࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઊ੭ੋടدӋ্ܱઔ੶ಡඥ
ࣼ੭ૂीઊ५ೂഡઊ൲ਁؘࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीੌࣷહ
੶ܾӋܱനৡഡدӋ্ܱઔد7VDL-&HWDO2SKWKDOPRORJ\
$KPHGYDOYHਭ0ROWHQRLPSODQWઅ़ी൲ऀӖݬ
ਁؘࣛفહ੶ܾ੶़֢ी൲१ҁઊ֪ਁگ܅ઽઽऀӖ ಡଙפֳણઅ࠾ઌଔزௗݑ
,QGLFDWLRQVIRU*ODXFRPD,PSODQW6XUJHU\
થ൙
ᦥᵝݡ⦺Ʊ᮹ŝݡ⦺ᦩŝ⦺Ʊᝅ
Fig. 1. ࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઅહઅ࠹൛
Journal of The Korean Glaucoma Society
JOURNAL OF THE KOREAN GLAUCOMA SOCIETY 18
ݬઊۅৰҿӘѿৌدӋࡂӋٻৼد%DHUYHOGWLPSODQW
ਊ१19*અௗݑਁઔৰࣳ൭Әહઊކ઼൝ઘ़֢ी१
ܲઊৌӄੌ੭ણௗࣘीઊ५ೂഢѿ؟ऀઊًد 6LGRWL3$HWDO2SKWKDOPRORJ\19*൝ઘઅӄੌ੭ݼஔ
ૂी१രഡӄੌࡘݴ౿ഡࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઊ़
ीઅऀӖݬઊؘٙ٩ઊټد
"QILJDBOE1TFVEPQIBLJDFZF
़ીஔਁࡻനߗ़ીஔԓݼӋઌӖ़ીஔӋ२હ ઌࣼ੭ૂीઅऀӖݬઊ֯ҫ੶ܾઝ্ܱઔدߗ़
ીஔӘઌӖ़ીஔਁࣳҀפֳણ़ीઅऀӖݬࡻӯ ടਔڹࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઅऀӖݬઊࣼ੭ૂ
ीࡂد੶:LOOLDP$HWDO2SKDOPRORJ\
ךݼڙކڢ0ROWHQRણௗݴઊੋനඔઌઌӖ़ીஔԓ ݼӋߗ़ીஔ൝ઘਁҲࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी१രടਔӋ
ґਖ਼ପऀӖݬ܅ӋࡂӋടਔد)UHHGPDQ-HWDO$UFK
2SKWKDOPRO
6WFJUJD(MBVDPNB
೩ ٩ ޅ ਐ ਁ ٳ ࠉ ټ פ ֳ ણ અ ӄ ੌ ࣼ ੭ ૂ ी
DQWLPHWDEROLWHݴ࣏ੋടৌӄੌऀӖݬઊۅৰؘҫ੶ܾ
্ܱઔ੶7RZOHU+0HWDO2FXODU,PPXQRO,QIODPP ಡඥघऀӚਐӘٳࠉټ೩٩ޅਐઊ֢ઊઅࣼ੭ૂी
ઊ५ೂഡӄੌߗ़ીஔ५ݼఒਠઍઊ࣏ੋٻৼَԓݼӋ
३ࣥേӚઊઔؘӄੌਁؘࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी१രടؘҫઊ
ًدӋ্ܱઔد8YHLWLF*ODXFRPD൝ઘਁ࣏ࣳੋټࠒ़
੭ણௗؘ$KPHGYDOYH0ROWHQRLPSODQW%DHUYHOGWLPSODQW
ਁࣳڂઊઝٻৼدӋࡂӋٻৼد0ROWHQR$&HWDO
2SKWKDOPRORJ\&HEDOORV(0HWDO2SKWKDOPRORJ\
'D0DWD$HWDO2SKWKDOPRORJ\
$POHFOJUBM(MBVDPNB
െથԪࡂӋټࠅਁઅടৰݾઊਁࣳઅӋ२હઌࣼ੭
ૂीઅऀӖݬਁܾࣳऀઌਁࡻന֯ҫ੶্ܾܱ
ઔ੶:DOODFHHWDO2SKWKDOPRORJ\*UHVVHOHWDO
2SKWKDOPRORJ\JRQLRWRP\֢WUDEHFXORWRP\ѿ५ೂഡӄ
ੌԓݼӋ,ULGRFRUQHDOG\VJHQHVLV$QLULGLD$SKDNLD6WXUJH
:HEHUV\QGURPHઊઔؘӄੌਁؘࠒ़੭ણௗࣘीઊًࣷ
ٻӋઔد$QWLPHWDEROLWHVؘघৈਁࣳઅന࣏ࣳੋനৡട
़ؘٙी൲१ҁઊӄӘതਁگ܅ਉӘ೩਼࠸ઊৈଖ़ઔ
Table 1.$KPHGYDOYHਭ0ROWHQRLPSODQWઅણԞહઌऀӖݬࡻӯ
1 year 2 year 3 year 4 year 5 year
Ahmed valve 63.2% 56.2% 43.2% 37.8% 25.2%
Molteno implant 37.0% 29.6% 29.6% 29.6% 29.6%
<DOYDFHWDO(\H
Table 2.,QWUDRFXODUSUHVVXUHDQGPHGLFDOWKHUDS\LQWKH7XEH9HUVXV7UDEHFXOHFWRP\6WXG\
Tube group Trabeculectmoy P -value
Baseline
IOP (mmHg) 25.1 ± 5.3 25.6 ± 5.3 0.56
Glaycina medications 3.2 ± 1.1 3.0 ± 1.2 0.17
1 year
IOP (mmHg) 12.5 ± 3.9 12.7 ± 5.8 0.73
Glaycina medications 1.3 ± 1.3 0.5 ± 0.9 <0.001
2 year
IOP (mmHg) 13.4 ± 4.8 12.1 ± 5.0 0.101
Glaycina medications 1.3 ± 1.3 0.8 ± 1.2 0.016
3 year
IOP (mmHg) 13.0 ± 4.9 13.3 ± 6.8 0.78
Glaycina medications 1.3 ± 1.3 1.0 ± 1.5 0.30
4 year
IOP (mmHg) 13.5 ± 5.4 12.9 ± 6.1 0.58
Glaycina medications 1.4 ± 1.4 1.2 ± 1.5 0.33
5 year
IOP (mmHg) 14.4 ± 6.9 12.6 ± 5.9 0.12
Glaycina medications 1.4 ± 1.3 1.2 ± 1.5 0.23
www.koreanglaucoma.org
19
9ROXPH_1XPEHU
ӋԓܾઌനਉӘ೩ਐ֢ৈѿֳਐઊࣥԢ़ઔԞڹߚઊد
%HFNڢઅࡂӋਁઅടಡඥंઊടઅ൝ઘਁࣳࣼ੭ૂ
ीઅऀӖݬઊ़ी൲ךପਁؘךପਁؘܾঅࠒ़
੭ણௗਁࡻനെસඥ֯د%HFNHWDO$P-2SKWKDOPRO
1SFWJPVT(MBVDPNBTVSHFSZ
פֳણ़ीઊઅӴ़ीܾઌന੯ࡘҿޅਁࣛࠉઊ
੭ࠋٻৰࣼ੭ऀࠉඕઊࣥԞࣼ੭ૂीઅऀӖݬઊെસ ඥۅৰҲټدࠒ़੭ણௗؘઊઅࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी
ઊ५ೂഡڎਁ٩Ӌܱഢ़ઔ़ؘٙीࡘઅࣼ੭൛ѿࠋࣥ
ടܾ߳ҎTXDGUDQWਁد१ࣘടࣼ੭൛ࠉઊ੍ًҋ ടҲࠋࣥടܾ߳ࠉڙ१دݳTXDGUDQWݴઊੋടਉࠒ़੭ણ
ௗࣘी࣏ੋനৡഡدҁ3LJJ\EDFNJODXFRPDLPSODQW
ݴӋܱഢ़٩ઔؘٙઊؘӴઅڛTXDGUDQWѿࣼ੭൛
ઊઅ ࠒ़੭ણௗࣘी ڢ੶ܾ ़ीਁ હഥട ߆ട
&\FORSKRWRFRDJXODWLRQઅહ٩ٻৌؘ൝ઘਁࣳӋܱന
ࡆ़ઔد3HGLDWULFVL]HGJODXFRPDLPSODQWݴઊ़ीഡࣼ
੭൛ټਉӘ೩ୄ੶ܾࣘടӴٳણѿࡽࠤടҲࠋࣥ
ഢ़ઔ੶ܾ߳৩१ѿ੭ٻӋઔؘ൝ઘਁؘࣳ३ૻടҲҿ
ીനৡഡد
1BUJFOUSFRVJSJOHB,1
ઊமفৢߜௗݑܾٻӋઔؘ൝ઘਁࣳ.3ݴ१ രടҲٻ़ी൲ઊٻפֳણઊࡽࠤടҲ൛ ٻؘҫࡆ़ઔدઊܟഡӄੌࣼ੭ૂीࡂدؘ.3ਭٳ १ਁࠒ़੭ણௗࣘӋܱനৡട़ी൲७Ҁഡસ
੶ܾઌനҀޅઊ२ઊ५ೂടؘҫޅԞന9DOYHѿઔؘࠒ़
੭ણௗݴࣷടؘҫઊد
5SBCFDVMFDUNPZWT"INFE(MBVDPNB7BMWF
ך:LOVRQઅ൝ઘݴفࣛ੶ܾࣼ੭ૂीӘ
$KPHGࠒ़੭ણௗઅऀӖݬࡻӯടؘઑࣛӴݴ१രടਉ
ࠋടਔؘٙઊઊടܾٻң֢ઊࣛઅടҋ
ऀӖઊ܅Ӌીઅടਔڹڂ़ीਭܾࡻ॥ഡऀ
Ӗݬࡂਔކ$KPHGJURXSਁࣳஷѿહઌҋടݴഡ
ৢߜௗݑѿًചഡҫ੶ܾ֢ౌ֭د१രഡ़ीઊઍୱ़ीઊ ৼؘৈإઊઅ़ीܾઊٻৌৈୱܾ१രഡ
़ीઊৼ़ؘؘी൲ऀӖݬઅୱઊਁਕലࡂઊৌد
ԓݼӋךڎࠋټણԞ)8GDWDਁࣳ٩ڂԓݜਁ
ઔৰࣳୱઊݴࡂઊৌد:LOVRQHWDO
5VCFWT5SBCFDVMFDUPNZ4UVEZ
7XEHYV7UDEHFXOHFWRP\6WXG\ؘ797VWGX\JURXSਁઅ ന ࣼ੭ ૂीӘ %DHUYHOGW ,PSODQWઅ ऀӖݬ ࡻӯഡ
PXOWLFHQWHUFOLQLFDOWULDOܾঅઍୱऀؘۙ19*೩٩ޅਐڢਐ
੶ܾઌഡӄੌݴૂ਼ഡઊୱऀפֳણ൝ઘݴفࣛ੶ܾട ਔ੶ઊਁࣼ੭ૂीઊ५ೂടਔң֢ࠕֳણ़ीࠊ
़ीԞਵܲઊઔؘ൝ઘݴߗઙܾ%DHUYHOGWLPSODQWRU
WUDEZLWK00&PJPO[PLQXWHVӶ੶ܾ֢ৰࠔીട ਉך$-2ਁࡂӋټઊܑךךԓݼӋךਁך
)8GDWDѿࠋٻৼدӴઅҿӘݴৢടدӘҎ د797VWXG\JURXS$P-2SKWKDOPRO
ךҁઅ)8ԞҁӋࡂڹڂ़ीࠩڂா࡚ഡ
ҋട൭Әݴ৴़ઔৼدࡻ़ܿी൲ґਖ਼ਁؘࣼ
੭ૂीӶઅઊെસടҲ֯ކґਖ਼ڎࡘౡؘڂ
Ӷҁઅୱઊݴࠋҽഢ़৺ৼدસઘڝઊઅӴਁࣳࠒ
़੭ણௗࣘीઅऀӖݬઊًَ֯ҫܾفࣛ൝ઘࣷ
ਁઔৰࣳઅݼതӋܱടৌӋ࡚ࣴടਔԞڹߚઊ܅Ӌࣹ
ടӋઔد797VWXG\ਁؘࣳߗઙܾ൝ઘѿҀӶਁࠔીٻৼ Ӌ19*$SKDNLDLQIODPPDWRU\QGDU\JODXFRPDڢઊفࣛਁ
ࣳૂ਼ٻৰࡂ౿੭ણௗݴӋܱടҲٻؘ൝ઘઅӄੌࡂدفࣛ
൝ઘઅ5LVNIDFWRUѿ֯੶ಉҀޅґݴ౿ഡࠕֳણ़ी
१രഡ൝ઘކفࣛ੶ܾടਔدઊਁસઘڝفࣛ൝ઘࣷਁ
ઔৰࣳઅݼതઊ৺دڂ़ीણԞહ੶ܾࡻ॥ഡ
൭ӘݴѿଔدӋҿֳ݀ݼӋઔد
़ी൲ךҁࠒ़੭ણௗࣘӶਁࣳ
ന੭અടҲًއടҋૂѿചടਔކًણԞહ੶ܾ
Ӛ୵ടਔڹڂӶҁਁୱઊݴࡂઊৌد़ी൲ࠒ़੭
ણௗࣘӶਁࣳചഡҋടૂઅ़ؘి࠹൛ݴࡂઊ
ৌࠉךઊӄӘടࣳࣼ੭ૂीӶਁًࣳއҋ ടૂѿചടҲٻࣳךପࡘౡؘڂӶҁઅୱઊѿ৺ৰد
ऀӖݬઊৈا५ೂݴԞ੶ܾࣔೞࡂڹࣼ੭ૂी
Ӷࠒ़੭ણௗӶࡂد़ًी५ೂੰࡂਔد,23⾚
PP+JԓݼӋUHGXFHG,23OHVVWKDQ५ೂ܅Ӌીട ਔڹહ५ೂੰךପਁࣼ੭ૂीӶਁࣳԓݼӋ
੭ણௗӶਁܾࣳ੭અഡୱઊݴࡂਔد५ૂ़ी൲൝ ઘਁҲചഡઊࡂدً֯੶ܾ߳५ೂઅԞً
Journal of The Korean Glaucoma Society
JOURNAL OF THE KOREAN GLAUCOMA SOCIETY 20
֯ஷৰPP+Jࠅճৼڹ٩ࣼ੭ૂीӶਁࣳԓݼ Ӌ੭ણௗӶਁܾࣳ੭અഡୱઊݴࡂਔ੶PP+Jܾ
֯ஷৼڹਁ٩ࣼ੭ૂीӶਁࣳԓݼӋ੭ણௗӶ
ਁܾࣳ੭અഡୱઊݴࡂਔد
ךପહથ़ीࡻੰ੭ણௗӶਁࣳࣼ੭ૂी
Ӷਁܾࣳࣼ੭ૂीӶਁًࣳد
१ܲ%DVHOLQHӘ़ी൲ךӄӘ१ઽਁࣳڂڂӶਁࣳ
ୱઊݴࡂઊৌد
़ी൲ഥ࠾ࣔೞࡂڹഡشࣼ੭ૂीӶ
ਁًࣳഥ࠾ઊࠋҽٻৼ੶֢شઊ൲ךԪ़ी൲Ԟ
ഥ࠾ਁؘࣳڂӶҁୱઊݴࡂઊৌ੶ന़ी
ઊചഢી٩ઊң֢१ܲઅെસഡ҆घݴઍ੶ేކుૻഡഥ
࠾અࠋࣥ٩ڂӶҁਁୱઊݴࡂઊৌد:RXQGOHDNV
EOHEOHDNV҆Ҁઊࣛڢઅഥ࠾ࣼ੭ૂीӶਁࣳඕട
़ी൲Ӵٳણڢઅഥ࠾੭ણௗӶਁࣳد
797VWXG\ؘઊઅӴਁࡻന੭ણௗࣘीઅ੭ੋऀઊ
އઊࡘҀٻৼؘٙ&DSULOROLؘસઘڝઊҁӘടਔң֢פֳણ़
ीӋܱ१797VWXG\ਁઅനؘࣳٻؘઊ੭ਁفനدӘ
ҎઊԞीടਔؘٙࠒ़੭ણௗؘܾ/RZWHHQઊടઅ
৴ԞඩڝԞڹߚਁௐਁࣳࣼ੭ૂीࡂد੭ણ
ௗؘੌ़ടدӋഢ़৺੶797VWXG\ਁࣳܣ7UDEઅഥ࠾
ઊًৌ੶ಡඥ%DHUYHOGW੭ણௗਁًࣳއઊࠋࣥ
ടؘӴٳણؘޓੌ७Ҁഡߚૂݴ੭ࠋടஷહӚ୵Ԟ ҁઊࡘઙੋӘऀӖݬץടԞਁৈଓତ੶7XEHHURVLRQڢ
ણԞહ੶ܾࠋࣥഢ़ઔؘഥ࠾ઊਉඥથഡدۙഡفࣛ
൝ઘؘࠕֳણ़ीઊ֢ࣼ੭ૂीઊ߸ࠊ൝ઘݴفࣛ
੶ܾടਔԞڹߚਁৰۄ़ी٩ࠊৌӄੌਁفഡࣹٽ
़৺੶QRQYDOYHGSODWHઌ%DHUYHOGWކفࣛ੶ܾടਔԞਁ
੭ણௗஔܾઊҿӘݴࠉਕടؘؘٙߗݼѿگݴ़ઔدӋ
ടਔد&DSULROL-$P-2SKWKDOPRO
요 약